Shelby Fifer

Shelby Fifer

  •   5   (9 reviews)

Shelby's sales performance at a glance

See how Shelby has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

5
Reviews
5
Properties for sale
6
Sold properties
$589k
Average sale price
$3.4m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

About Shelby

Shelby is a dedicated real estate professional specializing in residential resale, new construction, and custom home building. She combines market expertise, strong negotiation skills, and a client-first approach to deliver exceptional results for buyers, sellers, and investors at every stage. A Colorado native with deep roots in Golden, Colorado, Shelby brings valuable local insight and a true understanding of the Denver Metro area. As a proud military spouse and boy mom, she knows how meaningful it is to find a place that truly feels like home. Shelby works with a wide range of clients—from first-time homebuyers to seasoned investors—and is passionate about helping each client navigate their unique real estate goals. She offers a well-rounded perspective on the market, including insight into land and the building process, helping clients feel informed and confident as they explore their options. She has hands-on experience in residential resale, guiding clients through pricing, preparation, and negotiations to achieve strong outcomes in a competitive market. With experience in new construction and custom homes, Shelby helps clients understand the process and what to expect along the way. Known for her attention to detail, professionalism, and ability to navigate complex situations, Shelby goes above and beyond to ensure every transaction is smooth and successful. She leverages modern marketing strategies and local expertise to help sellers stand out, while empowering buyers to make confident, informed decisions. Clients appreciate Shelby’s patience, passion, and personalized approach. She especially enjoys working with first-time buyers and finds nothing more rewarding than handing over the keys to their very first home—while also providing a high-touch, refined experience for those seeking higher-end properties. When she’s not working with clients, Shelby enjoys fishing, camping, and traveling throughout Colorado with her family and friends.

Shelby's reviews

  5  
Shelby has 9 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 6.
Review Shelby
Buyer review
Shelby was absolutely key in helping me find my first home!
22 days ago
Shelby was absolutely key in helping me find my first home!

I recommend working with Shelby in the highest regards! From start to finish, she was an incredible advocate for me at every step of the process in buying my first home. She consistently went above and beyond, traveling to Fort Collins without hesitation for showings and always making herself available when I needed guidance or had questions. Shelby held my best interest at the forefront of her mission and genuine commitment to finding the best home for me. She is patient and took the time to understand exactly what I was looking for. Her professionalism, reliability, and dedication made what could have been a stressful process, feel smooth and enjoyable. I always felt like I had someone in my corner and would recommend Shelby to my closest family and friends to guide the adventure of purchasing a home or property!

Seller review
Excellent communicator, quick to follow up, very knowledgeable.
about 1 month ago
Excellent communicator, quick to follow up, very knowledgeable.

Quick to get back to you via email Or phone call. If she doesn’t’ know, she is quick to find the answer. Quick to ease tension, stress/ anxiety, strong communication skills. Highly recommend her if you are selling fast or have a lot of anxiety lol.

Seller review
Shelby is very Polite and Professional, it was a pleasure working with her.
3 months ago
Shelby is very Polite and Professional, it was a pleasure working with her.

Shelby was very prompt in communicating all correspondence and deadlines with us, being very easy to talk with. Seemed to always be working, keeping up with the odd timelines/deadlines of this industry. She is always thinking of new ways to promote your property as necessary. Helping us with our very unique property was an added challenge but took it on without hesitation. Has a vast knowledge of the market, with many resources to pull from. She has a unique understanding and vision of potential for specific properties. I would recommend anyone thinking of selling and/or buying to meet with Shelby.

Seller review
Excellent Realtor
6 months ago
Excellent Realtor

Shelby was amazing to work with in selling my house. I moved to another state for work and depended on Shelby probably more than most home sellers in Colorado will but I can't thank her enough for being available mornings and evenings to answer my questions and providing updates on the sales process. I appreciated her honesty in giving me feedback on the house and what she felt was needed to sell it. Repairs cost money and I told her I trust her advice and will do what is needed to sell. I don't remember the exact date when my house was put on the market with Shelby but it sold relatively quickly. I started with a different realtor and I wasted months on the market until I was connected with Shelby through a coworker. Selling a house is stressful and you don't realize how much a good realtor is worth until you find one like Shelby. I moved for my job but if I ever come back to the Denver area, I will hire Shelby again.

Seller review
Exceeded our expectations!
7 months ago
Exceeded our expectations!

From our first phone call through to closing Shelby was prompt to get to know us, research our market and lay out for us options for moving forward. She was easy to get ahold of and truly went above and beyond to facilitate the sale of our home and move out of state.

Seller review
Cared about what was important to us
about 4 years ago
Cared about what was important to us

When we decided to sell our home last year I thought I knew the agent that we would use. But after I interviewed Shelby I knew she was who we needed to help us achieve our goals. She saw our needs and our dreams, but also helped keep us grounded. Especially as the market shifted. It was a roller coaster. I wanted to throw in the towel more than once, but Shelby believed in us and in the process. She knew what our home was worth and didn't let us give up. She guided us every step of the way. And she made us feel like we were her only clients, meeting every need and fighting for the things that mattered the most to us. Realtors are such a valuable asset when selling a home and the right person matters so much. We could not have asked for a better match for our situation. Shelby is a calming presence and a fierce fighter all in one. Thank you, Shelby for helping us see our dream come true.

Show all 9 reviews
map

Shelby's properties

Shelby has 5 properties for sale and sold 6 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$240,000
Apt 201/7883 Allison Way
Arvada CO 80005
2
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of REMAX Alliance | Arvada
SoldJun 30, 2026
$740,000
15032 West 70th Avenue
Arvada CO 80007
3
4
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REMAX Alliance | Arvada and Compass - Denver
SoldMay 15, 2026
$462,000
1225 Alameda Street
Fort Collins CO 80521
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX ALLIANCE
SoldMay 1, 2026
$860,000
6480 West 60th Avenue
Arvada CO 80003
3
3
5
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Alliance and Your Castle Realty LLC
Show all 11 properties

Shelby's sold properties

Shelby has sold 6 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
15032 West 70th Avenue, Arvada, CO, 80007
15032 West 70th Avenue
Arvada CO 80007
3
4
2
Single-Family$740,000Jun 30, 2026
1225 Alameda Street, Fort Collins, CO, 80521
1225 Alameda Street
Fort Collins CO 80521
3
2
2
Single-Family$462,000May 15, 2026
6480 West 60th Avenue, Arvada, CO, 80003
6480 West 60th Avenue
Arvada CO 80003
3
3
5
Single-Family$860,000May 1, 2026
16321 Orchard Grass Lane, Parker, CO, 80134
16321 Orchard Grass Lane
Parker CO 80134
4
3
2
Single-Family$520,000Apr 15, 2026
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent