Midge's profile

Midge's reviews

  5  
Midge has 53 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Midge's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, empathetic, detail-oriented, responsive, supportive, reliable, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Midge is the best!
over 3 years ago
Midge is the best!

Midge did a great job of understanding what I was looking for in a home. Her knowledge and experience made me feel comfortable and confident. I feel privileged to have had her by my side when I purchased my first home.

Buyer review
If you are buying or selling, Midge is the best
almost 4 years ago
If you are buying or selling, Midge is the best

If you are buying or selling, Midge is the best. She helped us find the perfect home within budget that met all of our needs. We ended up with a new construction home and when the cement floors of the garage ended up with a few oil spills, Midge spoke with the contractor and had a sub contractor in on our closing day upgrading our garage floors to terrazo flooring free of charge. She found tons of small items at our pre-close walk through and made sure our home was move in ready and everything we needed. She knows all the areas from Parrish to North Port, steered us in the right direction the whole time and we love our home.

Seller review
I was 600 miles away when I decided to sell my home
almost 4 years ago
I was 600 miles away when I decided to sell my home

I was 600 miles away when I decided to sell my home. It could've been a complicated procedure, but Midge's expertise and networking skills made for a smooth sale. Midge was an advocate in my corner and was available day or evening to assist me through the process. Midge knows real estate! She is an excellent agent and I highly recommend her.

Seller review
I would recommend Ms. McCarthy to anyone. She...
about 4 years ago
I would recommend Ms. McCarthy to anyone. She...

I would recommend Ms. McCarthy to anyone. She is a wonderful realtor and just a really nice human being. She went above and beyond to help me understand this whole process. Answered all my questions in a timely manner and stayed calm thru all my anxiety !! She really knows this business and how it all works. I would highly recommend her !!!

Buyer review
Words cannot describe how thankful I am to have had Midge as our realtor
over 4 years ago
Words cannot describe how thankful I am to have had Midge as our realtor

Words cannot describe how thankful I am to have had Midge as our realtor. My husband and I had zero knowledge on purchasing a home since this was our first time buying and Midge could not have done a better job. She was AlWAYS there and easy to contact with any and all questions throughout the entire process. Always one step ahead and planning for the next step, it completely took the stress off me. There’s no need to worry or check up on her, she knows what needs to be done and gets it done, and more than likely will be reminding you of what you need to get done, not vice versa. I learned a lot from her as well, she has a nice way of explaining more complex things in simpler terms as well as years of experience and knowledge to share. Please do not hesitate to hire this lovely woman, I guarantee you will love her just as much as we did.

Buyer review
I am very lucky that I found Midge about 14 or 15 years ago
over 4 years ago
I am very lucky that I found Midge about 14 or 15 years ago

I am very lucky that I found Midge about 14 or 15 years ago. She helped me with my first Home in Sarasota Lake, my parents home in Desoto Lakes in Sarasota, my cousin’s home in port charlotte, my brothers home in Sarasota FL and my second home recently in Port Charlotte. My family and I are very thankful to her as she is honest, reliable, puntual, and excellent rep. I found Midge in 2008, and she was very patient with me, and we purchase my first home in 2009, and since then, she has helped my family and I. I cannot thank her enough…

Buyer review
Outstanding, again.
over 4 years ago
Outstanding, again.

Our recent home purchase represents our second experience with Midge McCarthy. She is relentless in her search for appropriate properties and scheduling viewings. She has an extensive knowledge of both Sarasota and Manatee Counties. Her communication skills are outstanding; clear, concise, and her demeanor is always friendly, positive and supportive. Midge is detail oriented, follows up on questions and issues, is a treasure trove of real estate knowledge and procedure and has excellent follow-up abilities.

Seller review
Midge McCarthy of REMAX Sarasota represented my wife and me in 2018 when we purchased a second home
over 4 years ago
Midge McCarthy of REMAX Sarasota represented my wife and me in 2018 when we purchased a second home

Midge McCarthy of REMAX Sarasota represented my wife and me in 2018 when we purchased a second home in Sarasota Florida. Her knowledge and professionalism was so over and above the real estate agents that we have dealt with previously that we wouldn’t consider retaining anyone else to sell the property we had purchased just 2 1/2 years earlier. She worked diligently scheduling showings to abide by our tenants schedule. She developed a great rapport with the buyers agent and went out of her way to take it upon herself to coordinate the scheduling of repairs that were needed before closing. Best of all, we had asked for and received updates on a daily basis. We believe that Midge is the best of the best!

Buyer review
Midge was a very excellent agent.
over 4 years ago
Midge was a very excellent agent.

Midge was excellent at listening at showing us property that was what we were looking for. We lived about 140 miles from Longboat Key. We looked at several properties and made offers on several ones. The condo we bought was perfect for us. Midge was very experienced and followed up on every detail. If you fine a property. you need to be prepared to act and make a offer. She will be our agent on any other properties we buy.

Buyer review
Exceptional client oriented professional
over 4 years ago
Exceptional client oriented professional

I highly recommend Midge. she is both professional and friendly. Midge went above and beyond to help us narrow our focus to the right neighborhood and then worked tirelessly to promote and protect our interests in a chaotic market.

Buyer review
Midge McCarthy is the absolute best we could ask for
almost 5 years ago
Midge McCarthy is the absolute best we could ask for

Midge McCarthy is the absolute best we could ask for. Helped us all the way through our purchase process and even after. We felt very comfortable knowing that Midge was very knowledgeable about every aspect of the purchase, and never missed a beat. We would definitely recommend her to family and friends.

Buyer review
Professional but best of all her great personality with her clients
almost 5 years ago
Professional but best of all her great personality with her clients

Professional but best of all her great personality with her clients. She kept working and searching for a place that meet our request. Even in this tight housing market she found us our place...happy that we're here. Thank you Midge for making it happen!!

25 - 36 of 53
© 2026 RateMyAgent