Felicity Rollins

Felicity Rollins

Broker: 3216696
  •   5   (19 reviews)
  • top20badge

    Recognized for being in the Top 20% for customer satisfaction.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

About Felicity

Welcome to Buy In The Bay Realty Group! Ranked in the Top 10% of Tampa Bay agents in 2017 and Top 12% in 2025, with 20+ years of experience, I bring seasoned insight and a results-driven approach to every transaction. I’m Felicity Rollins, founder of Buy In The Bay Realty Group, LLC, established in 2017 to provide strategic, high-level real estate representation rooted in expertise and long-term client relationships. Two Decades of Market Experience: For more than 20 years, I’ve represented buyers, sellers, investors, developers, and builders across Florida, Massachusetts, and Virginia. My background includes residential resale, luxury properties, land acquisition, townhome and community development, new construction sales, and investment strategy. This breadth of experience allows me to anticipate challenges, solve problems proactively, and negotiate from a position of strength. $800+ Million in Closed Sales: Throughout my career, I’ve facilitated more than $800 million in residential real estate transactions, including homes, townhome developments, and land. That figure reflects strategy, precision, and a commitment to delivering measurable outcomes — not just transactions. Shaping Communities Across Tampa Bay I’ve played a key role in the growth and sales of well-known communities such as: The Arlington St. Pete The Exchange at Westshore Westshore Village The District on 9th These projects required coordination with developers, builders, marketing teams, and buyers to ensure successful launches and sales execution. My specialties include: Buyer Representation – Strategic acquisition guidance and market positioning Seller Representation – Data-driven pricing and targeted marketing New Construction – From pre-construction planning through final closing Investment Properties – Portfolio building and long-term strategy Development Consulting – Sales positioning and community strategy Blockchain Transactions – Experience facilitating cryptocurrency real estate purchases, including Bitcoin and Ethereum Education & Professional Foundation Bachelor’s Degree in Real Estate and Management University of Massachusetts Amherst – Isenberg School of Management University of South Florida Exchange Program Participant Industry Recognition 2006 Major Achievement in Marketing Excellence – $33M in sales Top Producer in New Home Sales Top Customer Satisfaction Recognition Keller Williams 2013 “Mega Agent in the Making” Professional Affiliations National Association of Realtors Florida Association of Realtors Greater Tampa Association of Realtors At Buy In The Bay Realty Group, real estate is not treated as a transaction — it’s treated as a strategy. If you’re buying, selling, investing, or developing, my role is simple: protect your position, maximize opportunity, and execute with precision.

Felicity's reviews

  5  
Felicity has 19 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 6.
Review Felicity
Buyer review
Calm in the chaos of the storm!
about 1 month ago
Calm in the chaos of the storm!

Felicity was wonderful in helping with the purchase of our new home. She knew and advised of very helpful mortgage lenders, home inspectors and insurance companies. Further, she was able to help with the self-listed seller as there was extra steps she had to take to make it a seamless process for us. We now have our dream home-Thank you, Felicity!

Buyer review
Felicity was an amazing buyers' agent!!
4 months ago
Felicity was an amazing buyers' agent!!

Felicity has an very in depth knowledge of the Tampa real-estate market. We were facing a very tight timeline to find a suitable home, and Felicity went above and beyond to make that happen. She is a delight to work with, very responsive, and goes above and beyond to find properties that her buyers are interested in. We would not hesitate to use her again, and are very happy with our purchase!

Seller review
All Star Agent
6 months ago
All Star Agent

Felicity did an amazing job of helping me sell my house. She kept me informed on the market trends, and enhancements I could make to help the house sell! She possesses incredible knowledge about the area, knows how to get things done, and is always available to discuss options! Could not have asked for a better agent during my home selling experience!

Buyer review
Beyond Excellent!
7 months ago
Beyond Excellent!

Felicity is the best choice for finding the right home! She has a wealth of knowledge about the Tampa Bay area and provides great insight when it comes to finding the perfect place. She made the buying process run smoothly and offered valuable guidance every step of the way. Her ability to bring your vision to life and her level of commitment are truly immeasurable. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to make the Tampa Bay area their home!

Buyer review
Dream Home Finder
9 months ago
Dream Home Finder

Without Felicity's depth of knowledge of the Tampa Bay area, her ability to ask the right questions, and steer us toward the right areas and finally the right houses was invaluable. Her ability to hear our criteria, pinpoint locations and then finally negotiate all the stickiness of our final purchase was unmatched. Felicity is warm and funny with just the right amount of straight-forward honesty. We met many other realtors at open-houses during our search and Felicity's professionalism was unmatched. During the search, she had the vision to show us potential in properties, discuss possibilities, and how good of fit it would be for us. I believe she understood our needs better than we did! We are so fortunate to be able to work with her.

Buyer review
Great Experience for a First-Time Home Buyer
about 1 year ago
Great Experience for a First-Time Home Buyer

I can't say enough good things about my experience working with Felicity as my realtor! As a first-time home buyer, she was incredibly patient with me throughout the entire process—even when I kept changing my mind about what I wanted. She never made me feel rushed or pressured and truly wanted me to find the perfect home. She was available, even at odd hours, to show me houses and answer all my questions. Thanks to her dedication and support, I finally found the perfect place to call home. I highly recommend her to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, kind, and committed realtor!

Show all 19 reviews

Felicity's properties

Felicity has 4 properties for sale and sold 8 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 22, 2026
$527,000
1303 West Carissa Court
Tampa FL 33604
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of BUY IN THE BAY REALTY GROUP LLC
SoldMay 1, 2026
$899,000
5807 Schooner Way
Town 'n' Country FL 33615
4
2
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of BLUE LIGHTHOUSE REALTY INC and BUY IN THE BAY REALTY GROUP LLC
For Sale
$850,000
3704 W Platt St
Tampa FL 33609
4
3
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of BUY IN THE BAY REALTY GROUP LLC
SoldFeb 5, 2026
$789,900
1618 Magdalene Manor Dr
Lake Magdalene FL 33613
4
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX PREMIER GROUP and BUY IN THE BAY REALTY GROUP LLC
Show all 12 properties
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent