Michael's profile

Michael's reviews

  5  
Michael has 78 reviewsacross 35 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michael's qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, honest, dedicated, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Mike is the BEST!
10 months ago
Mike is the BEST!

Mike Butterworth was absolutely the best! He spent so much time helping us find our new home. He answered our questions, guided us every step of the way, and made the entire transaction seamless. We highly recommend Mike to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Seller review
Above and beyond!
10 months ago
Above and beyond!

Mike Butterworth is the premier Real Estate Agent in NJ hands down. He is professional, knowledgeable, available at all times, and most importantly he genuinely cares about you. Mike got us into our forever home and sold our previous home seamlessly. Any time we had a question, he got it answered or called someone who could help us immediately. Not only that, but he knows his building construction and can spot something good or bad a mile away. Even though our business relationship ended after we bought our home, we gained a friend. Thanks for all of your hard work Mike! I strongly recommend him to everyone.

Seller review
Mike is the absolute best.
10 months ago
Mike is the absolute best.

Mike went above and beyond my expectations. He was available day or night for any questions I had or for help with my house. He is very knowledgeable and puts his clients needs before anything else. I would highly highly recommend using Mike for anyone looking to buy or sell. A++ in my book.

Buyer review
THE BEST EXPERIENCE POSSIBLE
11 months ago
THE BEST EXPERIENCE POSSIBLE

Where do I even begin.. Michael was so fantastic that we could not possibly fit all of the compliments we have into one review. Our experience with Mike was definitely one to remember. When it comes to customer service, Mike checked every single box. Boxes that we did not even know needed to be checked. His attention to detail, follow up, availability, and work ethic is beyond anything we have ever seen. A true hustler. A true master at his craft. Mike made sure that this entire process went smoother the butter. As first time home buyers, we had no idea what to expect, but buying a home with Mike truly was a breath of fresh air. Thank you Mike. For finding us the perfect home and making our first time home buy one for the books.

Buyer review
Reliable, Trusted, Knowledgeable.
12 months ago
Reliable, Trusted, Knowledgeable.

Mike is extremely knowledgeable about real estate and our purchase area. He is incredibly responsive, well-connected, and always available for his clients. More than a realtor, Mike became a trusted advisor, ally, and educator who consistently put our best interests first. I would highly recommend Mike.

Buyer review
First Time Homebuyers  & The Realtor Who Wore Every Hat
about 1 year ago
First Time Homebuyers & The Realtor Who Wore Every Hat

We worked with Mike Butterworth through an extended and challenging home search, navigating one of the toughest markets for first-time buyers. Throughout the entire journey, Mike remained patient, supportive, and genuinely invested in helping us find the right home. He was personable, realistic, and the epitome of professionalism. REALTOR  |re-al-tor| [noun] Tour Guide, Consultant, Therapist, Advisor & Inspection Bestie—see also: Closing Magician. We’re so grateful to have had him by our side every step of the way.

Seller review
Professionalism and Support
over 1 year ago
Professionalism and Support

Thank you for making the sale of my home such a smooth and stress-free experience. Your professionalism and support meant a lot—truly appreciated!

Buyer review
Wonderful experience!
over 1 year ago
Wonderful experience!

Mike worked with us for over 2 years on and off due to life getting in the way, and he led us to our dream home. 10/10 will recommend Mike to anyone looking for a home he was phenomenal!!!!

Buyer review
Never Use Another Realtor
over 1 year ago
Never Use Another Realtor

My husband and I were in the fence about selling and buying but I found this home on Zillow and reached out to the realtor unbeknownst it was Mike. He called me instantly and although he wasn't the listing agent he worked tirelessly to get us into see this house that is now our home. He met us here every time we asked so we could look and double check things. It didn't matter if it was a Tuesday or a Saturday he was here. I honestly can't say enough about Mike. He's very honest, he knows when to give his opinion and when not to but he's always on your side. You will be in good hands with Mike. I would recommend Mike any day of the week and know you'll be in good hands.

Seller review
Realtor of the Year
over 1 year ago
Realtor of the Year

Our experience couldn't have been any better. Any time we called Mike to show us a house he was there. He gave up his weekends for us at a moments notice. He is very knowledgeable and not pushy!! He started as our realtor and ended as our friend! I'm can't say enough about him. If you're in the market for a home, call Mike.

Buyer review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
over 1 year ago
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

One of the characteristics in finding a Real Estate Agent is trusting their choices. Our journey began when we on a search for a home that required many features for our multi generational family. To say we made the right choice in having Mike as our agent is an understatement. His response to our questions were prompt and thorough. One reason was his familiarity with Ocean County, where we wanted to move to. When you begin your search for the ideal house for your family, consider Mike Butterworth as your agent. We are so happy that he helped us find our perfect home.

Buyer review
Mike is the best!
over 1 year ago
Mike is the best!

Mike was great, whatever we needed Mike made sure to take us. Everything went smooth and easy, it was a real pleasure working with him. Thanks again Mike!

25 - 36 of 78
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent