Sarah Sutfin

Sarah Sutfin

REALTOR® / CIPS / CRS at Compass RE Texas, LLC
Texas Realtor: 0544289
  •   5   (6 reviews)

About Sarah

From her genuine smile to her focus on outstanding client-services, Sarah Sutfin’s enthusiasm for the Central Texas real estate market is contagious. With more than 21 years of residential real estate experience, Sarah has helped her clients buy a wide variety of properties. From downtown condos to homes with acreage, and from Lake Austin waterfront properties to homes with Texas-sized views, Sarah is uniquely qualified to help international, out-of-state and local buyer’s find their dream home. In any scenario, Sarah believes that buying a home is a unique process and she considers it a privilege to walk alongside each client. She has an innate desire to listen to and understand the wishes of her clients and forging a long-lasting relationship with them is a top priority for Sarah. Growing up in Cincinnati, Ohio, Sarah worked in the family business: sausage making. As a fourth-generation German sausage maker’s daughter, Sarah learned the most important business basics from her dad: treat people with respect, offer a product that exceeds expectations, and enjoy what you do. Working with international business and government visitors, Sarah’s mother was equally influential, and taught Sarah more about an appreciation for additional cultures and stories beyond her hometown. Before becoming a Realtor® in 2005, Sarah spent almost a decade in the marketing industry working on campaigns for Dallas Magazine, the Disney Channel, and several advertising agencies in Indianapolis, Indiana. Apart from her welcoming, professional, and determined demeanor, Sarah’s clients benefit from her exceptional marketing expertise and her strategic ingenuity. Sarah is also passionate about spending time with her family. Hiking Austin’s beautiful trails is a favorite activity with her husband, kids, and grandkids. Sarah also loves photography, live music, architecture, travel, and Kentucky basketball (March Madness is her favorite time of the year!). She is also board member for the Nicaragua Resource Network—a faith-based, nonprofit organization that serves the educational, spiritual, physical, and medical needs of impoverished children and families in Nicaragua. By hiring Sarah, you’re choosing to work with a gracious, patient, and dedicated agent who will assist you with the buying process. Keeping a finger on the market’s pulse is also a top priority for Sarah in Austin’s dynamic and competitive market. Sarah’s reputation precedes her. She is a Certified International Property Specialist and is recognized in the top 4% of Realtors®. She is also a Residential Real Estate Council member with access to up-to-the-minute details on significant market updates and trends. Sarah provides an atmosphere of peacefulness, joy, and care as she walks clients through the buying process. Sarah believes that working with buyers is a joy and privilege, and she is always honored to be part of her buyer’s homeownership journey. Professional Designations: Certified International Property Specialist (CIPS) Residential Real Estate Council (RRC) Accredited Buyer’s Representative (ABR) Real Estate Member Affiliations: Austin Board of Realtors Dallas Board of Realtors San Antonio Board of Realtors Texas Realtors National Association of Realtors

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 6 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 6.
Review Sarah
about 2 months ago
Extremely knowledgeable and very responsive

Working with Sarah Sutfin was a great experience from start to finish. As newcomers to Austin, we especially appreciated how she guided us through the different neighborhoods and helped us find the right fit for our lifestyle. She was knowledgeable, responsive, and truly listened to what we were looking for. Her patience and attention to detail made the entire home buying process smooth and stress-free. We would highly recommend Sarah to anyone buying or selling a home.

3 months ago
Provided A Comprehensive Service

Sarah's guidance on preparing my home for photos and potential buyers was spot on, a nice mix of fewer personal items but not the barren look. Attractive signs were made and placed throughout the home that pointed out key selling features which other agents don't often bother to read in the listing and are not always obvious. Her decorating skills with changes, arrangements, and added plants were valuable and fun and many I've repeated in my new home. Sarah doesn't just list your home (paperwork). She knows what is needed for photography to showcase the home's key selling features which led to rearrangements of art work, shifting area rugs, furniture, and decorative objects, plus sending large speakers and the treadmill to the garage. Sarah was straightforward in her analysis of the current market, even suggested the option of waiting to list. She was accurate on pricing, yet flexible when I wanted to try a higher price. I appreciated her talks with the buyer's agent that led to a quick sale in a not great market. I've bought and sold many homes and in many cities and market conditions; the process from start to finish with Sarah was exceedingly positive, creative, comprehensive, and professional. She doesn't just stick a sign in your yard, have a few photos taken, and hope for the best.

7 months ago
All around great experience!

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Sarah Sutfin as our real estate agent when selling our Texas home, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience. Sarah is incredibly personable, easy to work with, and brought a genuine passion for helping us through every step of the process. She has an excellent eye for staging and guided us with thoughtful suggestions that made our home shine. Communication was always clear and consistent — she explained everything thoroughly and kept us updated so we always knew where we were in the process. What truly set Sarah apart was the way she went above and beyond, especially after we moved out of state before the sale was complete. She made sure everything was taken care of and gave us such peace of mind from afar. Working with Sarah was an absolute pleasure, and I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a dedicated, knowledgeable, and caring real estate agent.

7 months ago
Sarah Sutfin is awesome....

We had such a great experience working with Sarah in finding our new home in Georgetown, Texas. From the very beginning, she truly listened to what we wanted and, amazingly, found us the perfect home within just a week. She quickly understood our priorities and even thought of things we hadn’t considered, which made the whole process smooth and stress-free. Sarah was always responsive to our questions, no matter how big or small, and her local market knowledge was invaluable. She also connected us with trusted contractors we’ve already used before and after closing, which made the transition into our new home much easier. Moving to Georgetown could have felt overwhelming, but Sarah made it such a positive experience. She didn’t just find us a home—she welcomed us to the community. She listened to what we wanted, found us the perfect house in no time, and answered every question with patience and care. More than anything, Sarah became our first friend here, and we feel so lucky to have met her.

almost 2 years ago
Incredibly Dedicated and Kind A+++!

Sarah was absolutely lovely. She was very dedicated and motivated to help us find the perfect home. She was honest and very caring. This was my first home and my parents live across the country and Sarah filled me with confidence and had a motherly touch to her assistance. I found great comfort and trust in working with Sarah. I would encourage anyone to work with her. She worked day and night to make sure we got complete satisfaction with our home and I am very beyond happy with the home we chose. I highly encourage you to work with Sarah if you want someone hard working, honest, caring; who will definitely exceed your expectations. Thank you, Sarah! I am forever grateful and will recommend you to any of my friends looking to buy homes in the future! A+++++!

almost 2 years ago
Best Agent Ever

My wife and I relocated for work and Sarah was a blessing. We had a newborn and redid our floors all at the same time and I do not think that I could have kept my sanity without the help of Sarah. She made the whole process smooth and simple for our family and we cannot thank her enough.

Sarah's properties

Sarah has 2 properties for sale and sold 8 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$315,000
145/12224 Tawny Farms Rd
Austin TX 78748
2
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of Compass RE Texas, LLC
SoldMar 3, 2026
Price not available
14/1719 Spyglass Drive
Austin TX 78746
3
4
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Compass RE Texas, LLC
SoldFeb 12, 2026
Price not available
811 Saratoga Lane
Georgetown TX 78633
2
2
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Compass RE Texas, LLC and Keller Williams Realty Lone St
SoldFeb 11, 2026
Price not available
531 Deer Meadow Circle
Georgetown TX 78633
3
2
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Stacy Group, LLC and Compass RE Texas, LLC
Show all 10 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent