Mike's profile

Mike's reviews

  5  
Mike has 84 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Mike's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, reliable, hard-working, supportive, clear communication, detail-oriented, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Incredible Professional Realtor!
3 months ago
Incredible Professional Realtor!

From day 1 we knew Mike was our agent. He not only sold us our brand new home, he found it, made several construction site visits, with video updates, and guided us through the process of buying a new construction home even though we were 1,500 miles away the entire time. He also sold our existing condo in record time even though other properties similar properties remain on the market. His professional approach to listing, marketing and closing a sale are second to none! Thanks, Mike for your incredible commitment to your craft!

Buyer review
Nothing but accolades for Mike
7 months ago
Nothing but accolades for Mike

I initially called Mike about one of his listings, and was not intending to hook up with a realtor quite yet. As an out of state buyer, I had also never purchased a property in Florida before. While the property I called about was not right for me, Mike was so personable and knowledgeable, I quickly knew he was the right realtor for me; no BS; absolute professionalism. After reviewing multiple listings Mike sent to me, I flew down to Sarasota and did a two day marathon viewing houses. As a recent retiree who has renovated several homes through the years, I had promised myself I would not buy another fixer upper, but when you find the right home, you have to go with it. Mike educated me about the pros and cons and local regulations regarding the property. With me back North, Mike attended all of the inspections (property, sewer, mold, pool) and kept in close contact with me. He helped me to negotiate an excellent buying price, and also to obtain temporary housing during the renovation. It has been several weeks since the closing, and Mike continues to assist me and be available for questions and obstacles. I don't think I could have done this without his help, dedication and knowledge (without losing my sanity lol). I have nothing but accolades for Mike. If you want a top notch realty agent, without question, contact Mike Martino!

Buyer review
Fantastic
9 months ago
Fantastic

Mike loves his job. You can tell because he’s very knowledgeable about real estate. He’s very thorough about details and kept me informed and up-to-date at all times.

Buyer review
Above and beyond
10 months ago
Above and beyond

Mike was recommended from a co-worker and we took a chance. It was a great experience from his communication to the hours he put in for us. Moving from out of state we had a lot to learn here in Florida. Mike was great at explaining all the nuances vs our old state. He did a great job with us helping to find a lawyer and loan as well. We really wish he was able to be our realtor in NC but 1 out of 2 isn’t bad. 100% would use Mike for every real estate transaction.

Seller review
We think Mike Martino was outstanding.
about 1 year ago
We think Mike Martino was outstanding.

My husband and I recently worked with Mike Martino, “realtor extraordinaire,” on the preparation and sale of our Siesta Key home. The house had been our sole residence for 16 years, and it was full of items that reflected the many memories collected during our lives. Mike coached us on all things necessary to sell our house, and his team of reliable contractors helped with packing, cleaning, painting, and landscaping. Although we were in a buyer’s market, our house was under contract within the first week. Thank you, Mike, for your infinite patience!

Seller review
Mike a Rare Gem
over 1 year ago
Mike a Rare Gem

Mike Martino is a rare find! I met Mike ten years ago when he helped an out of town friend buy and sell an investment property on Siesta Key. I was impressed with Mike’s attention to detail and how he went above and beyond expectations for my friend ... from start to finish. Simply put, Mike knows the marketplace and provides an incredible level of service. Since then, I have worked with Mike on several transactions. A young realtor asked me recently if I worked with a real estate agent. I mentioned Mike Martino, who he knew. He asked me what exactly Mike does that’s great. I told him that Mike is knowledgeable, honest, experienced and he exceeds expectations every time I work with him. Earlier this year, he was incredibly smart in a negotiation. Where another realtor may have gotten in the way of a sale, Mike’s insight and experience helped to close the deal. He also fought for me when a buyer’s closing agent tried to slip additional costs into the final closing documents. Mike is thorough and patient when guiding me through the sales process and takes time to explain the details … and there are numerous details that come up during the life of a transaction. He stays one step ahead so we stay on schedule. Mike also listened to my input along the way. He is available. If Mike doesn’t pick up my call, he always gets right back to me. Over the course of 5 years, he has never once forgotten to call me back. Mike is experienced and resourceful. He has connected me to accountants, appraisers, cleaning services, staging companies, lawn care, and others. In terms of going above and beyond, he helped me stage my home with some of his own personal items … He also hired a crew to clean up my back yard of tree limbs when I wasn’t available to do so. I've recommended Mike to friends!

Seller review
An excellent experience
over 1 year ago
An excellent experience

“You must use Mike Martino. He’s the best,” a friend told me when we were planning to put our condo on the market. Flash forward a few months. Mike not only helped us declutter, facilitated storage, staged our condo to perfection and arranged stunning photography, he got us into contract between two major hurricanes. As a former realtor myself, I was impressed by his depth knowledge of market conditions, timing and pricing. While other properties in our community have been lingering on the market for many months ours sold in a month. So without qualification I’d say, “ you must use Mike Martino. He’s the best.”

Buyer review
Most amazing home buying experience
over 2 years ago
Most amazing home buying experience

Mike is one of the most amazing realtor my husband and I have ever worked with! His knowledge of the area was incredible and his willingness to help with questions and concerns made you feel very comfortable to work with him. He definitely goes above and beyond to make sure you are happy. We have recommended Mike to our out of state friends and will continue to do so as he is genuinely a great & honest person!

Buyer review
Sharp Agent at the Top Of His Game
over 2 years ago
Sharp Agent at the Top Of His Game

I chose to work with Mike after meeting him when I viewed a home that I found myself on Zillow. Mike brings that old-school "customer-first" flavor to his business. He didn't pressure me into signing with him, and gave me a mountain of sage advice about how to go about executing my strategy as I discussed it with him. I found him to be knowledgeable, courteous, respectful, and a good listener. Over the course of a 25 year military career, I have bought and sold many houses, both on my own and through agents. Without-a-doubt, Mike brings that added value to the transaction on multiple levels. His hallmark "go-getter" attitude and zero-pressure sales tactics are just what this world needs.

Seller review
Mike is the best in all fronts!
over 2 years ago
Mike is the best in all fronts!

I’ve bought and sold several homes through Mike. I can’t say enough about his expertise and professionalism. He is a pleasure to work with and always makes what can be a challenging process as smooth as possible. I would highly recommend Mike’s services to anyone who is buying or selling property in the Sarasota area. He is simply the best at what he does…hands down!

Seller review
Mike is the guy!!
over 2 years ago
Mike is the guy!!

This was the second transaction with him and he is super in resolving any issues quickly, he has a great list of references for tried and true businesses in upgrading and refreshing your home before & after sale. He is top in market knowledge and "timing" for sales!! We will use him always and no one else👍

Buyer review
Super Knowledgeable and Trust Worthy
about 3 years ago
Super Knowledgeable and Trust Worthy

Michael was very knowledgeable about the local market as well as the overall landscape of purchasing real estate in FL. We also found Mike to be very trustworthy and helpful from meeting him at the open house thru to the closing. He went out of his way to make the entire process as seamless as possible. He does what he says and beyond. I would highly recommend Michael.

1 - 12 of 84
© 2026 RateMyAgent