Matt's profile

Matt's reviews

  5  
Matt has 65 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Matt's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, detail-oriented, hard-working, attentive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Handles curveballs better than Randy Johnson!
1 day ago
Handles curveballs better than Randy Johnson!

This was a lengthy process, with challenges along the way and Matt handled them all! With a pending sale to an investor that dragged on and on (not Matt's fault!) to a listing on MLS that had more showings than we knew what do do with, Matt kept me informed at every turn. Once listed my house sold in less than 3 months, and Matt went above and beyond to handle the details to make everything go as smoothly as possible. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Matt as a buyer's or seller's agent!

Seller review
Matt's the best, hands down.
14 days ago
Matt's the best, hands down.

Matt is a agent that really knows real estate. His integrity, knowledge and personality are why I refer all my friends family and clients to Matt. You cant go wrong.

Seller review
Excellent communicator 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
17 days ago
Excellent communicator 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

We worked with Matt to sell our townhome, and we couldn't be happier with the experience. From our very first meeting, Matt brought a data-driven strategy to price and market our home perfectly. He made the entire listing and showing process incredibly stress-free and kept us informed at every single step. Thanks to his sharp negotiation skills, we closed the deal smoothly and efficiently. If you want a dedicated, professional, and highly effective realtor to sell your property, hire Matt Hinshaw.

Seller review
Knowledgeable, honest, and great response time; overall just easy to work with.
21 days ago
Knowledgeable, honest, and great response time; overall just easy to work with.

Matt did an amazing job in selling our townhome! He was very knowledgeable about the area and guided us through the entire selling process. He was available to answer any questions we had along the way. He really made the whole experience as stress-free as selling a house could be. Highly recommend!

Buyer review
Excellent Agent
3 months ago
Excellent Agent

Matt was very knowledgeable and experienced. Seamless process from beginning to end. He matched showings with our desires, I was very knowledgeable about the area, and negotiated with the seller very well.

Buyer review
Made the transaction painless
3 months ago
Made the transaction painless

Matt contacted me after another agent never responded. It took about a year to find a property that would work for us, I was kind of locked in on one property at the beginning. He was helpful throughout the time. He was very knowledgeable about all of the areas we were looking at and was very responsive to all of our questions. Great experience.

Seller review
Matt is an excellent communicator with a wealth of knowledge. I would highly recommend Matt Hinshaw!
5 months ago
Matt is an excellent communicator with a wealth of knowledge. I would highly recommend Matt Hinshaw!

My wife and I were left with devastating news April 2025. We now had to deal with a full estate to include the sale of beautiful home. Not being from Prescott Valley we were referred to Matt Hinshaw. This was probably the best recommendation and decision we could have made. Matt was there for us no matter what questions, issues or concerns we had. Matt would answer his phone day or night and even caught him when he was enjoying the outdoors on the weekend, yet he still answered. Matt is a down to earth realistic guy and willing to work through anything, not for himself but for the seller and/or buyer. Matt Hinshaw will definately be my choice in the future for any needs in Prescott / Prescott Valley area. Thank you Matt for a wonderful experience in such a bitter sweet hard time!

Seller review
Very Comunicative
8 months ago
Very Comunicative

Matt has a lot of experience in Relistate very communicative we sold our property in few months

Buyer review
Great experience
8 months ago
Great experience

Matt was awesome from start to finish. Very knowledgeable and quick to respond.

Buyer review
Excellent experience!
8 months ago
Excellent experience!

Matt was complete professional, knowledgeable in real estate and always had time for my questions and concerns. Very personable as well. I highly recommend.

1 - 12 of 65
© 2026 RateMyAgent