John's profile

John's reviews

  5  
John has 38 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
John's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Words do not even fully begin to encapsulate John's value as a real estate agent
9 months ago
Words do not even fully begin to encapsulate John's value as a real estate agent

Words do not even fully begin to encapsulate John's value as a real estate agent. His extensive knowledge of the market, paired with his expertise when it comes to evaluating the condition of a home, are truly unmatched. Our family has worked with John on several real estate transactions - both as buyers and sellers. He will listen to your needs, and then dedicate himself to helping you weigh out the pros and cons of the home and give informative suggestions on how to proceed. After several years of his continued support, we grew to feel incredibly confident and even cocky at times, knowing we had him representing, negotiating, and advocating for us along the way. He has a way of taking the pressure off the home buying process, and goes to extreme lengths on the back end, to make sure his clients are positioned to bring the best offer or counter offer to the table. You will NEVER find an agent in the Tampa Bay area that is better than him! He will answer your every question, keep you informed throughout, and representing you in a way that makes it look easy when you know it's anything but! We are so incredibly grateful to have worked with him over the last several years and we HIGHLY recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. John, we sincerely thank you for not only your business but the kindness you have brought to this process. We know you will continue to find success and wish you the best in all future business endeavors!

Buyer review
John Pestalozzi represented us when purchasing a townhouse in the Country Way area of Tampa
9 months ago
John Pestalozzi represented us when purchasing a townhouse in the Country Way area of Tampa

John Pestalozzi represented us when purchasing a townhouse in the Country Way area of Tampa. He was very knowledgeable about the values in the area, which put our minds at ease. Additionally, we were planning after the closing to rent the property. So, John researched the rental market to determine the viability. John handled the tenant placement and lease. He has been exceptional in finding us tenants who meet our criteria for all of our investment properties. John Pestalozzi is easy to contact and very knowledgeable about the real estate market in the Tampa Bay area. We will definitely contact him in the future for all of our real estate transactions!

Buyer review
John has helped us locate and purchase two vacation homes in the Tampa Bay area
9 months ago
John has helped us locate and purchase two vacation homes in the Tampa Bay area

John has helped us locate and purchase two vacation homes in the Tampa Bay area. He is extremely knowledgeable and very responsive. He has his pulse on the real estate market, and I used him as a trusted advisor when we entered negotiations to purchase. I have no doubt he got us the best deal that could have been had.

Buyer review
We have worked with John twice in our search for a vacation home in Florida
9 months ago
We have worked with John twice in our search for a vacation home in Florida

We have worked with John twice in our search for a vacation home in Florida. We have found him to be extremely responsive, and his knowledge of the real estate market is very deep. He is a very good negotiator, and I have no doubt he has saved me money during those critical negotiations when making offers. If I have future needs in the local market, John would be the first person I would call. He is a very trusted advisor, and I appreciate his efforts on our behalf.

Buyer review
This is my third time using John and I came back because everything was smooth with no surprises
11 months ago
This is my third time using John and I came back because everything was smooth with no surprises

This is my third time using John and I came back because everything was smooth with no surprises. He is very thorough and communicates constantly. He even suggested a lower bid on my new place than I was planning on and it was accepted. I have friends that have used him also and we were all more than satisfied. All I can do is recommend this guy and I really don't think you would be disappointed........

Buyer review
John is so thorough it amazed me
11 months ago
John is so thorough it amazed me

John is so thorough it amazed me. He is on top of everything and as issues popped up he took care of them as quickly as possible. This is the 3rd time I have used him and if I need to sell there will be a fourth. I highly recommend this guy.

Buyer review
John is a true partner!  John's helped my family purchase several properties and each time he exceed
about 1 year ago
John is a true partner! John's helped my family purchase several properties and each time he exceed

John is a true partner! John's helped my family purchase several properties and each time he exceeds expectations. His patience, knowledge of the market as a whole as well as local areas, is truly unmatched. He's goes above and beyond and ensures you understand the in's and out's all along the way. He's a true partner, who makes things happen.

Seller review
Thank you John! Such a fantastic experiemce and so very knowledgeable
over 2 years ago
Thank you John! Such a fantastic experiemce and so very knowledgeable

Thank you John! Such a fantastic experiemce and so very knowledgeable. We had the best outcome and greatly appriate your service excellence!! We highly recommend your realtor services!! Our home sold at a top price and John was there every step of the way! Best regards, The Salliers

Buyer review
John has been excellent to work with and will be my go-to advisor for all future things real estate
over 2 years ago
John has been excellent to work with and will be my go-to advisor for all future things real estate

John has been excellent to work with and will be my go-to advisor for all future things real estate. From the very beginning, John listened carefully to our criteria and provided us with valuable analysis and insights based on our specific needs. He seamlessly navigated us through some unusual challenges that quickly emerged and was very responsive no matter what time or day of the week it was. We were out of town for about half of the time between offer and closing, and John was able to keep a close eye on the entire process and step in for us when we were required to attend to things. I had a great experience with John and look forward to working with him in the future.

13 - 24 of 38
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent