Sarah's profile

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 131 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sarah's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, detail-oriented, supportive, well-prepared, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Sarah is the Mayor of Hernando Beach!
about 1 year ago
Sarah is the Mayor of Hernando Beach!

Just purchased a house with Sarah’s help in Hernando Beach South. If you’re new to the area and looking to relocate there - Sarah is the only agent for you. Being born and raised in Hernando Beach she has a connection to anyone and knows someone for anything you might need done. Being out of state, Sarah went above and beyond in every aspect of the sell, inspections and closing. She always had my best interest in mind when negotiating with the other agents and ensured everything was done correctly since the Florida laws are different than the Texas laws where I’m coming from.

Seller review
Above and Beyond Real Estate Agent
about 1 year ago
Above and Beyond Real Estate Agent

Sarah is a superior real estate agent who provides truly personalized and expert service. Sarah is a true leader in her field, she made the sale of my home far less stressful, achieving very positive and timely results. Her knowledge, hard work, and no-nonsense approach make her a trusted professional who partners closely with her clients. Sarah is highly organized and she communicates effectively (returns calls and texts)–she takes the time to explain even the smallest detail, and she keeps her clients well informed throughout the process. On a personal note, Sarah went above and beyond for me. As an out-of-state owner selling a home after the loss of a parent, I was deeply grateful for her care and compassion. She handled nearly everything on my behalf, easing what could have been a very difficult experience. I am thankful to have met Sarah and to have been her client. She exceeded all my expectations and proved herself to be not only an outstanding real estate agent, but she's also an exceptional person.

Seller review
Couldn't have been better
about 1 year ago
Couldn't have been better

From start to finish, Sarah showed why she is one one the top realtors in the area. She is personable, knowledgeable and honest. She know the market better than anyone else! She stayed on top of everything, and kept us up to date.

Seller review
Sara was very professional.
about 1 year ago
Sara was very professional.

Sara is very knowledgeable, she assisted us through many important decisions. She communicated with clarity and sound advise on what the buyers realtor request were so we could make informed decisions. Thank you Sarah

Buyer review
Top Notch Realtor
about 1 year ago
Top Notch Realtor

After connecting with a couple other local agents, I reached out to Sarah based on previous reviews. From the moment that we began dealing with Sarah on the purchase of a home, it was evident that she deserved a 5 star rating or more! Sarah's knowledge of the local market, building codes, 50/50 rules was second to none. She ensured we made the right decisions in choosing a home and was an excellent source of information and always available to answer any of our questions and concerns. We felt so confident in Sarah's knowledge and guidance that we ended up purchasing two homes and closed on the same day. I'm not sure this would have occurred if we used any other realtor. In closing I would highly recommend that you reach out to Sarah with any of your real estate needs in Hernando Beach!

Seller review
Outstanding Service from Start to Finish!
about 1 year ago
Outstanding Service from Start to Finish!

Sarah was an absolute pleasure to work with! From our very first meeting to the final closing, she kept us informed, answered every question with patience, and guided us through the process with ease. Her professionalism, attention to detail, and friendly demeanor made selling our home a truly stress-free experience. We especially valued her deep knowledge of the Hernando Beach area, which, paired with her warmth and personal touch, made all the difference. We’re so grateful for her hard work and highly recommend Sarah to anyone buying or selling a home! 🔑 🏡

Buyer review
Goes the extra mile
about 1 year ago
Goes the extra mile

Sarah has wealth of knowledge. She walked us step by step in the process of buying our property. She communicated every step of the way. She went above and beyond to help us find the right place for us, giving us all the tools to make good decisions. I am so grateful to have found her.

Buyer review
Wonderful experience!
about 1 year ago
Wonderful experience!

Sarah is so kind and knowledgeable. She is very attentive and on top of everything. She explained every email that we received and made us feel very comfortable about the whole buying experience. We could go to her with any questions that we had and she responded right away. We will definitely go to her again with any of our buying or selling needs! Thanks Sarah!

Seller review
Sarah Hill - such a great experience having Sarah sell our house - she is definitely the best!
about 1 year ago
Sarah Hill - such a great experience having Sarah sell our house - she is definitely the best!

Sarah definitely had the market knowledge to sell our house and in a very short time. She was always courteous, professional and easily reached for any questions we had. Sarah always kept us up to date on everything happening with our sale. I highly recommend Sarah to anyone looking to sell their house or to buy a house. You will not be disappointed using Sarah as your realtor!!!

Seller review
Sarah is the Best!
about 1 year ago
Sarah is the Best!

When you want the best....go with Sarah Hill. From the first conversation that I had with her, I knew she would be our realtor. Sarah presented herself well...showing her professionalism, market knowledge, fun personality, and high energy. She gave honest advice and worked with us, not against us. Sarah is able to communicate and negotiate effectively. She was available at any moment for questions, excellent follow-through skills, and delivered a positive outcome. From start to finish, she made selling our home easy and stress free! If you are looking to sell your home, she will do it. If you are looking to buy, she will find you the right house. Sarah is a joy to work with, and I highly recommend her.

Seller review
Sarah did a fantastic job
about 1 year ago
Sarah did a fantastic job

It was an absolute pleasure working with Sarah. She was always prompt with communication and helped with the little "fix it" items that come up at inspection. The marketing was top notch and very professional.

Buyer review
A True Local Expert with Unmatched Dedication and Professionalism
about 1 year ago
A True Local Expert with Unmatched Dedication and Professionalism

Working with Sarah Hill was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. She is hands down the most knowledgeable real estate agent I’ve ever encountered. Sarah grew up in Hernando Beach and it shows — she knows every local contractor, painter, plumber, and business in the area, which made the entire home-buying process smooth and efficient. She was incredibly accessible, always just a call or text away, and her communication skills are top-notch. She kept me informed at every step, and I never once felt lost or out of the loop. What stood out the most was how much she genuinely cared — her top priority was making sure I was happy and confident in my decision. Sarah is also unafraid to give her honest opinion, which I appreciated immensely. She’s not just trying to close a deal — she’s there to make sure you make the right decision, even if that means pushing back (professionally) on something you might not have considered. Her market knowledge, professionalism, and commitment to her clients make her the kind of real estate agent everyone deserves but rarely finds. If you’re considering buying or selling in Hernando Beach or nearby, do yourself a favor and call Sarah Hill. You won’t regret it.

49 - 60 of 131
© 2026 RateMyAgent