Holly's profile

Holly's reviews

  5  
Holly has 95 reviewsacross 49 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Holly's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, dedicated, patient, clear communication, supportive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Always comes through!!
about 1 year ago
Always comes through!!

Once again Holly came through. Had a property that due to circumstances beyond our control needed a cash buyer. Holly was able to secure a buyer due to her relentless persistence. She is definitely anyone’s go to agent!!

Buyer review
Knowledgeable, responsive , and easy to work with
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable, responsive , and easy to work with

Holly is always quick to respond, is so attentive to my budget and exactly the types of houses I was looking for. Not showing me things that didn’t fit my criteria. Gives me lots of good advice regarding ideas for renovations. She also is very honest about pitfalls or potential issues with homes we looked at. She’s well connected and found all the right professionals to make the inspection and purchase process easy. She’s a gem and would choose her again as my agent in a NY minute!

Buyer review
Knowledgeable, Kind, and Professional
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable, Kind, and Professional

I'm delighted to share my incredibly positive experience working with Holly Gerchen as my real estate agent. From our very first meeting, it was clear that Holly possesses a truly vast depth of knowledge in her field. She navigated every aspect of the process with remarkable expertise, from understanding market trends to intricate legal details, and always had insightful answers to my questions. Holly's professionalism, dedication, and genuine care for her clients shine through in everything she does. She made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable, always keeping me informed and empowered. I highly recommend Holly Gerchen to anyone looking for a real estate agent who is not only exceptionally knowledgeable but also a pleasure to work with. She truly goes above and beyond! Sincerely, Debbie

Buyer review
Exemplary top-tier service!
over 1 year ago
Exemplary top-tier service!

Holly is the ultimate professional. She has guided us step-by-step through the showing, inspecting, negotiating, and buying processes. Holly understood what we were looking for and tailored properties to our budget and needs. Her tenure as an agent is well demonstrated by her knowledge of the market itself, and her honest advice helped us to be confident in our decisions. We are incredibly grateful for the service that her and the team provided to us during this process!

Seller review
More than an agent. A gymnast...
over 1 year ago
More than an agent. A gymnast...

I learned a lot about Holly as she handled the sale of our condo. But she never mentioned that she had experience as a gymnast. Holly, metaphorically, did handsprings for us, and stuck the landing (and the closing). When I tell you the degree of difficulty was high, well you'll just have to take my word for it, because I am only allowed 2000 characters in this post. I'll tell you though that many last minute matters surfaced as time expired and Holly was there for us whenever we needed her 24/7. If you need Holly at 3 a.m. (we actually didn't) she will respond. Get ready for lots more customers Holly and maybe less sleep.

Seller review
Knowledgeable, Kind, and Professional
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable, Kind, and Professional

I'm delighted to share my incredibly positive experience working with Holly Gerchen as my real estate agent. From our very first meeting, it was clear that Holly possesses a truly vast depth of knowledge in her field. She navigated every aspect of the process with remarkable expertise, from understanding market trends to intricate legal details, and always had insightful answers to my questions. Holly's professionalism, dedication, and genuine care for her clients shine through in everything she does. She made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable, always keeping me informed and empowered. I highly recommend Holly Gerchen to anyone looking for a real estate agent who is not only exceptionally knowledgeable but also a pleasure to work with. She truly goes above and beyond!

Seller review
Holly is the best.
over 1 year ago
Holly is the best.

Holly knows the market. She is smart, intuitive and delightful. Hire her and follow her advice. You won’t be sorry. She knows how to price a home and she knows how to sell it. She quickly understands what is important to you in looking at homes. She sees details in the homes you are looking at that you would miss. If you have questions about a property, she will get you answers, quickly. She has great relationships with other realtors. There weren’t many homes on the market when we were looking. Holly took the extra step of looking at properties that had been taken off the market and queried the agents about their potential availability. I was impressed and grateful. Work with Holly. She is simply the best.

Buyer review
When I Think of Holly, I Think of Hemingway
over 1 year ago
When I Think of Holly, I Think of Hemingway

Hemingway wrote "The Old Man and The Sea." Until Holly came along, I was an old man at sea. You see (sea), I am 73 and my wife, Sally, wanted to look for a new home. I liked the home we had. It sat atop our five-story building in the Central West End with large windows and a view of the Gateway Arch accompanied most mornings with a brilliant sunrise. But Sally wanted a layout conducive to hosting more family members overnight, especially the grandchildren. Hard to say no to that. Still, I was reluctant to leave. I figured I'd stay at sea till Sally got over it. Then Holly arrived with her lifeboat. No life preservers, but on board was a sign for an open house, which attracted many people, but most of the rest of the necessities were contained in Holly's head, her contacts, her savvy with condo buying and selling, her accessibility --- there for us 24-7 -- her candor, her empathy. But you know what I liked best. She laughed at my jokes even when Sally didn't. Well, yes, she probably does that for every client. But those laughs were hearty ones, so I'll take them. We looked around and found a wonderful place. Our bid was not accepted, though not Holly's fault. In fact, lucky us, the place got nailed by the tornado that blew through town on May 16. So Holly in a way was prescient. I think she knew. She found us a place on the eighth floor of a high rise in Clayton. It was very much unlike our loft. Many more residents., 21 floors They call it a vertical community. But she knew we would like the amenities, a full-service staff, a deck where we can grill and watch people swim and play tennis across the street. Easy access to bike paths. Our place even has an enormous copier for all to use, and a paper shredder to destroy any damning evidence we have on hand. The building manager is almost our best friend already. When the tornado blew through, it came literally within yards south of our building. I am certain Holly knew it would. Looking for an agent? Hire this woman.

Buyer review
Expert Experience
over 1 year ago
Expert Experience

So helpful at every turn

Buyer review
Holly’s market knowledge, communication and professionalism are all superb
almost 2 years ago
Holly’s market knowledge, communication and professionalism are all superb

As a first time homebuyer, Holly’s experience, knowledge about the market and what to look for when buying a home really helped us land our dream home in the neighborhood we wanted and at a great price. Holly is extremely knowledgeable, and a great communicator. She patiently walked us through every step in the process. We were purchasing from out of state and Holly’s expertise combined with her attention to detail really helped us feel like we had a reliable ally who represented our interests very well.

Seller review
3rd transaction with Holly
about 2 years ago
3rd transaction with Holly

Very knowledgeable found and sold property within 30 days got above market value or right on market value. Holly is the perfer Agent for our organization in the st.louis area.

Buyer review
Satisfied buyer
about 2 years ago
Satisfied buyer

Holly Gerchen was immensely patient with my seemingly endless questions. She asked questions on my behalf that i didn’t think of to make sure the home we were touring didn’t have hidden issues or was updated to code . Once we got into escrow, Holly Gerchen was diligent in making sure all inspections were in place, communicated with the seller’s agent, and kept me informed on a daily basis. I am not sure how you can have a better agent than Holly Gerchen and her entire team. If i ever need to sell my current home, i know exactly who to call when the time comes =)

13 - 24 of 95
© 2026 RateMyAgent