John's profile

John's reviews

  5  
John has 38 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
John's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
John has been excellent to work with and will be my go-to advisor for all future things real estate
over 2 years ago
John has been excellent to work with and will be my go-to advisor for all future things real estate

John has been excellent to work with and will be my go-to advisor for all future things real estate. From the very beginning, John listened carefully to our criteria and provided us with valuable analysis and insights based on our specific needs. He seamlessly navigated us through some unusual challenges that quickly emerged and was very responsive no matter what time or day of the week it was. We were out of town for about half of the time between offer and closing, and John was able to keep a close eye on the entire process and step in for us when we were required to attend to things. I had a great experience with John and look forward to working with him in the future.

Seller review
Selling the home we built 40 years ago where we raised our boys and had so many wonderful memories w
over 2 years ago
Selling the home we built 40 years ago where we raised our boys and had so many wonderful memories w

Selling the home we built 40 years ago where we raised our boys and had so many wonderful memories was very difficult and emotional, finding a new home where we would be happy was not an easy job. John’s guidance and support helped us along the way through this transitional time in our lives, and we are very happy with the outcome. John was always available with advice, helping us make the right choices, recommending capable and reasonable service people for anything that needed to be repaired, altered or added. John was super patient with my “perfectionist” personality of inspecting and analyzing every home we considered purchasing. My husband and I trusted John fully and recommend him to everyone looking for a new home, or selling their dream home…John will be there for you physically and emotionally to hold your hand through the tough decisions in the kindest and most professional style you hope to find in a realtor. Thank you John, we will always be grateful for all you have done helping us through this not so easy journey.

Seller review
Selling the home we built 40 years ago where we raised our boys and had so many wonderful memories w
over 2 years ago
Selling the home we built 40 years ago where we raised our boys and had so many wonderful memories w

Selling the home we built 40 years ago where we raised our boys and had so many wonderful memories was very difficult and emotional, finding a new home where we would be happy was not an easy job. John’s guidance and support helped us along the way through this transitional time in our lives, and we are very happy with the outcome. John was always available with advice, helping us make the right choices, recommending capable and reasonable service people for anything that needed to be repaired, altered or added. John was super patient with my “perfectionist” personality of inspecting and analyzing every home we considered purchasing. My husband and I trusted John fully and recommend him to everyone looking for a new home, or selling their dream home…John will be there for you physically and emotionally to hold your hand through the tough decisions in the kindest and most professional style you hope to find in a realtor. Thank you John, we will always be grateful for all you have done helping us through this not so easy journey.

Seller review
I hired John because I knew in these tough market conditions, I needed an agent who was seasoned and
almost 3 years ago
I hired John because I knew in these tough market conditions, I needed an agent who was seasoned and

I hired John because I knew in these tough market conditions, I needed an agent who was seasoned and has been through these challenging times before. I knew a new agents would not be able to navigate this season we are in with the economy. Sure enough, we came accross also some other HOA and appraisal issues that only a seasoned professional could have navigated real solutions to keep us closing on time. I also knew my property had challenges we would face along the way before I even listed it, and I did not think twice about who I would choose to see me through this process. He always texts and answers calls and had alot of patience with my concerns. He is on top of the scenario start to finish and makes you feel like your a priority.

Seller review
I hired John because I knew in these tough market conditions, I needed an agent who was seasoned and
almost 3 years ago
I hired John because I knew in these tough market conditions, I needed an agent who was seasoned and

I hired John because I knew in these tough market conditions, I needed an agent who was seasoned and has been through these challenging times before. I knew a new agents would not be able to navigate this season we are in with the economy. Sure enough, we came accross also some other HOA and appraisal issues that only a seasoned professional could have navigated real solutions to keep us closing on time. I also knew my property had challenges we would face along the way before I even listed it, and I did not think twice about who I would choose to see me through this process. He always texts and answers calls and had alot of patience with my concerns. He is on top of the scenario start to finish and makes you feel like your a priority.

Buyer review
I called John on a Friday afternoon to ask if he would represent me as I was interested in a house I
over 3 years ago
I called John on a Friday afternoon to ask if he would represent me as I was interested in a house I

I called John on a Friday afternoon to ask if he would represent me as I was interested in a house I knew wouldn’t be on the market for long. Within and hour we had an approval from the tenants, and a viewing followed by a written offer all in the same evening. The offer was quickly accepted and the story goes on from here. John is extremely professional and informative. He operates with integrity and intense knowledge of todays market. I trust his judgement and recommendations on all levels. Not once did I feel like I was receiving misinformation. I trust John and will highly recommend him to my new friends in Florida! Outstanding work John! Respectfully Eileen Telford

Buyer review
John Pestalozzi is an added value to anyone that is looking to purchase a home or wishing to sell
almost 4 years ago
John Pestalozzi is an added value to anyone that is looking to purchase a home or wishing to sell

John Pestalozzi is an added value to anyone that is looking to purchase a home or wishing to sell. John is professional, thorough, consistently accountable but most importantly, On the Side of the Clients he serves. If you are looking for knowledgeable advice, give John a call for a consultation. Truthfully, one of the best first steps you will take when you are seeking to buy or looking to sell.

Seller review
John professionally guided us through the many steps required to get our home properly positioned to
about 4 years ago
John professionally guided us through the many steps required to get our home properly positioned to

John professionally guided us through the many steps required to get our home properly positioned to fetch top dollar once it hit the market. John made helped to make the selling process so much easier through his guidance and real estate expertise. We appreciated all of his suggestions and hard work that led to us closing successfully for well over our list price in a very short amount of time. John is so professional and so personable that the whole process was a pleasure. I would highly recommend John to anyone considering buying or selling a home.

Seller review
John successfully guided us through many steps in getting our home ready to put on the market and we
about 4 years ago
John successfully guided us through many steps in getting our home ready to put on the market and we

John successfully guided us through many steps in getting our home ready to put on the market and were made so much easier with John's expertise and guidance. We appreciate all of his suggestions and hard work that led to us closing successfully for well over our list price. John is so professional and so personable that the whole process was a pleasure. I would highly recommend John to anyone considering buying or selling a home.

Seller review
John is a seasoned professional
over 4 years ago
John is a seasoned professional

John is a seasoned professional. He has great knowledge of the greater Tampa Bay market, and great knowledge of the industry as a whole through his many years of experience. John will be attentive to your needs and keep you informed throughout the entire process. You won’t find a better agent to help navigate through the buying or selling process. We highly recommend him!

25 - 36 of 38
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent