Michelle McCulloch

Michelle McCulloch

Sales Agent / REALTOR® at WNY Metro Roberts Realty
  •   5   (21 reviews)

About Michelle

My clients are my passion! I am a full time agent in Western New York and also licensed in Florida. I left the traditional workplace to work for clients in need of a real estate advocate. As a mom of 4, 3 that live out of state, my goal is to serve my clients exactly how I want a Realtor to work with them when they purchase their home. Everything about real estate is exciting for me. From the first meeting, to closing day and beyond. You will find I will work hard to make the process as seamless as possible. Great communication and attention to detail are my priorities as we go through the process of buying or selling your home. Let's chat so I can answer your questions and concerns. Each Realtor is different, so make it a point to get to know what that difference is!

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 21 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 6.
Review Michelle
19 days ago
Michelle was absolutely amazing through the entire process!

Michelle was absolutely amazing from start to finish! Her communication was excellent — she kept us updated, answered my MANY questions, and was always honest and straightforward about what was happening. She knows the market, gave us great advice throughout the process, and when it came time to negotiate and work through issues, we always felt like she had our best interests in mind. And then came closing… which apparently needed a few extra plot twists. Michelle remained professional, calm and on top of everything, even when my patience was running a little thinner than hers. She handled the craziness, kept things moving, and helped get us across the finish line. Selling a house while moving out of state is no small task, and having an agent we could trust made a huge difference. We are on to the next adventure! We truly appreciate everything Michelle did for us and would recommend her in a heartbeat. If you want someone who communicates, knows her stuff, fights for her clients, and can survive a little closing circus — Michelle is your girl!

4 months ago
You want a real-life realtor....stop here!

My wife and I sold a house in New York and bought in Florida. Talk about a realtor that LITERALLY flew from NY to FL for a day to show us houses. Michelle will go above and beyond, she will fight for you as her client...not a sale. You will not be disappointed that you read this and went with her. I promise!

10 months ago
Michelle was amazing!

Michelle helped my family and I sell my mother’s house and we had a great experience. Throughout the very difficult process for my family she was there every step of the way. She explained every step thoroughly and was always there to answer any questions we had. Michelle sent us daily updates and she truly made the process a lot more manageable. Highly recommend her! Thank you Michelle!

11 months ago
Diligent Professional

Michelle did the absolute most to make our bome buying process meet the timeline we held. Absolutely clear communication and direction at all times. A personal touch that made us feel like family. We couldn't be happier with her as our agant!

12 months ago
Realtor you can trust and will enjoy working together with in your buying or selling process

After my interviewing a few realtors, it was clear for me to hire Michelle McCulloch to help me sell our long time homestead and buy a senior home with specific needs next. Michelle worked to sell our home at a reasonable price, and made the sell process seamless because of her involvement. She also helped me seek out specific types of ranches in certain locations which most times had us looking at several homes a day, driving from one town to the next. Her patients and understanding and input she offered, through each home we viewed along with her knowledge and willingness to be available for me at any time made my home seeking and buying a success. To have a realtor with a joyful positive attitude and always with a smile was an added bonus in what is typically said to be a stressful time, I’d most certainly recommend Michelle McCulloch and I am sure you will experience the care, trust and experience required from her in helping you buy or sell your home property or land as I have and I thank you Michelle, for that and more. God bless. 🤗

Show all 21 reviews

Michelle's properties

Michelle has 9 properties for sale and sold 18 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldSep 11, 2026
$560,000
2364 Walker Road
Darien NY 14005
4
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty and KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY WNY
SoldAug 31, 2026
$505,000
1439 Clinton Street Road
Bennington NY 14011
3
2
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty and Howard Hanna WNY Inc.
SoldAug 25, 2026
$182,000
3356 Route 98
Wyoming County NY 14167
3
2
2
Other
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty
Pending
$324,900
2573 Pratt Rd
Batavia NY 14020
3
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty
Show all 27 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent