Nathan Pfahler

Nathan was the absolute best. He was always willing to go to a last minute showing, and always gave his absolute best. Nathan was especially good at answering all of the questions I had as a new home owner. He goes above and beyond for his clients and has fun doing it. Truly the most amazing realtor there is and I would recommend him, as well as his expertise, to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Nathan arranged for us to see a list of homes we provided. Then once he had a better understanding of our needs, was able to guide us to a property that wasn’t on our list. He worked with us all day fitting in other clients as well. Even through a torrential down pour.

Working with Nathan was a great experience. He is very knowledgeable and experienced. He took the time to show us several properties and helped us to find our dream home for now. I enjoyed his enthusiasm as well as his expertise in several areas. He takes his time when it comes to details. He also sold a home for us in 2025 which was a great experience as well. He does go out of his way when he can for the finer details. I would recommend him to anyone wanting a good, reliable, professional real estate agent.

Could not have asked for a better realtor if for some reason we ever had to move back to Indiana Nathan Prather would be our realtor. He’s kind considerate and pays attention to detail thank you for everything Nathan. It was such a joy, Ethan and Joann Atsinger.

This was the second property that Nathan sold for me. He is so experienced knowing how to market a property, this was a historic home. The property sold within days (less than a week). With his negotiation skills we received more than asking price. He has a great positive attitude. I rate him the #1 realtor in Indiana and will always use him as my realtor.

Nathan knew the neighborhood and have experience on how to market a rental property that needed some repairs. He sold the property in 4 days, and we received the full asking price. He was wonderful to work with and answered all my questions. I would recommend him to anyone. He is the best realtor I ever worked with.