Sarah Prystupa

Sarah Prystupa

CO: 100052522
  •   5   (17 reviews)

Sarah's sales performance at a glance

See how Sarah has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

2
Reviews
0
Properties for sale
3
Sold properties
$307k
Average sale price
$1.2m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About Sarah

As a Colorado native with deep roots in Arvada, I’m proud to help people navigate one of life’s biggest transitions—buying or selling a home. My journey from Metro State University to studying abroad in Costa Rica and New Zealand has shaped my appreciation for community, culture, and connection, and those values guide every client relationship. With over four decades in the Denver metro area, I bring deep local knowledge, thoughtful strategy, and a calm, steady approach to each transaction. From first-time buyers to long-time homeowners planning what comes next, my focus is always on clarity, confidence, and results. Now with Market Masters Real Estate, I’m proud to deliver an experience rooted in integrity and intention—mastering the art of service by putting people first, listening carefully, and tailoring each plan to what matters most to you. Real estate isn’t just about property—it’s about building a life that fits. I’d be honored to help guide you home.

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 17 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 6.
Review Sarah
Sarah's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, supportive, responsive, detail-oriented, honest, friendly, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Excellent experience all around. Sarah is great at what she does.
about 1 month ago
Excellent experience all around. Sarah is great at what she does.

We had a fantastic experience with Sarah and highly recommend her. She was always responsive, listened well to our initial criteria and feedback on properties, made house hunting fun, and she was so patient with all of our questions and walked us through each step, helping us understand the process. What I appreciated the most was that she encouraged us to find the perfect home for us: to not settle and to go with our hearts and intuition. She said we'd know when it was the right one, and we did! Sarah really goes the extra mile to connect with her clients and takes to heart that looking for a home is a big deal and not just a business transaction. We never felt rushed or pushed, and in fact, Sarah would ask us great questions and give helpful insight to help us make decisions. We felt truly cared for and were guided well by Sarah. Her extensive market knowledge was very appreciated in a tough market, and her negotiation skills and professionalism are top notch.

Buyer review
An amazing journey together
about 2 months ago
An amazing journey together

Working with Sarah Prystupa as my real estate agent was truly an incredible experience from start to finish. I went into the home search not really knowing exactly what I wanted, but Sarah made the entire journey feel easy, exciting, and stress-free. She did an amazing job showing me a wide variety of options—from condos and townhouses to homes with large yards—helping me explore possibilities I hadn’t even considered. Her knowledge of the real estate market is outstanding, and she consistently helped me avoid potential pitfalls by pointing out issues I would have never noticed on my own. What really stood out was her attention to detail. Sarah was extremely thorough when reviewing contracts and HOA documents, making sure I fully understood everything and felt confident in every decision. Thanks to her dedication, patience, and expertise, I found my dream home. I am beyond grateful for her guidance and would highly recommend Sarah to anyone looking to buy a home!

Buyer review
A True Advocate!
over 2 years ago
A True Advocate!

Sarah, was amazing in our home search. We have worked with Sarah on an off for 4 years as we looked to find the perfect house for our family. Sarah was great in understanding our wants and needs, as well as preparing us for a challenging market. While the search took some time, it was really a matter of not settling, and she was amazing at understanding this, and working with us. We finally found the right home, and Sarah's network of lenders, and inspectors worked quickly to get us to the closing table in under 30 days! I would absolutely recommend Sarah to help any buyer in their search, as she is friendly, funny, compassionate, and diligent in finding the perfect home.

Seller review
Absolutely Amazing!
over 2 years ago
Absolutely Amazing!

The first time we worked with Sarah was 3/2020, the world had shut down and we decided to buy a house. Even though things in the world were crazy Sarah was always there to figure it out. We than referred our son to her, she was amazing helping his young family find their very first home. Most recently my father passed away after living in his house for 47 years. After getting the house cleared out, it needed some up-dates and renovation. Sarah was there to help us decided what was worth doing and what we should leave. She also helped us through a few surprises along the way and dealing with the renovation team. She was an advocate for everything I did and always there to help with the hard stuff. She will walk you through every step and talk you through the options, even listen to the family drama that comes with it. I would recommend Sarah to anyone looking for a home. She is very honest, she knows the metro area and will work to find you the perfect home. She is also wonderful with the sales end. She will help get your home ready for the market, help with suggestions on pricing and the reasons she has for the recommendations. She sold both of our homes quickly and at a fair price. I will call her anytime I need a realtor, maybe sooner than she knows.

Buyer review
Sarah is an amazing Realtor who goes above and beyond!
over 2 years ago
Sarah is an amazing Realtor who goes above and beyond!

Sarah was so knowledgeable, helpful and willing to do whatever I needed with this purchase! We looked a a ton of houses and she never said "no" when I called to say I wanted to schedule another showing. When I fell in love with this home, so helped me understand the process, what I should do to help my offer stand out, and then kept everything moving along once we were under contract - she called in a roofing specialist at the last minute to help with the inspection, arranged for a sewer scope when that might have been a roadblock, provided great guidance and advice, and was just generally a wonderful person to work with and an amazing partner during this stressful time. This is the second home I've purchased with Sarah's help, and I highly recommend working with her!

Buyer review
We have the BEST Realtor!
over 2 years ago
We have the BEST Realtor!

Sarah is an exceptional realtor and person. I highly recommend her and we were fortunate to have her as our realtor. She went above and beyond she promptly responded to every message even when she was out of town. She is an expert and informed us of the pros and cons of properties. We are very happy with our home and are glad we found the right place for our family.

Show all 17 reviews
map

Sarah's properties

Sarah has sold 3 properties in the last 12 months, showing 3, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMar 13, 2026
$517,496
# B/5890 Holland Court
Arvada CO 80002
3
3
2
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of MARKET MASTERS REAL ESTATE
SoldMar 6, 2026
$397,000
10481 Emerson Street
Northglenn CO 80233
3
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Northwest and MARKET MASTERS REAL ESTATE
SoldJan 6, 2026
$307,000
APT 13/1001 East 17th Avenue
Denver CO 80218
1
1
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of MARKET MASTERS REAL ESTATE
Show all 3 properties

Sarah's sold properties

Sarah has sold 3 properties in the past 12 months, showing 3.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
# B/5890 Holland Court, Arvada, CO, 80002
# B/5890 Holland Court
Arvada CO 80002
3
3
2
Townhouse$517,496Mar 13, 2026
10481 Emerson Street, Northglenn, CO, 80233
10481 Emerson Street
Northglenn CO 80233
3
2
1
Single-Family$397,000Mar 6, 2026
APT 13/1001 East 17th Avenue, Denver, CO, 80218
APT 13/1001 East 17th Avenue
Denver CO 80218
1
1
1
Condo$307,000Jan 6, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent