Sarah's profile

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 114 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sarah's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, detail-oriented, supportive, well-prepared, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Amazing experience! Will recommend to anyone looking to buy.
5 months ago
Amazing experience! Will recommend to anyone looking to buy.

We loved working with Sarah. From start to finish she was amazing. She will walk every property with you, show you things that you might miss, show you the good, the bad, everything. She will make sure you get exactly what you want, and more! We will recommend her to anyone who needs to purchase a property. Thank you Sarah for helping us find our perfect property!

Buyer review
Sarah is the Best!
5 months ago
Sarah is the Best!

This is my 5th property with Sarah. She does an excellent job!

Buyer review
SARAH WAS ONE OF THE MOST PROFESSIONAL AGENTS I HAVE EVER DEALT WITH,
6 months ago
SARAH WAS ONE OF THE MOST PROFESSIONAL AGENTS I HAVE EVER DEALT WITH,

I CALLED SARAH FROM THE HOUSE LOCATION AND SHE MET WITH ME RIGHT AWAY, WALKED ME THRU THE PROPERTY, INSPECTING FROM GARAGE TO LIVING AREA TO OUTSIDE, VERY EASY TO DEAL WITH AND WALKED ME THRU THE PROCESS ASAP TO FINALIZE THE DEAL BEFORE I LEFT. THANK YOU SARAH FOR A WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE.

Seller review
An Absolute Professional
7 months ago
An Absolute Professional

If you value competence, speed, professionalism and results you can't do better than Sarah. She gained my trust and started working very hard and amazingly fast from day one. We closed in record time. Nobody could believe it! Any now I'm happily moving on to the next chapter of my life. Highly recommended!

Seller review
Nature Coast #1 Realtor
7 months ago
Nature Coast #1 Realtor

I can’t say enough great things about Sarah Hill! She is truly the most knowledgeable and dedicated realtor on the Nature Coast. As a native to the area, Sarah knows every neighborhood, waterway, and hidden gem — and that local insight made all the difference when it came to selling our home in Hernando Beach. From the very beginning, Sarah impressed us with her professionalism and attention to detail. She took the time to explain every step of the process, helped us prepare our home to show its best, and priced it perfectly for the market. Thanks to her expertise and marketing skills, our home sold in record time — and for a fantastic price! What really sets Sarah apart, though, is her personal touch. She doesn’t just treat you like another client — she treats you like family. She genuinely cares about the people she works with, always making sure we felt comfortable, informed, and supported throughout the entire process. Her communication was excellent; she was always available to answer questions, offer guidance, and celebrate the milestones along the way. Sarah is caring, incredibly smart, and truly passionate about what she does. If you’re buying or selling on the Nature Coast, you couldn’t ask for a better realtor or advocate. We’re so grateful for everything she did for us — Sarah Hill is simply the best!

Buyer review
Could not have been a better experience
7 months ago
Could not have been a better experience

I met Sarah at an open house and quickly realized that her knowledge of the of the community, coastal home construction, insurance considerations, and all things to do with Florida waterfront living was well beyond that of the agents I previously met. After meeting with her a couple of more times she inspired my trust to represent me for an out of state home purchase. The home she found for me is a perfect fit, she negotiated a great price, her contacts for inspections and insurance were great, her extended contacts for maintenance and remodeling have been easy to work with, and the closing was incredibly smooth. My home buying experience with Sarah could not have been better!

Seller review
Hernando's Best
8 months ago
Hernando's Best

Sarah just helped me sell another house. She’s the best in the business and knows Hernando and the weeki area like the back of her hand. There’s no one better so don’t look any further, she’s the one for you.

Buyer review
Sarah is the Mayor of Hernando Beach!
8 months ago
Sarah is the Mayor of Hernando Beach!

Just purchased a house with Sarah’s help in Hernando Beach South. If you’re new to the area and looking to relocate there - Sarah is the only agent for you. Being born and raised in Hernando Beach she has a connection to anyone and knows someone for anything you might need done. Being out of state, Sarah went above and beyond in every aspect of the sell, inspections and closing. She always had my best interest in mind when negotiating with the other agents and ensured everything was done correctly since the Florida laws are different than the Texas laws where I’m coming from.

Seller review
Above and Beyond Real Estate Agent
8 months ago
Above and Beyond Real Estate Agent

Sarah is a superior real estate agent who provides truly personalized and expert service. Sarah is a true leader in her field, she made the sale of my home far less stressful, achieving very positive and timely results. Her knowledge, hard work, and no-nonsense approach make her a trusted professional who partners closely with her clients. Sarah is highly organized and she communicates effectively (returns calls and texts)–she takes the time to explain even the smallest detail, and she keeps her clients well informed throughout the process. On a personal note, Sarah went above and beyond for me. As an out-of-state owner selling a home after the loss of a parent, I was deeply grateful for her care and compassion. She handled nearly everything on my behalf, easing what could have been a very difficult experience. I am thankful to have met Sarah and to have been her client. She exceeded all my expectations and proved herself to be not only an outstanding real estate agent, but she's also an exceptional person.

Seller review
Couldn't have been better
9 months ago
Couldn't have been better

From start to finish, Sarah showed why she is one one the top realtors in the area. She is personable, knowledgeable and honest. She know the market better than anyone else! She stayed on top of everything, and kept us up to date.

Seller review
Sara was very professional.
9 months ago
Sara was very professional.

Sara is very knowledgeable, she assisted us through many important decisions. She communicated with clarity and sound advise on what the buyers realtor request were so we could make informed decisions. Thank you Sarah

Buyer review
Top Notch Realtor
9 months ago
Top Notch Realtor

After connecting with a couple other local agents, I reached out to Sarah based on previous reviews. From the moment that we began dealing with Sarah on the purchase of a home, it was evident that she deserved a 5 star rating or more! Sarah's knowledge of the local market, building codes, 50/50 rules was second to none. She ensured we made the right decisions in choosing a home and was an excellent source of information and always available to answer any of our questions and concerns. We felt so confident in Sarah's knowledge and guidance that we ended up purchasing two homes and closed on the same day. I'm not sure this would have occurred if we used any other realtor. In closing I would highly recommend that you reach out to Sarah with any of your real estate needs in Hernando Beach!

25 - 36 of 114
© 2026 RateMyAgent