Shelly's profile

Shelly's reviews

  4.9  
Shelly has 107 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, patient, detail-oriented, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Knows her job well
over 4 years ago
Knows her job well

Showed us the house in our range, and kept us abreast of new listings.

Buyer review
Shelly is an incredible real estate agent.
over 4 years ago
Shelly is an incredible real estate agent.

My family and I moved from North Carolina to Savannah recently, and we had the good fortune to have Shelly LaMonica as our real estate agent. She was awesome. Our requirements for a home were very wide-ranging. In all honestly, we were probably unrealistic given the lack of inventory on the market. However, Shelly was not only able to help us find a wonderful home, but she was integral in the negotiation process. In fact, Shelly was there every step of the way to take the pressure off us and to make sure the entire process went as smoothly as possible.

Buyer review
Shelly was consistently helpful and knowledgeable throughout my time working with her
over 4 years ago
Shelly was consistently helpful and knowledgeable throughout my time working with her

Shelly was consistently helpful and knowledgeable throughout my time working with her. I purchased a home with her from out of state and needed someone who knows the area as well as local rules and regulations. She was able to give me answers to all of my questions and did it in a timely manner. Shelly went above and beyond several times during my experience, including making extra time for us while we were in town during a changing closing schedule. I would definitely recommend her to anyone I know!

Buyer review
Great experience working with Shelly!
over 4 years ago
Great experience working with Shelly!

Shelly was consistently helpful and knowledgeable throughout my time working with her. I purchased a home with her from out of state and needed someone who knows the area as well as local rules and regulations. She was able to give me answers to all of my questions and did it in a timely manner. Shelly went above and beyond several times during my experience, including making extra time for us while we were in town during a changing closing schedule. I would definitely recommend her to anyone I know!

Buyer review
Exceptional Shelly was exceptional from start to finish
over 4 years ago
Exceptional Shelly was exceptional from start to finish

Exceptional Shelly was exceptional from start to finish. We'd contacted her from out of state (i.e., she was recommended by friends of ours who'd worked with her on their home purchase) and in spite of being in different time zones we were impressed initially with her responsiveness and guidance, helping us understand the ins and outs and possibilities open to us in Savannah. When we visited the city in person we felt extremely well prepared. Shelly's intimate knowledge of the area and the housing market was a huge asset because, given the time limited nature of our trip, she expertly focused our home search on properties that (a) likely would fit our family's needs and (b) represented a wide range of options so we could discern between criteria. We found the home we LOVED on the first day of hunting and the process moved shockingly smoothly after that. Shelly arranged everything with ease and efficiency, from the initial offer all the way through closing. She responded to minor course corrections with equipoise, transparency and good guidance. We completely trusted her and highly recommend her services. She's professional, personable, and deeply knowledgeable of the housing market. She intuitively understood our needs -- even before we did -- and helped us match them with the best possible housing options. She also has a wide network of colleagues, and provided a pool of resources to guide us through home inspection and other aspects of the purchase and move (i.e., contractors, cleaning services, etc.).

Buyer review
Exceptional
over 4 years ago
Exceptional

Shelly was exceptional from start to finish. We'd contacted her from out of state (i.e., she was recommended by friends of ours who'd worked with her on their home purchase) and in spite of being in different time zones we were impressed initially with her responsiveness and guidance, helping us understand the ins and outs and possibilities open to us in Savannah. When we visited the city in person we felt extremely well prepared. Shelly's intimate knowledge of the area and the housing market was a huge asset because, given the time limited nature of our trip, she expertly focused our home search on properties that (a) likely would fit our family's needs and (b) represented a wide range of options so we could discern between criteria. We found the home we LOVED on the first day of hunting and the process moved shockingly smoothly after that. Shelly arranged everything with ease and efficiency, from the initial offer all the way through closing. She responded to minor course corrections with equipoise, transparency and good guidance. We completely trusted her and highly recommend her services. She's professional, personable, and deeply knowledgeable of the housing market. She intuitively understood our needs -- even before we did -- and helped us match them with the best possible housing options. She also has a wide network of colleagues, and provided a pool of resources to guide us through home inspection and other aspects of the purchase and move (i.e., contractors, cleaning services, etc.).

Buyer review
Great Agent to work with!
over 4 years ago
Great Agent to work with!

Shelly was wonderful to work with! We were first time home buyers in a city we haven’t lived in that long and shelly helped out and made it so easy during a time where the housing market was crazy! We love our home!

Buyer review
I was lucky to find her!
over 4 years ago
I was lucky to find her!

Shelly was very knowlegdeable, professional, and incredibly helpful all the way around.

Buyer review
A wonderful experience!
over 4 years ago
A wonderful experience!

Shelly made the process of buying a home in Savannah an easy experience. Almost everything was done virtually since I don't live in the area yet. She took all the time needed to send me info, do video walk throughs of homes I was interested in, make suggestions, and answer all my questions. She has a friendly, sunny personality which made me feel totally at ease. Thanks so much, Shelly!

Buyer review
Shelly was great
over 4 years ago
Shelly was great

Shelly was willing to put in the emotional investment with my wife and I in order to acquire a house we were absolutely dead set on having. She was patient and open to our letters back and forth with the seller and even took larger financial steps to close the deal for us. We couldn’t be more thankful.

Buyer review
Easy To Work With And Thorough
over 4 years ago
Easy To Work With And Thorough

Shelly made the home buying process very easy. She handled everything in a timely, professional manner and kept me well informed every step of the way.

49 - 60 of 107
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent