Kyle's profile

Kyle's reviews

  5  
Kyle has 131 reviewsacross 40 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kyle's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, resourceful, patient, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Kyle was recommended to us by family and he treated us like family
over 3 years ago
Kyle was recommended to us by family and he treated us like family

Kyle was recommended to us by family and he treated us like family. We had specific parameters of what we wanted in a new home, looking in a competitive area near Central Ave where the few coming available seemed to sell immediately to cash buyers.He was always quick and thorough with his communication and feedback, incredibly accommodating to our schedules and requests, and highly connected and knowledgeable of all St Pete neighborhoods. One of the best attributes, however, was feeling how sincere he was about making sure we found something we'd still love years down the road versus trying to make a sale and move on. I can keep going but there's plenty of proof here and with all the other perfect ratings to show you there's nobody better if you're looking to buy in St. Pete. Thanks for all of the help, Kyle!

Seller review
Kyle was great to work with
over 3 years ago
Kyle was great to work with

Kyle was great to work with. No high pressure or salesman like attitude. Easy going and very workable. Involved us in all aspects as needed. Has great ability to get the “word” out with extensive network. Loved the photographer he works with. Made the whole experience very easy. Communicates extremely well.

Buyer review
Kyle did an excellent job assisting with our investment property search
over 3 years ago
Kyle did an excellent job assisting with our investment property search

Kyle did an excellent job assisting with our investment property search. He was knowledgeable and proactive. He provides great resources and was very thorough. I would highly recommend Kyle to anyone looking in the St Petersburg area. He went above and beyond.

Buyer review
It was so easy and fun to work with Kyle as he found us our first home! From the start of conversati
over 3 years ago
It was so easy and fun to work with Kyle as he found us our first home! From the start of conversati

It was so easy and fun to work with Kyle as he found us our first home! From the start of conversations, to all our questions, to finding the perfect home for us, Kyle was so patient and helpful. Always available to answer our questions. Always proactively looking for homes on our behalf and setting up showings. This is the only realtor for our family.

Buyer review
Kyle was fantastic to work with
almost 4 years ago
Kyle was fantastic to work with

Kyle was fantastic to work with. My wife and I recently moved from Ohio and he was willing to work with us both while we were in and out of state. He provided great insight on moving to the area and even gave recommendations on things to check out during our visits. Kyle was prompt and polite and always made us feel like a priority throughout the whole process. When we did put in an offer on a house he had great suggestions as to what would make it stand out in this tough market. Through the closing process he was able to suggest inspectors and specialists for everything we needed. Start to finish we couldn't be happier with our experience. I would 100% recommend Kyle to anyone wanting to buy or sell a home in the area.

Buyer review
Kyle has now helped us with several real estate buys/sells and I couldn’t imagine a better person to
almost 4 years ago
Kyle has now helped us with several real estate buys/sells and I couldn’t imagine a better person to

Kyle has now helped us with several real estate buys/sells and I couldn’t imagine a better person to work with! He is very knowledgeable and could easily answer our plethora of questions… but if he couldn’t, he always got an answer and got right back to us. He has helped us navigate the hiccups that can occur and stay to our timelines. I trust Kyle implicitly, have known him for years and would have no reservations about recommending him to anyone for any real estate transaction!

Seller review
I was extremely pleased with, and very grateful for the quality of service that Kyle provided me thr
almost 4 years ago
I was extremely pleased with, and very grateful for the quality of service that Kyle provided me thr

I was extremely pleased with, and very grateful for the quality of service that Kyle provided me throughout the sale of my home. Having never sold a house before, I knew I would have a ton of questions for Kyle and a high level of nervousness and panic throughout the process. Let me tell you what….the nerves and panic basically disappeared after one meeting! All my initial questions were answered and Kyle definitely kept my nerves in check. The house was going to need to be listed within weeks of our first conversation and Kyle delivered. Some minor house repairs were required after I had accepted the offer on my home and Kyle found all the right people to do those repairs in unbelievable short timeframe. Even better, Kyle and his wife found time to go out of their way to attend my going away party!! Do yourself a favor if you are ever in the market to buy or sell a home. Hire this man!! I think you will agree with me that the whole experience of working with Kyle Hickey will be both phenomenal and rewarding!! Thank you again Kyle for everything. Mark Schroeder

Buyer review
Kyle was very professional and attentive throughout the home-buying process
about 4 years ago
Kyle was very professional and attentive throughout the home-buying process

Kyle was very professional and attentive throughout the home-buying process. He always answered out questions promptly and thoroughly and shared his expertise. He made sure the entire process went smoothly and that we were informed of the process and next steps from first contact through closing. I highly recommend using Kyle.

Buyer review
Kyle was very knowledgeable and attentive throughout the home-buying process
about 4 years ago
Kyle was very knowledgeable and attentive throughout the home-buying process

Kyle was very knowledgeable and attentive throughout the home-buying process. Responded to our our questions promptly and thoroughly. Did a great job negotiating repairs to be completed on the house before purchase. We cannot say enough good things about Kyle. I would highly recommend him to be your realtor.

Buyer review
Professional, personable, knowledgeable
about 4 years ago
Professional, personable, knowledgeable

Professional, personable, knowledgeable. Simply great to work with. Always available and always kept us informed and up to date with everything. Thankful and grateful for Kyle.

Buyer review
My husband and I can’t thank Kyle enough! We spent over 4 months looking for our first home in St
about 4 years ago
My husband and I can’t thank Kyle enough! We spent over 4 months looking for our first home in St

My husband and I can’t thank Kyle enough! We spent over 4 months looking for our first home in St. Pete. Kyle was there every step of the way and helped us go through tons of house showings, multiple offers, failed inspections, and finally a closing! He was patient, quickly responded to all of our questions and helped in every way possible. Kyle truly went above and beyond 😊 Highly recommended!!

Buyer review
Kyle is truly an amazing Realtor and we are so glad that we used him to purchase our new home! I jok
over 4 years ago
Kyle is truly an amazing Realtor and we are so glad that we used him to purchase our new home! I jok

Kyle is truly an amazing Realtor and we are so glad that we used him to purchase our new home! I joked with my husband many times that Kyle is an angel on earth for putting up with us throughout the process. We were moving to St. Pete from out of state and Kyle helped us tour homes even when we weren't in town. Once we found a house we loved (albeit site unseen), Kyle helped us negotiate a strong deal below asking price in such a wildly competitive market. We had to put a lot of trust in Kyle and we are so glad that we did. He walked us through all of the possible scenarios and was incredibly patient with us. Kyle also worked closely with my husband's company relocation team to help ensure that the process ran smoothly. Kyle is the best Realtor in St. Pete and I highly recommend him to anyone who is interested in buying a home in the St. Pete/Tampa area!

61 - 72 of 131
© 2026 RateMyAgent