Michelle McCulloch

Michelle McCulloch

Sales Agent / REALTOR® at WNY Metro Roberts Realty
  •   5   (19 reviews)

About Michelle

My clients are my passion! I am a full time agent in Western New York and also licensed in Florida. I left the traditional workplace to work for clients in need of a real estate advocate. As a mom of 4, 3 that live out of state, my goal is to serve my clients exactly how I want a Realtor to work with them when they purchase their home. Everything about real estate is exciting for me. From the first meeting, to closing day and beyond. You will find I will work hard to make the process as seamless as possible. Great communication and attention to detail are my priorities as we go through the process of buying or selling your home. Let's chat so I can answer your questions and concerns. Each Realtor is different, so make it a point to get to know what that difference is!

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 19 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 6.
Review Michelle
6 months ago
Michelle was amazing!

Michelle helped my family and I sell my mother’s house and we had a great experience. Throughout the very difficult process for my family she was there every step of the way. She explained every step thoroughly and was always there to answer any questions we had. Michelle sent us daily updates and she truly made the process a lot more manageable. Highly recommend her! Thank you Michelle!

6 months ago
Diligent Professional

Michelle did the absolute most to make our bome buying process meet the timeline we held. Absolutely clear communication and direction at all times. A personal touch that made us feel like family. We couldn't be happier with her as our agant!

8 months ago
Realtor you can trust and will enjoy working together with in your buying or selling process

After my interviewing a few realtors, it was clear for me to hire Michelle McCulloch to help me sell our long time homestead and buy a senior home with specific needs next. Michelle worked to sell our home at a reasonable price, and made the sell process seamless because of her involvement. She also helped me seek out specific types of ranches in certain locations which most times had us looking at several homes a day, driving from one town to the next. Her patients and understanding and input she offered, through each home we viewed along with her knowledge and willingness to be available for me at any time made my home seeking and buying a success. To have a realtor with a joyful positive attitude and always with a smile was an added bonus in what is typically said to be a stressful time, I’d most certainly recommend Michelle McCulloch and I am sure you will experience the care, trust and experience required from her in helping you buy or sell your home property or land as I have and I thank you Michelle, for that and more. God bless. 🤗

9 months ago
Very Knowledgeable

Michelle was great with the information she gave me concerning homes in the area that sold or were being sold. I then had a good idea of what my home would sell for. She was very easy to work with. The photos taken of the home were great. It looked good enough for me to buy the home. All the transactions went smoothly. I did have to update the electrical panel and Michelle recommended a good electrician who did a great job. I was very pleased with her encouragement as I had not sold a home before. All things considered I would highly recommend her as your real estate agent. She was very professional and knowledgeable about real estate in this area. This was a family home that was lived in for over 50 years. I live in California. It was very important to have a realtor that could help me coordinate things with the issue of the time difference between New York and California. I am so happy and pleased that the house sold and hope that the new owners will have 50 wonderful years living in the house as our family did. The sale went very smoothly from start to finish. I would highly recommend Michelle!

10 months ago
Excellent experience

Michelle was wonderful to work with. I wasn’t quite sure what I was looking for, but after a few questions and going to a couple showings, she knew exactly what would peak my interest. I valued her experience as I’m a first time homebuyer. She never pressured me one way or another, and laid out details of the homes we saw that I definitely wouldn’t have considered. She was also extremely easy to work with as far as schedule. I had a tight and limited timeline and she worked with me with ease. I’d highly Michele to any friends or family, and would not hesitate to work with her again.

Show all 19 reviews

Michelle's properties

Michelle has 4 properties for sale and sold 19 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 14, 2026
$690,000
680 Centerline Road
Sheldon NY 14145
3
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Lancaster and WNY Metro Roberts Realty
Pending
$379,900
70 Colony Run
Attica NY 14011
2
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty
SoldMar 30, 2026
$328,000
945 Shawna Shores
Haines City FL 33844
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of MARK SPAIN REAL ESTATE and CARPENTER REALTY GROUP
SoldFeb 5, 2026
$241,500
7212 Derby Road
Evans NY 14047
3
1
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty
Show all 23 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent