Mike's profile

Mike's reviews

  5  
Mike has 84 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Mike's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, reliable, hard-working, supportive, clear communication, detail-oriented, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Consummate Professional
about 3 years ago
Consummate Professional

From initial discussion to property close, Mike made the process easy. He made more money for us than we expected, was very detailed in the listing and contract process which paved the way for a smooth close. Mike also handled some of the inspection completion work so we didn't have to find vendors to do the work. The entire deal was effortless for us and we highly recommend him as a realtor.

Buyer review
More Than An Agent
about 3 years ago
More Than An Agent

Mike is a knowledgable and kind person who happens to know a lot about real estate and helping you find your perfect property. You simply can not go wrong with whatever you entrust to him.

Seller review
Attentive and Thorough
over 3 years ago
Attentive and Thorough

Mike and Veronica are a great team that marketed and sold our two Siesta Key units in a short amount of time for a reasonable market price. We found them to be attentive and knowledgeable. Their communication with us and third parties were exceptional. We always felt informed and updated. Our emails and texts were promptly responded to, usually in less than an hour. The majority of our business was handled digitally and electronically. We unfamiliar with the buying selling process and were in another state. We felt comfortable with Mike and Veronica taking the lead the handling the process from start to finish. The team was very good at providing seemingly effortless execution handling the incidental issues, for example, the air conditioner unit, although serviced regularly, was considered dirty by the sellers inspector. M and V scheduled and supervised a AC serviceman to bring the AC unit up to the seller's expectations. Another example, Veronica returned the cable boxes for us, a small thing yet there were many of these small tasks that made working with them a pleasure. I found their work to be superior to other relators we considered working with and would highly recommend them.

Buyer review
Mike Martino True Sales Professional
over 3 years ago
Mike Martino True Sales Professional

Let me start by saying, I’ve gotten to know Mike over the last 6 or so years as he and our family have worked together on buying and selling 3 houses in Sarasota now. Mike is Top Shelf.. Period! He brings so much knowledge to the table and makes it so much easier for my wife and I to continue with our daily lives while he takes care of everything else. Moving can be very stressful but working with Mike eliminates all of that which is very important to me. I would highly, and have recommended Mike to all family and friends and will never consider working with anyone else. Thanks for everything Mike.. You are the best! Lou and Jodi Pisillo

Buyer review
The best there is!
over 3 years ago
The best there is!

Mike came highly recommended and we are honored to write this review and pay it forward. As out-of-towners we were a bit nervous looking for a property from afar. From our first conversation, Mike was very honest, patient, and friendly. We let him know what we were looking for and he took the time to explain the different neighbors and point us in the right direction. Mike was always and continues to be extremely communicative, and goes out of his way to help any way he can. We are so thankful that we found Mike, he made the whole process seamless and we couldn’t be happier!

Seller review
Our favorite realtor ever!
over 3 years ago
Our favorite realtor ever!

We have never worked with someone so selfless and dedicated to helping strangers. We took over a year on and off to find our perfect home and Mike stuck by our side the entire time. He was always so quick to find new listings and show it to us that same day. He answered every late night text or phone call and truly cared about us. There is no need to work with any other realtor besides Mike. He is extremely professional, knowledgeable, and reliable.

Seller review
Mike exceeded our expectations!!!
over 3 years ago
Mike exceeded our expectations!!!

Mike did an amazing job selling our house. He had a vision and executed it. He went the extra mile getting things done, following up on stuff and keeping us updated. Mike exceeded our expectations!!!

Seller review
Highly Recommend - The best out there!
almost 4 years ago
Highly Recommend - The best out there!

This is the second time we have used Mike to sell and purchase a house and we would never choose anyone else. Mike is very knowledgeable, professional, hard working and goes above and beyond! Most importantly he is honest, ethical, trustworthy, and very patient. We recommend Mike to all family and friends.

Seller review
5 Star Real Estate Experience!
almost 4 years ago
5 Star Real Estate Experience!

I’ve done many transactions with Mike..both buying and selling. He is always a consummate professional professional who knows his business extremely well. I would not hesitate to recommend Mike to anyone who needs help navigating this complicated market. You are guaranteed to get top dollar for your property! Mike is simply the best! Highly recommend!

Seller review
Expert In all ways
almost 4 years ago
Expert In all ways

This is our second time working with Michael. He has an amazing eye for detail and a great understanding of the market! Our home sold in less than 24 hrs of listing, $50k over asking and 2 weeks from list to close- not because of the market, but because Michael does the homework to list at the best price and present our home at it’s finest! We will be working with Michael again!

Seller review
If Mike were anything less can five stars, I would represent myself as I have had my real estate lic
over 4 years ago
If Mike were anything less can five stars, I would represent myself as I have had my real estate lic

If Mike were anything less can five stars, I would represent myself as I have had my real estate license since 2007. I am a value driven consumer who has always found Mike to be well worth the investment (time and money) when representing me in numerous transactions. In my most recent sale, and although it is a seller's market, he was able to obtain the highest sold price per square foot in the City of Sarasota off water properties. When taking on a listing, he is very methodical from beginning to end (and after) for example: Ensuring the property is in top condition prior to listing, self-investing in resources and materials and time to ensure the property is most appealing to the majority of buyers who would likely be interested, pricing the property to achieve much activity while never leaving potential profits on the table for his clients, ALWAYS being available for what may only seem important to the client, post listing...having the property exposed to as many people as possible through open houses and marketing materials, being available for potential buyers and their agents while minimizing the seller's interruptions, and always keeping safety and guarding the owner's property a top priority.

13 - 24 of 84
© 2026 RateMyAgent