Michelle's profile

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 159 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, honest, supportive, empathetic, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent experience
5 days ago
Excellent experience

Michelle was amazing to work with. Very insightful and informative.

Seller review
It is so refreshing to have an agent who actually cares!
10 days ago
It is so refreshing to have an agent who actually cares!

Michelle is a pleasure to work with. Her professionalism is outstanding because she supplements it with a genuine human touch. When setting the price for my home, I had an idea of what I was going to ask. But knowing the market in this area, Michelle made recommendations on a price that made total sense. Along the path of selling my home, she was very responsive to answer any questions or concerns. When it came time to entertain offers, she listened to my thoughts and then tailored them to a very pleasing counteroffer. Due to her suggestions, the acceptance of my counter and the closing process went without a hitch. I could not ask for a better experience!!

Buyer review
Michelle is the best!!
16 days ago
Michelle is the best!!

I cannot recommend Michelle enough as a realtor. She is responsive, diligent, and so knowledgeable of every aspect of buying/selling. She made us feel so comfortable and took time to answer all our questions. Michelle also was a huge advocate for us as buyers and made sure we had everything we needed. She is professional, communicative, and so fun to be around! I’m so thankful we had Michelle help us buy our new home!

Buyer review
BEST REALTOR & SERVICE!!
3 months ago
BEST REALTOR & SERVICE!!

Michelle is truly the best! She was always willing to drive out, explore options, and took the time to understand exactly what I wanted in my first home. Even when I felt unsure or changed my mind, she reassured me it was completely okay and part of the process. She genuinely enjoys what she does, and it shows. Her communication was excellent—always checking in about paperwork, discussing how I felt about each home, and offering helpful feedback. Her knowledge is honest and straightforward, and she kept everything professional while bringing positive energy. Michelle made me feel confident in my decisions and always had my back. I would recommend her and her business over and over again!

Buyer review
Michelle is Awesome
5 months ago
Michelle is Awesome

Knowledgeable, experienced, knows the market well. No notes, she did a fantastic job for us and I would highly recommend her!

Seller review
Great from start to finish
7 months ago
Great from start to finish

Michelle absolutely did amazing work throughout the whole house sale process! Could not have done it without her expertise! She and her team are also super friendly and a joy to talk to:) highly recommend!

Seller review
Expectations
7 months ago
Expectations

Michelle and her assistance strived to have our home presented at in its best light so that we can get more value out of our home. They keep you informed and on task with what needs to be accomplished. I only ever felt that she had high expectations that was in the best interest for us. We feel so much gratitude for everything she did for us. I highly recommend choosing her.

Seller review
Michelle Starkey Truly Gets the Job Done!
8 months ago
Michelle Starkey Truly Gets the Job Done!

My parent's house had been on the market for just over 2 years. We decided it was time to find a new realtor. My neighbors were selling their house, and recommended their realtor to us. We truly were blessed that it was Michelle Starkey. I believe my parent's property sold in under 2 months from the time it was listed. Michelle is truly so much more than just a realtor. She becomes your friend! Our situation was sensitive, and she met our needs with care and concern. Every step truly was very quick and easy. When I had anxiety, she quickly took all fears away. Michelle is very knowledgable, and our situation definitely had some quirks, but she was able to navigate through it effortlessly. We are completely satisfied with everything from the listing, to the buyers. Our family is at peace. Thank you Michelle!!!

Seller review
Rockstar!
9 months ago
Rockstar!

Michelle is beyond incredible! She put so much effort into making sure our house got the value it deserved. She knew the market and helped us in countless ways. This is the second time we have worked with Michelle and both times she exceeded any and all expectations! I could not recommend a better realtor. She is on it and prioritizes helping meet your needs. Honesty and integrity define Michelle and she will not do anything but give YOU 100%! Rockstar!

Seller review
So thankful!
9 months ago
So thankful!

Michelle was a huge help to me when I decided to sell my dad’s home. She was so patient and supportive with all my needs and questions. She is so easy to work with. I appreciate all the help!

Buyer review
Michelle Starkey is THE BEST!!!
10 months ago
Michelle Starkey is THE BEST!!!

From the moment we met with Michelle she completely put our minds at ease! She was truly interested in learning exactly what we were looking for and made the entire experience of searching a pleasure. I would highly recommend her to everyone who is looking to sell, buy or both - you will not regret it!

1 - 12 of 159
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent