Nathan's profile

Nathan's reviews

  5  
Nathan has 31 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nathan's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Always knowledgable and responsive!
over 1 year ago
Always knowledgable and responsive!

I've been working with Nathan for 20 years and he's helped me buy and sell several homes. He's alway a pleasure to work with. If he doesn't know an answer, he'll find it. Plus, he's patient with my indecisiveness and desire to look at 100 homes before I buy one. Highly recommend Nathan!

Seller review
Reliable when it matters
almost 2 years ago
Reliable when it matters

We didn’t realize we had purchased a very needy house during the Covid Pandemic until it all began to hit us two years later. We decided to do our best to fix up the place as much as we could afford before moving on. Nathan entered the picture and helped us every step of the way, and through much frustration and many curveballs over the course of a whole year, we finally found a family who was willing to buy. We couldn’t have done it without Nathan!

Buyer review
Great Experience!!
almost 2 years ago
Great Experience!!

Nathan was great to work with. I told him what my priorities were and dialed in searches that matched. He guided me through the offer process and helped out through the closing. The whole process went as smoothly as could reasonably be expected.

Seller review
A fantastic realtor! Extremely smooth process!
almost 2 years ago
A fantastic realtor! Extremely smooth process!

Nathan is a professional in the true sense of the word. From the very beginnings, of finding a realtor all the way through the process until the closing, Nathan makes everything so easy! He is very professional and will make the process as streamlined and simple as possible. I highly recommend Nathan if you are looking for a realtor to buy or sell your home.

Seller review
Wonderful Experience
almost 2 years ago
Wonderful Experience

Nathan is the real deal and always goes the extra mile. He genuinely cares for his clients and I felt like he kept a keen eye out to protect me from making a poor decision. He knows the Brownsburg (and surrounding) markets extremely well. Thanks Nathan!

Buyer review
Could not ask for a better agent!
almost 2 years ago
Could not ask for a better agent!

Nathan Pfahler was amazing to work with! I have purchased several homes in the past, but this was the first time going through the process on my own. Nathan was extremely patient with me and answered all of my questions quickly and sometimes multiple times! One of the qualities I was most impressed with was the speed in which Nathan would respond to my request to view a home. If you are looking for a new home right now, you know you have to move fast. When I would contact Nathan with a property I was interested in, he immediately went to work to get an appointment set up to see the home. Nathan also has great recommendations on the other professionals you need to work with to complete your home buying team. I don't have any plans to buy a home again anytime soon, but when I do, I will absolutely be contacting Nathan Pfahler.

Seller review
Wealth of Knowledge and Great Personality
almost 2 years ago
Wealth of Knowledge and Great Personality

Nathan was an absolute blast to work with. He has a huge knowledge base and one of the best agents I have worked with. I would highly recommend working with him if you are looking for or selling a home!

25 - 31 of 31
© 2026 RateMyAgent