Matt's profile

Matt's reviews

  5  
Matt has 61 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Matt's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-connected, empathetic, detail-oriented, attentive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Amazing Experience
about 3 years ago
Amazing Experience

From the start Matt was always there to help. Didn’t matter what time of day or what he has going on you can tell that he makes your experience number one. Selling the house was always what was going to be best for my family and I. Never any pressure to decide one way or another. He would advise if we asked and gave us the time frame and structure of what was going on at that stage of the deal. There was never any doubt in my mind that I was in great hands through this entire transaction. Thank Matt for a great sale and experience. If you’re looking to buy or sell I would suggest using Matt, 100%!

Seller review
Kudos to Matt Hinshaw
about 3 years ago
Kudos to Matt Hinshaw

I had great vibes upon listing my property with Matt Hinshaw and would not hesitate to recommend him to others. He conducted himself in a very workmanlike manner.

Buyer review
Knowledgeable and Accommodating
over 3 years ago
Knowledgeable and Accommodating

Matt is really knowledgeable about the local area and knows which neighborhoods align with the needs and personality of the buyer. He was also always available during off hours so that I never had to take of work, which is important at a new job. He also has great connections with others in the process which eases the confusion and feelings of being overwhelmed that the home buying process can cause. It was also helpful that he knows some of the pitfalls of the local area (like houses with cracks in the foundation or sloping floors). Overall it was a good experience and that was based solely on Matt's help.

Seller review
Matt is the best!
over 3 years ago
Matt is the best!

Highest recommendation for this excellent realtor! Responsive, knowledgeable, kind, honest---all the best qualities you want to produce the best results.

Seller review
Not just an agent but so much more
over 3 years ago
Not just an agent but so much more

Matt is so much more than an agent he is your number one fan, always available to help, he is a CLOSER, he is a friend. Matt is the way to go if there is a Deal to be made. I used Matt to sell not one, not two, but Three homes in a span of 2 years. Thanks Matt for all of your attentiveness and hard work, Zaza

Buyer review
Diligent throughout
over 3 years ago
Diligent throughout

My home buying journey took an entire year. Throughout it, Matt consistently communicated with me, continuously adjusted search notifications as my budget and needs changed, and was always available to schedule showings when new houses listed. He is extremely knowledgeable about his market and has foresight of upcoming trends and changing conditions. When I became discouraged, he showed compassion, kept a positive outlook, and encouraged me to continue looking regardless of how tough it got. I’m now a customer for life and look forward to working with him again, and I will recommend his services to all of my friends and family. Thank you for grinding it out with me, Matt!

Seller review
Best Home Selling Experience Ever
over 3 years ago
Best Home Selling Experience Ever

Having bought and sold multiple homes in multiple states, this was by far the greatest experiences of them all and 100% attributed to the excellence of Matt Hinshaw. Under the most challenging circumstances of trying to sell my dads home, many obstacles to navigate and overcome, Matt could not have been more professional, friendly, responsive, or capable. In plain speech, Matt knows his shit and will bust his behind at all hours of the day, even on holidays, as I can attest, to get the job done and get the best deal for his clients. In my experience, Matt Hinshaw is the best in the biz and I absolutely recommend his service without question. 100%. If you are looking to sell or buy a home in Prescott or Prescott Valley, AZ, Matt is your realtor.

Buyer review
Very Please
over 3 years ago
Very Please

Sometimes you have no choice but to trust online reviews. We were new in town and couldn't get word of mouth recommendations. We picked Matt from the comments people left on line and we clearly made the right choice. Matt has extensive knowledge of the area and is very professional in his approach. He asked pointed questions and listened to our needs. It took only a few days to find the right house and to negotiate a deal. Then the real work began and Matt stayed right on top of every detail, ensuring that we understood everything that was needed from us, as well as all of the information coming from the sellers and inspectors. He was very patient with all of our questions and made sure we were comfortable with the process. When it comes time for us to sell, Matt will be our first call!

Buyer review
We unexpectedly found ourselves needing to buy a house and found Matt from his online reviews
over 3 years ago
We unexpectedly found ourselves needing to buy a house and found Matt from his online reviews

We unexpectedly found ourselves needing to buy a house and found Matt from his online reviews. We were not disappointed. He asked many questions and listened carefully to assess our needs, then immediately began feeding possible availabilities. It took only a few days and several viewings to find the right house. During that time and the subsequent weeks to closing, he was on top of every task that had to be done and was able to answer my myriad of questions, without once sounding like I was being a bother, which I'm sure I was. Our buying process took place over two major holidays and a time when Matt was under the weather, but he never stopped working for us. We felt confident and comfortable with Matt's expertise and knowledge of the community. When it comes time to sell, he will be our first call.

Seller review
My favorite thing in working with Matt was his responsiveness
almost 4 years ago
My favorite thing in working with Matt was his responsiveness

My favorite thing in working with Matt was his responsiveness. Both buying and selling are such emotional and stressful times. Matt understands that and replies in a timely manner to put your mind. Any time I reached out, he would talk me through a process, even when he had already explained it to me the week or day before.

49 - 60 of 61
© 2026 RateMyAgent