Michelle's profile

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 159 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, honest, supportive, empathetic, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Made downsizing possible
about 3 years ago
Made downsizing possible

We were ready to downsize after becoming empty-nesters. Michelle & Tara made the purchase of our townhome possible & easy!

Seller review
Michelle Starkey, my realtor
about 3 years ago
Michelle Starkey, my realtor

Gary and I love Michelle. She wants to be sure that we understand the whole process in the selling of our home. Michelle is also very good listener. Our home was staged beautifully by Michelle and her assistant Tara. She knows the market very well.

Seller review
ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL
about 3 years ago
ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL

Michelle is a person who absolutely cares for her clients and goes the extra mile to make sure everything goes flawlessly!!! Due to my past work requirements, I have moved many times. I have never had an agent take the time to really understand my needs and then follow through on every detail until she finds the right place for you. During the selling/buying process she keeps you informed on everything and makes the whole process go smoothly. I would ABSOLUTELY recommend Michelle to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Amazing first time home owner experience!
about 3 years ago
Amazing first time home owner experience!

When searching for my first home she was able to connect to my vision of what I wanted and was able to give helpful and honest feedback on houses we looked at. When I found my perfect house she was quick to help me get an offer in and within the next couple weeks I was moving in!!

Buyer review
Michelle was incredibly patient with us in our home-buying process
about 3 years ago
Michelle was incredibly patient with us in our home-buying process

Michelle was incredibly patient with us in our home-buying process. We were first time home buyers and she walked us through all of the steps. We looked at so many houses with Michelle, and for several months could not find the right one. She never once made us feel dumb for taking longer than we thought we should. If you want the best then Michelle is the realtor for you. Cannot recommend highly enough!

Buyer review
Michelle is FANTASTIC!
about 3 years ago
Michelle is FANTASTIC!

I reached out to Michelle to be my realtor and that was the best decision I could have made in my journey for my home. She was such a great match for me. Michelle is communicative, knowledgeable, patient, helpful, and VERY present. She never made me feel like a bother or like my questions weren't valid. She taught me a lot about the process and helped to know what to look for. She always made herself available for showings and even encouraged me to get in sooner to be sure I didn't miss opportunities, even if it was the same day. When I found my dream home she was up all night drawing up the offer and working her butt off for me to get this house. She shared in my excitement but always remained honest about odds. Then at the closing there were some issues with the house and she made sure that I wasn't taken advantage of and fought for me to be sure the issues didn't add stress or expense to a closing/moving weekend that was already going to be busy and stressful. I could not recommend her more strongly and had such a wonderful experience.

Buyer review
Michelle is incredible! Absolutely could not recommend her enough. Best realtor I've ever had!
over 3 years ago
Michelle is incredible! Absolutely could not recommend her enough. Best realtor I've ever had!

I had an incredible experience working with Michelle Starkey. I had heard such great things about her as an agent, and after she helped us by a house, I can say with confidence she worked above and beyond our expectations! Michelle was so encouraging and patient throughout the whole process. She never pushed us to make a decision and always gave such great advice. Michelle was quick to communicate with us, as well as other agents, ensuring that we were in the best position for buying a home. She also connected us with a great lender, and she and him worked together well to ensure we were comfortable with the property. I was so impressed by Michelle's commitment to our deal, and she made the entire process not only less stressful, but also joyful! I looked forward to looking at houses with her, as she was always joking and making the process so fun! Seriously, I cannot recommend Michelle enough as an agent. You won't regret working with her!

Buyer review
Best Realtor!
over 3 years ago
Best Realtor!

Michelle was great throughout the entire process! She made the house search fun, offered us valuable insight with each house we looked at, was great at communicating, very professional, and taught us a lot about the whole process. I couldn’t recommend her enough!

Buyer review
Wonderful
over 3 years ago
Wonderful

Michelle has been absolutely great from the first time we reached out to her and even now that we got our house she has still been nothing but kind. She is very responsive to messages and is super understanding when it comes to unforeseen circumstances causing a showing to be pushed back. She always gave her honest opinion to the best of her abilities, she was and continues to be very professional. I can’t say enough good things about her. I highly recommend to anyone and everyone that is looking for a realtor!

Buyer review
Make a new friend in real estate!
over 3 years ago
Make a new friend in real estate!

Michelle Starkey is the gold standard in real estate! I’ve worked with her now on two properties and in both situations she was excellent. She is patient, reasonable and knowledgeable about this market and real estate process. And let’s be honest - she’s a blast to be around! She makes the entire process fun, even the stressful parts. My family is so happy with our new home - one we only found because of Michelle’s hard work! We are forever grateful to her.

Seller review
Peace of Mind
almost 4 years ago
Peace of Mind

Michelle is foremost a nice, personable and genuinely caring person. As an agent she’s all that, but also no nonsense and gets the job done. She’s smart, knows the market and the values of the market, she will help get you get the most dollars in your situation. I had moved my mother into assisted living so it was crucial that we sell the house asap. She not only did that but went the extra mile and volunteered to be with my mom at assisted living to help her and make her feel more comfortable at the closing. I was referred to her and she didn’t disappoint, it was a tough and stressful period for our family and she made the sale of my mom’s home a lot less stressful. I couldn’t have been any happier from my experience, I’m very thankful!!!

61 - 72 of 159
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent