Shelli's profile

Shelli's reviews

  5  
Shelli has 74 reviewsacross 38 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelli's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, great listener, supportive, clear communication, patient, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Best experience!
about 2 years ago
Best experience!

Shelli Anderson had so much patience working with us as first time homebuyers in the 2020s crazy home market. She helped us for 3 years find our home, worked so hard to narrow down what would be best for us based on our preferences, and shared her knowledge what we should look for when touring homes. Our favorite phrase being “lipstick on a pig” so we didnt get caught up in the freshness of new paint. She was just overall STELLAR and we even referred her to our friends.

Seller review
The Best Realtor experience thus far!
about 2 years ago
The Best Realtor experience thus far!

Shelli is a great Realtor. She was able to help my husband and I get our old home ready to sell in about 72 hours ( We already had our new home picked out and offer accepted). Through the ups and downs of selling and buying Shelli was patient and knowledgeable. She kept us informed for the whole process.

Buyer review
SHELLI IS THE BEST!
about 2 years ago
SHELLI IS THE BEST!

Shelli helped us buy our first home 3 ish years ago. We loved her so much, when we began looking for our next home, we asked her to help us again. She’s so knowledgeable, kind, and fun. She’s always looking out for your best interest and is readily available. 10/10 quality realtor!

Buyer review
Shelli made this experience easy
about 2 years ago
Shelli made this experience easy

I’m very grateful that Shelli helped us find our very first home 🥹 She was wonderful and very patient. The energy she brought to each time we got together was the cool mom energy that everyone needs in a process like this! We loved you! And thank you so much!

Seller review
Shelli Anderson is the best!
about 2 years ago
Shelli Anderson is the best!

If you want someone personable, dedicated, knowledgeable and will be with you every step of the way, Shelli Anderson is your realtor! From start to finish, Shelli guided me through the stress of preparing and selling my home of 35yrs, finding the perfect family to love it for the next generation.

Seller review
Super Agent
about 2 years ago
Super Agent

Shelly did a remarkable job as my real estate agent. She had a great knowledge of things we needed to do in order to sell the house. The pricing was perfect the experience went very well and even under stressful times she still maintained her steady demeanor.

Buyer review
Best realtor ever!!
over 2 years ago
Best realtor ever!!

I am a first time home buyer and Shelli went above and beyond to help me. She even offered to meet me in down town Indy to help me get the paperwork I needed

Seller review
Shelli Anderson shared her knowledge of real estate and sold our home at the price we wanted.
almost 4 years ago
Shelli Anderson shared her knowledge of real estate and sold our home at the price we wanted.

Shelli Anderson was our realtor when we sold our home. Shelli made herself available whenever we had questions or needed her advice. She was prompt when she returned our calls and handled every aspect of home selling/buying with utmost professionalism. I would not hesitate to recommend Shelli or to use her again for our home buying or selling needs.

Seller review
Thanks for helping us sell our home Shelli!!
almost 4 years ago
Thanks for helping us sell our home Shelli!!

Thanks to Shelli Anderson for alot of hard work and persistence in selling our home even with a shifting market. We appreciate everything you did to make this happen!!

Buyer review
Thanks Shelli!!
almost 4 years ago
Thanks Shelli!!

Thank you Shelli Anderson for helping us along the way to purchase our new home!! We appreciate all of the hard work you put in to getting us in our new home!! It was great working with a long-time friend to see this happen!!

Seller review
Shelli Anderson  was a wonderful agent and made herself available to us for any questions or concern
almost 4 years ago
Shelli Anderson was a wonderful agent and made herself available to us for any questions or concern

Shelli Anderson was a wonderful agent and made herself available to us for any questions or concerns during the sale of our home as well as answers for our new home. She went above and beyond to help us with the detailed paperwork and any help we needed we reached out to her and she answered in a timely manner. I would recommend Shelli for any home selling or buying need.

25 - 36 of 74
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent