Jeffrey Cave

Jeffrey Cave

NAR: SL3536045
  •   5   (31 reviews)

About Jeffrey

Meet Jeff Cave, a highly recommended real estate professional with a comprehensive understanding of the Sarasota County market. Recently transitioning to a new role as a Sales Associate for Homes by Towne, Jeff now specializes in selling semi-custom homes in the highly anticipated Shellstone community. With an impressive 5-star rating across multiple reviews, Jeff has built a strong reputation as a pricing expert and trusted advisor. Over the past year, he successfully negotiated the sale of 24 properties, focusing primarily on Single-Family homes and Villas. His strategic approach and deep market insight resulted in an average sale price of around $708,000, with Single-Family homes averaging over $1 million. Now focused on the next chapter of his career at Shellstone, Jeff continues to offer personalized attention and expert guidance to every client, whether they're building from the ground up or tailoring a semi-custom home. His dedication, sharp analytical skills, and commitment to excellence ensure buyers achieve the best possible outcomes in Sarasota County's dynamic real estate market. Connect with Jeff today and discover why he remains a top-tier professional trusted by buyers throughout Sarasota County and beyond.

Jeffrey's reviews

  5  
Jeffrey has 31 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 6.
Review Jeffrey
11 months ago
Second experience excellent!

Jeff previously handled selling our house and he did a terrific job doing so. He also represented me in purchasing my new house and I couldn’t be happier with the service (and the house). Jeff negotiated a good deal on the house, attended all inspections, and made sure the builder was on top of items that needed to be addressed. He is direct but always respectful and considerate, which goes a long way toward getting things done. Super happy!

12 months ago
Exceptional Realtor Who Helped Us Find Our Dream Home in Sarasota

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Jeff Cave as our realtor, and we couldn’t be more grateful for his dedication and support in helping us find our dream home. From start to finish, Jeff was outstanding. He never rushed us, never pressured us, and instead gave my wife and me all the time and space we needed to make the right decision. He showed us countless homes and always made us feel like we were his top priority—especially when we were in town, dedicating entire days to our search. Jeff’s professionalism, patience, and deep knowledge of the Sarasota market truly set him apart. If you're looking to make Sarasota your home, I can’t recommend Jeff enough. He made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and enjoyable. Thank you, Jeff!

12 months ago
Outstanding service and results in a challenging market

Jeff Cave exceeded all expectations in selling our home in Sarasota. Despite a shifting market, Jeff remained confident but also appropriately managed expectations about what was realistic in this market. His communication was top-notch—never felt out of the loop, and he always made time to answer questions and provide guidance through key decisions. He also had a good way with delivering difficult information (e.g. reducing sale price), and I appreciated his directness and realism—it ultimately sold the home! Jeff’s professionalism, integrity, and deep understanding of the local market set him apart—wouldn’t hesitate to work with him again or recommend him to anyone needing a trusted real estate professional.

about 1 year ago
The Best in the Game

In the highly competitive world of SWFL Real Estate, Jeff Cave is the best in the game. Jeff is a true professional that was there for us every step of the way. He answered every question,text, and phone call quickly and precisely. He took countless pictures and videos during our building process to keep us up to date. We will without a doubt work with Jeff for any of our Real Estate needs in the future.

about 1 year ago
Outstanding experience!

I highly recommend Jeff Cave for anyone looking for a realtor. Jeff is extremely knowledgeable of the market and everything that factors in to making a decision on your home purchase. I also was impressed with his negotiation skills that greatly reduced our lot premium and significantly reduced our closing costs. Jeff was available and committed to the process from our first meeting through the closing of our new home. It was challenging being engaged in the construction of our home from 1500 miles away but Jeff was always available to attend inspections, speak to the construction manager, take pictures and video or whatever task was needed at the time. Thank you Jeff for your outstanding effort on our behalf!

about 1 year ago
Excellent coverage and support

I really appreciated the attention and support from Jeff Cave and Laura Long. They made my purchase quite easy and we’re very quick to resolve any questions or issues. I look forward to working with them again in the future.

Show all 31 reviews

Jeffrey's properties

Jeffrey has 4 properties for sale and sold 10 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMar 27, 2026
$560,000
9165 Florida Rock Trail
Sarasota FL 34240
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HOMES BY TOWNE REALTY INC and PREFERRED SHORE
Pending
$1,374,900
811 Blue Shell Loop
Sarasota FL 34240
4
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HOMES BY TOWNE REALTY INC
SoldMar 5, 2026
$2,017,500
1320 Ivory Tusk Circle
Sarasota FL 34240
4
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HOMES BY TOWNE REALTY INC
SoldFeb 20, 2026
$700,000
9149 Florida Rock Trail
Sarasota FL 34240
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HOMES BY TOWNE REALTY INC and THE SUNSHINE STATE COMPANY
Show all 14 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent