Matt's profile

Matt's reviews

  5  
Matt has 65 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Matt's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, detail-oriented, hard-working, attentive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
It was a great experience to work with Matt Hinshaw!
9 months ago
It was a great experience to work with Matt Hinshaw!

Matt is a true professional, he kept me informed the entire process. I’ve been through this process both as seller and buyer a number of times. This by far was the best agent I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. You can trust Matt for your real estate needs whatever they may be.

Seller review
Gets things done.
11 months ago
Gets things done.

Matt like always just gets things done. No hesitation, always available to help and answer questions. I appreciate Matt and the experience that he has. Thank you.

Buyer review
I would definitely recommend Matt Hinshaw to anyone looking for a realtor in the Prescott AZ area.
11 months ago
I would definitely recommend Matt Hinshaw to anyone looking for a realtor in the Prescott AZ area.

I enjoyed working with Matt. Besides his knowledge in real estate, he is well versed in the events around the Prescott area. As we began to look at condos, he could fill me in on not only the condo complex, but what types of places that were in the surrounding area. He and the people he chose to work with, made getting through the process, comfortable. Information came in a timely manner and any questions I might have, were thoroughly answered. I would definitely recommend Matt Hinshaw to anyone looking for a realtor for the Prescott area.

Buyer review
Great realtor!
11 months ago
Great realtor!

Matt was very helpful and never rushed us. He answered all of our questions and returned our calls very quickly.

Seller review
MATT SOLD US even in a bad time!
about 1 year ago
MATT SOLD US even in a bad time!

Hired Matt to sell my home in chino in my divorce. Not only did Matt help me find people to fix up things I needed, he found GREAT workers as well! He dealt with lots of back and forth between parties on both sides and had to deal with quit a headache but managed to always answer or get right back with any questions. He sold our home in a timely matter as well in a rough market! 10/10 would recommend him!

Seller review
He is a great agent
about 1 year ago
He is a great agent

We did get the job done. My home was sold and all was good.

Buyer review
I rate Matt with 5 stars
about 1 year ago
I rate Matt with 5 stars

Matt represented both the seller and myself, the buyer. I felt he was very fair in assisting with inspectors, and the overall transaction.

Seller review
Matt is the best!
about 1 year ago
Matt is the best!

I have bought twice with Matt and sold once with Matt! He is knowledgeable about the Prescott market and is a full service agent offering a pain free experience. In my experience, his advice and support was unmatched and I felt like I received the best value as he represented me well. I felt he had the highest level of ethics and was extremely trustworthy. He also took care of all the details and I always knew exactly where the process stood. I never had to ask him for updates because he communicated fully with me in a timely manner. I felt safe and comfortable with him at every step. I would truly recommend him to close friends and family. He is fantastic! If I ever buy/sell again, Matt will always be my first choice!

Seller review
Fantastic!!!!!
about 1 year ago
Fantastic!!!!!

Matt is the best!! He is easy to work with, very knowledgable and very professional. He is on top of things and will always let you know what is going on with the buying of your property by either emailing you and giving you a call! DO NO hesitate to give this man a call!!!! I highly recommend!!!

Seller review
Matt is very dedicated
over 1 year ago
Matt is very dedicated

Matt started my listing on a piece of bare land in Seligman just over a year ago. The price started at 20k. Because of little action, the price continued to drop throughout the year. Matt has done a lot of work to keep my listing active. The property has sold for a price of 7k. Matt gets one side of the 5% commission. He has actually sustained a loss. However, his only goal has been to help me. He has certainly accomplished that goal. Our agreement was fully accomplished online. The process has been simple and accurate. Whenever you are seeking Real Estate help in the Prescott area, please give Matt a call first. He's also a wonderful person. Thank you Matt!

Buyer review
Matt is awesome, no better realtor in Prescott!
over 1 year ago
Matt is awesome, no better realtor in Prescott!

Matt Hinshaw in an excellent realtor and is so knowledgeable about the Prescott real estate market. He provided sound advice about neighborhoods and HOAs which made finding a great investment property very straightforward and stress-free. Matt's team kept every step of the process on track and we closed right on schedule. Matt is such a pleasant person to work with, and I would definitely choose Matt for future real estate needs.

13 - 24 of 65
© 2026 RateMyAgent