John's profile

John's reviews

  5  
John has 34 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
John's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Best-in-Class Real Estate Experience
24 days ago
Best-in-Class Real Estate Experience

Working with John was truly an exceptional experience from start to finish. He recently helped sell my parents’ home, and I can say without hesitation that his professionalism and expertise are second to none. From the very beginning, he demonstrated an impressive depth of knowledge about the market and a clear mastery of the home-selling process. Every detail was handled with care and precision—nothing was overlooked. His thoroughness gave me complete confidence at every stage, and he consistently anticipated questions or challenges before they even arose. What stood out most was his meticulous approach. From preparing the home for listing to negotiating offers, everything was executed flawlessly. He communicated clearly, kept me informed, and made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. Beyond his technical expertise, John was simply wonderful to work with—patient, responsive, and genuinely invested in achieving the best possible outcome for our family. If you're looking for someone who is truly best-in-class, highly knowledgeable, and deeply committed to excellence, I cannot recommend him highly enough. Everything about the experience was, quite honestly, perfect. Thank you, John!

Buyer review
Above and Beyond—The Realtor You Want on Your Side
4 months ago
Above and Beyond—The Realtor You Want on Your Side

We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor for our condo purchase in Redington Beach. John is truly amazing at what he does. From day one, he was always digging for information, asking the right questions, and making sure nothing slipped through the cracks. John’s diligence and meticulous attention to detail gave us so much confidence throughout the entire process. He went above and beyond to get clear answers, advocate for us, and ensure we were making a fully informed decision. Buying property can be stressful, but his professionalism, persistence, and thoroughness made it a smooth and positive experience. If you want a realtor who works incredibly hard and genuinely has your best interests at heart, look no further than John Pestalozzi. Highly recommend!

Buyer review
Went above & beyond!
4 months ago
Went above & beyond!

Me and my husband found out we had to move out of state for a career promotion, and we had less than 2 months to close on a home and move in. We only had 1 weekend to spare in between the holidays, so within a few days of talking, John had 2 days full of showings lined up and organized. He guided us to look at different areas/ neighborhoods of Tampa - giving us market knowledge along the way. He listened to our "must haves" but also helped us compromise to find the perfect home. The home we purchased had a few items that needed repair- with us being out of state it was hard to facilitate these estimates, etc. John went above and beyond to get those items done for us before and after the house transaction. We couldn't recommend him more! Very knowledgeable, not pushy, and made time for us/ worked with our schedules to get this done very quickly.

Seller review
John Pestalozzi is an Excellent realtor!
5 months ago
John Pestalozzi is an Excellent realtor!

I have bought and sold many properties over my lifetime and without question John was the best . He’s very impressive and very personable. He knows the area, he knows the issues, and fixes everything . He had a solution ready for every problem that came up. I was SO lucky to get him as a referral . Really, there was just no comparison . I recently worked with John Pestalozzi to sell my beachfront condo in Indian Rocks Beach, Florida, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From start to finish, John was wonderful to work with—professional, calm, and always one step ahead. He handled every detail of the sale with real skill and intelligence. John clearly knows the local market, and he guided me through pricing, showings, negotiations, and closing with confidence and clarity. He was always available to answer questions, kept me informed throughout the process, and made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and manageable. Thanks to John, my condo sold quickly and the entire process was seamless. I highly recommend John Pestalozzi to anyone looking to buy or sell property in the Indian Rocks Beach area.

Buyer review
My family has completed several transactions with John, both as buyers and sellers
5 months ago
My family has completed several transactions with John, both as buyers and sellers

My family has completed several transactions with John, both as buyers and sellers. His knowledge of the market, home buying process, and structural make up of a home, are unmatched. We felt confident each time he represented us, knowing we would end up with the best possible outcome with having an agent that would go above and beyond to advocate for us. He always made sure to take our needs into consideration and helped us weigh the pros and cons of each deal. He is incredibly responsive and kind, and I would never think of doing business with anyone else in the Tampa Bay area. We are eternally grateful for all he has done in helping us to find our forever home. You will not regret hiring him as an agent! We can't thank you enough, John.

Seller review
John Pestalozzi Jr has always done a great job!
5 months ago
John Pestalozzi Jr has always done a great job!

John Pestalozzi Jr. has always done a great job for us. Relocating out of state twice brings it's own set of challenges. We have complete confidence in John, walking us through all the steps and having honest and considerate conversations with us as both sellers and buyers. John not only excels in his business, but also has the professional connections with other business to assist during all the aspects of home buying and selling process. I would absolutely recommend Westward Real Estate.

Buyer review
The GOAT of Tampa Bay
5 months ago
The GOAT of Tampa Bay

John is the GOAT in the Tampa Bay real estate market. His experience and knowledge is clear from the moment you meet him. John is my only go to for all my real estate work.

Seller review
John is an excellent realtor
5 months ago
John is an excellent realtor

John is an excellent realtor. He is personable, responsive and he knows the business like the back of his hand. If you have any doubts or concerns he does a great job at putting your mind at ease. We would choose him again and again.

Buyer review
Words do not even fully begin to encapsulate John's value as a real estate agent
6 months ago
Words do not even fully begin to encapsulate John's value as a real estate agent

Words do not even fully begin to encapsulate John's value as a real estate agent. His extensive knowledge of the market, paired with his expertise when it comes to evaluating the condition of a home, are truly unmatched. Our family has worked with John on several real estate transactions - both as buyers and sellers. He will listen to your needs, and then dedicate himself to helping you weigh out the pros and cons of the home and give informative suggestions on how to proceed. After several years of his continued support, we grew to feel incredibly confident and even cocky at times, knowing we had him representing, negotiating, and advocating for us along the way. He has a way of taking the pressure off the home buying process, and goes to extreme lengths on the back end, to make sure his clients are positioned to bring the best offer or counter offer to the table. You will NEVER find an agent in the Tampa Bay area that is better than him! He will answer your every question, keep you informed throughout, and representing you in a way that makes it look easy when you know it's anything but! We are so incredibly grateful to have worked with him over the last several years and we HIGHLY recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. John, we sincerely thank you for not only your business but the kindness you have brought to this process. We know you will continue to find success and wish you the best in all future business endeavors!

Buyer review
John Pestalozzi represented us when purchasing a townhouse in the Country Way area of Tampa
6 months ago
John Pestalozzi represented us when purchasing a townhouse in the Country Way area of Tampa

John Pestalozzi represented us when purchasing a townhouse in the Country Way area of Tampa. He was very knowledgeable about the values in the area, which put our minds at ease. Additionally, we were planning after the closing to rent the property. So, John researched the rental market to determine the viability. John handled the tenant placement and lease. He has been exceptional in finding us tenants who meet our criteria for all of our investment properties. John Pestalozzi is easy to contact and very knowledgeable about the real estate market in the Tampa Bay area. We will definitely contact him in the future for all of our real estate transactions!

1 - 12 of 34
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent