Nathan's profile

Nathan's reviews

  5  
Nathan has 31 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nathan's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Dream House Found
9 months ago
Dream House Found

We were originally planning on building a home since I tend to be very particular about houses. While we were waiting for a lot to open we got a message from Nathan about a new house on the market that checked a lot of the boxes we were looking for. We saw the house that Thursday, put an offer in on Friday and had an accepted offer by Saturday and now we are currently living in our dream home.

Seller review
Highly Satisfied
9 months ago
Highly Satisfied

Nathan's expertise, professionalism and enthusiasm are hallmarks of his business acumen. Our house sold at list price within FOUR DAYS under his leadership. We would recommend his services without reservation!

Seller review
The Absolute Best
9 months ago
The Absolute Best

Nathan has been with my wife and I through our entire home journey starting in 2013 when we bought our first home together. We loved that home for 12 years before finding our dream home in our new neighborhood. We were originally wanting to build a new home until Nathan found this house that we “had to see” and after a quick 20 viewing of this new home we knew it was perfect. He was able to sell our old house for over market value within 3 days with the first offer coming in 3 hours after it was on the market. Cannot recommend Nathan enough.

Seller review
Above and Beyond - A Truly Exceptional Agent
12 months ago
Above and Beyond - A Truly Exceptional Agent

Selling a home can be a stressful process, but working with Nathan made it incredibly smooth and reassuring. From day one, he went above and beyond in every possible way. His vendor and contractor recommendations were spot on when it came time to prepare our house to sell. He was always available—no matter the time of day—and consistently responded to our calls, texts, and emails with impressive speed and professionalism. What truly set Nathan apart was how far he exceeded the responsibilities of a seller’s agent. While we were also purchasing a new home in another state—where our agent was frequently unavailable—Nathan stepped in without hesitation. He answered our questions, explained unfamiliar parts of the process, offered thoughtful advice, and even helped facilitate communication when we needed it most. Beyond his professionalism, Nathan brought a personal touch that meant so much to us. He gave us a heartfelt card at closing that made us feel genuinely appreciated, and even after we moved over 800 miles away, he continued to check in on us to see how we were settling in. That kind of care and thoughtfulness is rare and speaks volumes about his character. We are incredibly grateful for everything Nathan did and would recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. He’s not just a fantastic seller’s agent—he’s a true advocate and partner.

Buyer review
Fantastic experience
about 1 year ago
Fantastic experience

Nathan was an incredible agent who made me feel comfortable and informed during my entire searching and purchasing experience. As a first time home buyer there was alot I didn't know and he was consistently available to educate me and answer the many questions. Even afterwards he continues to be an amazing resource. I couldn't be more happy with the whole experience and would absolutely recommend him to any loved ones! Thank you again Nathan for all of your guidance!

Seller review
Review of Nathan Pfahler
about 1 year ago
Review of Nathan Pfahler

We would definitely recommend Nathan, he did everything he could do for us and we really appreciated his service. We will definitely be using him in the future for our next adventure.

Buyer review
Absolutely the best!
over 1 year ago
Absolutely the best!

I can't say enough about the outstanding service and attention I received from Nathan. He dedicated hours to finding me the right home and then guided me through the buying process. You won't go wrong by choosing Nathan and Weichert Group for your home purchase or sale. He will be my go-to realtor.

Seller review
Above and beyond
over 1 year ago
Above and beyond

I've been involved in two transactions with Nathan, one as a buyer and one as a seller. As luck would have it, we found a buyer on our own before we even engaged Nathan's services. For the fee we paid him to handle the paperwork, he WAY overdelivered. We had problems with our inspection coming in low. Nathan went to bat for us BIG TIME. Way beyond what we'd agreed to... simply do the paperwork. Got us THOUSANDS extra vs. if the first appraisal went through. For us as a buyer, he helped us win a fight against multiple other offers and helped close on a very tight deadline imposed by the sellers. Honestly, I don't know what we would have done without Nathan!

Buyer review
Fantastic experience
over 1 year ago
Fantastic experience

I was pretty nervous about my first time buying a home, uncertain about the process and the many details that come with such a momentous occasion. But Nathan was a constant, joyful guide through the whole process. He was knowledgeable, patient, and more than happy to bring his own excitement to every step in the process. He was never pushy but provided the benefit of his experience to every decision. I'm very grateful to have such a compassionate, intelligent, and selfless person to help me through the experience. He gave me the space I needed to make the decisions that were best for my life and was always happy to answer questions. I could not have asked for a better realtor to be there with me through the rollercoaster experience that was buying my first house.

Seller review
Friendly, Professional, and Gets Results!
over 1 year ago
Friendly, Professional, and Gets Results!

Nathan did an amazing job helping us buy our home 13 years ago, and it was a pleasure to work with him again to sell it. He gave us detailed advice on what to do to prepare to sell, and under his guidance, we got an offer for full asking price 48 hrs after listing it! We enjoy working with Nathan so much and consider him a friend. Highly recommend!

Buyer review
Could Not Recommend More
over 1 year ago
Could Not Recommend More

I could not recommend working with Nathan more. He is so quick to respond, easy to get ahold of, explains things well, and truly cares about your new home. He made the process of us buying a home so seamless. Truly could not have done it without him!

Buyer review
Nathan Pfahler Review
over 1 year ago
Nathan Pfahler Review

Nathan was awesome to work with. He was very caring and very thorough and helping us find just the perfect home! This was the second time that we have used him would highly recommend him if anyone is looking for a new home!

13 - 24 of 31
© 2026 RateMyAgent