Sheila Calistri

Sheila Calistri

Broker Associate at COMPASS FLORIDA, LLC member of Pardo Calistri Group
Broker Associate: 3279207
  •   5   (26 reviews)

About Sheila

A native Floridian and Tampa resident for over two decades, Sheila Calistri is an expert on the local affairs, culture, and lifestyle of the greater Tampa Bay area. With 15 years of experience in real estate, she and Emma Pardo head up the Pardo Calistri Group, a team of seasoned Realtors representing buyers, sellers, and investors in homes and condominiums throughout Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties. Sheila focuses on luxury residential properties in South Tampa, Seminole Heights, New Tampa, Riverview/Brandon, Clearwater, Largo, Seminole, Palm Harbor, Wesley Chapel, Land O' Lakes, and Zephyrhills. A graduate of the University of South Florida with a bachelor’s and master’s degree in business administration, Sheila fell in love with real estate after working as a project manager for a land developer for master-planned communities in Tampa, St. Petersburg, and Pasco County. She combines her extensive business acumen and intimate knowledge of the communities and schools with her passion for helping people find the perfect home. She is motivated by reducing stress and bringing joy to the real estate process, and she is committed to the pursuit of her clients’ goals in order to deliver a seamless and successful buying or selling experience. No matter what your needs are, Sheila will be your advocate from start to end, with the promise of continuing to be a resource even after the transaction is complete. Paired with the powerhouse Compass technology and service offering, including data and analytics software, staging, renovations, and a robust marketing team, Sheila is equipped with top-of-the-line tools and services that facilitate a hassle-free and enjoyable transaction, further elevating the experience of working with her. She utilizes Compass’s contemporary, high-tech marketing tools and materials to generate more awareness, better price points, and faster transactions than ever before, with a single-platform interface that centralizes every aspect of the real estate journey. In a booming market with thriving businesses, quality schools, and an unparalleled lifestyle under the sun, Sheila and her growing team are outstanding resources for clients and families in the Tampa Bay area. She lives in South Tampa with her husband and three children. In her off-time, she enjoys outdoor activities such as running, biking, boating, playing tennis, going to local parks, and going to St. Pete beaches with her family.

Sheila's reviews

  5  
Sheila has 26 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 6.
Review Sheila
over 1 year ago
Experienced, Professional, and Hardworking

I cannot say enough good things about Sheila. Not only did she help us by our home in Riverview, she was also able to help us sell it. Although the circumstances of the sale of our home was unique and extremely difficult being that my husband and I were in the middle of a divorce and due to criminal charges against my husband, we were legally not able to communicate with each other, so Sheila was forced to go back and forth between us to keep the sale of our home moving. Sheila was very knowledgeable during every difficulty we encountered and was understanding and professional throughout the entire process. She was always quick to respond to any questions I had and always notified us of showings and offers as soon as possible. I would use Sheila for every real estate transaction I ever have if I could. She is amazing at her job and maintains a positive attitude even when the situation seems bleak and most importantly, she gets the job done. She will work tirelessly for you and always consults you any time a decision needs to be made. If I could give her a million star review, I absolutely would.

over 1 year ago
Successful first home purchase!

Sheila was always available and helped me throughout the entire home buying process. She is very knowledgeable and has a wide network of industry professionals to help with each detail of the process. I highly recommend Sheila if you are starting the process of home buying in the Tampa Bay area

almost 2 years ago
The process was swift and painless. It kept moving forward

It was evident from the start Sheila had experience, therefore she was confident while helping me navigate my first-time home-buying journey. Through Sheila, I felt I was able to openly communicate any questions and concerns - whether they were for her or the seller, she got back to me on moments notice with the answers. The true value I noticed throughout our professional relationship was that I found plenty peace of mind. This process is supposed to be stressful - although there were times I found myself full of wonder and questions, I had no doubt everything would come together smoothly. It was because having Sheila, who is a true professional, this process was seamless. Thank you Sheila for constantly being at my wing and lending wonderful advice. I would not have landed the cozy spot I can now call home if not for her and her dedication to being the best she can be.

almost 2 years ago
Top realtor qualities

Sheila is a diligent, personable, and doesn’t take “no” for an answer agent. She puts her heart into her work and is an absolute shark for finding those properties. She showed up with listings and conducted separate school ratings as this was #1 on my list. I’ve worked with many realtors in the past, and not many have the motivation Sheila does. She got me and my family into our first home after shopping for 2.5 years. Highly recommend.

almost 2 years ago
Selling with ease and confidence!

Sheila is amazing! She gave me and my husband the confidence we needed to sell our home and ended up getting a great price. We felt secure before, during and after the sale. I highly recommend Sheila to my family and friends.

almost 4 years ago
A Smooth and Seamless Real Estate Purchase through Sheila

It was great working with Sheila. We bought our house site-unseen and from out of state, and the process was so much smoother than I thought it would be due to Sheila’s instincts on what we would like in a home and her knowledge of the Tampa area. In addition, Sheila understands the real estate market and how it trends and therefore offered expert advice on what a solid and fair purchase offer looks like. She really walked us through everything. I highly recommend Sheila!

Show all 26 reviews

Sheila's properties

Sheila has 12 properties for sale and sold 8 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$425,000
7402 S Germer St
Tampa FL 33616
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of COMPASS FLORIDA LLC
For Sale
$320,000
3301 N 12th St
Tampa FL 33605
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of BHHS FLORIDA PROPERTIES GROUP
For Sale
$450,000
5215 Southwest 125th Circle
Gainesville FL 32618
Land
Listing courtesy of BHHS FLORIDA PROPERTIES GROUP
SoldFeb 3, 2026
$575,000
4954 Cardinal Trail
Palm Harbor FL 34683
5
4
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 BEGGINS and COMPASS FLORIDA LLC
Show all 20 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent