Sarah Fye

Sarah Fye

  •   5   (13 reviews)

About Sarah

Meet me, Sarah Fye, your dedicated real estate expert and friend with a vibe as sunny as Arizona itself! Combine my insight on market dynamics and expertise in projecting investment revenue with my down-to-earth Midwest roots and you have found the perfect blend to help you achieve your real estate dreams. My mission is to make the complex aspects of real estate accessible to everyone and easy to understand- all while having fun! After lighting up the real estate scene in Orlando in 2003 then obtaining my Arizona license in 2021, I am a pro at finding clients their dream home or perfect investment, while keeping things like Return on Investment and other financial terms easy to understand. My clients seeking a primary residence have expressed their appreciation of my “investor” mindset as I point out items to consider for resale, because let’s be honest, we aren’t buying “forever” homes very often! My genuine concern for my clients has led to my consistent ranking among top agents, including a spot in the top 100 of 10,000 agents in Orlando and in the top 2,200 of 55,000 Arizona agents in 2023. As a proud member of the prestigious Russ Lyon Sotheby's International Realty, I specialize in Scottsdale and surrounding areas with a focus on helping clients buy, sell and 1031 exchange investment properties. Creating custom pro formas to help meet investment goals is a true passion of mine. My commitment goes beyond transactions, creating lasting relationships and having clients become my friends is pure joy for me! When I’m not out hustling for my clients, you can find me hiking our scenic trails, enjoying lake days with my hubby & friends and enjoying meals on sunny patios, I truly represent the vibrant Arizona lifestyle. Let me guide your journey to homeownership or investment success. Reach out and let’s bring your real estate dreams to life, with plenty of Arizona sunshine along the way!

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 13 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 6.
Review Sarah
over 1 year ago
This REALTOR is full of enthusiasm, courage and determination!!

My husband and I met Sarah for the first time at one of her listings back in Jan, 2024. We asked her to work with us and she gracefully accepted. After looking at over 20 homes together over the next 3 months, offering on a few, finally finding "the one" on March 28, making an offer and then the listing agent canceled the listing. Sarah tracked down the owner via her lender because she was in foreclosure but she wouldn't return calls. And then we saw it was listed again by another real estate agent so Sarah submitted our offer and we were under contract. Unfortunately while we were under contract, the lender foreclosed on the seller. Since Sarah had already been in communication with him previously she was able to get us in contract with him! During all this we were working with an attorney Sarah referred us to to work through the city zoning restrictions for assisted living facilities for this property. Once we got the approval from the city we were able to do our home inspection (Sarah advised we waited on this so we didn't spend money unnecessarily). So we finally closed on Monday, 08/26. We are incredibly grateful for Sarah's unwavering commitment to us for the past 8 months to help us strategize and get exactly what we wanted! We are definately grateful for your determination to hang in there with us, for your constant encouragement. There were days when it felt like nothing was going our way and the feeling of giving up steps in, but you've always been encouraging. Thank you Sarah! We are lifelong clients of yours for sure.

almost 2 years ago
Absolute Star!

Sarah was amazing! She was completely professional, knowledgeable and extremely helpful. She went above and beyond our expectations and it was a true pleasure to work with her. I would absolutely recommend her as an agent and would work with her again if the need arises.

about 2 years ago
A real estate agent with all of the qualities you want your agent to have.

Sarah is an all around outstanding real estate agent. She is truly the best I have ever experienced. Not only is she a wonderful person—patient, kind, and honest—she also has excellent communication skills and will work tirelessly to resolve any issues that arise. She will go above and beyond to make sure you are happy, comfortable, and satisified during the purchase process. We will choose Sarah for any future purchases or sales, and will miss working with her in the meantime!

about 2 years ago
Professional, knowledgeable, precise, and moves fast!

I wanted a property with in a particular area that I could improve and move into then have options for the future for a good return. Sarah was able to find me something and from first look to close was less than 30 days. She was a pleasure to work with and I will do business with her again and again.

over 2 years ago
Goes the extra mile!

I had a great experience working with Sarah. As an out of state owner of a rental property doing an unconventional sale, I needed a lot more help than usual and she regularly went above and beyond expectations. Would recommend!

over 2 years ago
Sarah's Great

Our real estate agent Kevin referred us to Sarah as we are out of state and didn't know who to turn to. We are so happy that he found the right person for the job. I was helping my sister with the sale of her condo and Sarah made sure to include me on all communication which was very important to us. She was very knowledgeable and always available to answer our questions. She even scheduled a housekeeper to get it cleaned for us prior to showings! Once we started receiving offers (lots of low ones!), Sarah advised us to sit tight and that she was confident we would get a full price offer. Sure enough, we got 2! The one we went with ended up backing out a couple days later and Sarah hustled to get the other one back in play and under contract the same day. What a relief! We highly recommended entrusting Sarah with your next real estate transaction, we would definitively work with her again!

Show all 13 reviews

Sarah's properties

Sarah has 2 properties for sale and sold 13 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 20, 2026
$736,800
2422 North 74th Street
Scottsdale AZ 85257
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of AIG Realty LLC and Russ Lyon Sotheby's International Realty
SoldApr 15, 2026
$350,000
205/3640 North 38th Street
Phoenix AZ 85018
2
2
1
Apartment
Listing courtesy of The Brokery and Russ Lyon Sotheby's International Realty
SoldMar 30, 2026
$2,390,000
6541 East 2nd Street
Scottsdale AZ 85251
6
6
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HomeSmart and Russ Lyon Sotheby's International Realty
For Sale
$585,000
UNIT 62/4525 N 66th St
Scottsdale AZ 85251
3
2
2
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of Russ Lyon Sotheby's International Realty
Show all 15 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent