Cathy Rustin

Cathy Rustin

Licensed Real Estate Agent at RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP member of Catherine Rustin Team
  •   5   (12 reviews)

About Cathy

The Rustin Luxury Home Team's focus on integrity, hard work, and stellar service has propelled them to one of the area’s leading real estate teams. Specializing in Sarasota waterfront homes, Cathy Rustin is a certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS) and member of the Institute for Luxury Home Marketing Million Dollar Guild. Cathy is a Summa Cum Laude graduate from the University of Georgia in advertising and marketing. Before moving to Florida, she served as a commercial printing broker in Atlanta Georgia for over 35 years, while maintaining a real estate and associate broker’s license. Cathy brought this same entrepreneurial spirit and passion to her real estate career in Sarasota, earning the Rookie of the Year award as well as the Gold Circle award for achieving more than $5 million in sales volume in her first year as a local agent. Cathy is passionate about giving back to the community and serves on the Board of Directors for the Florida Winefest/Caring for Children’s Charities, the Operations Board for the Pines of Sarasota, and the Board of Advisors of the Conservation Foundation of the Gulf Coast. She enjoys photography, scuba diving, boating, bicycling, and traveling. Cathy and her team will work extremely hard to offer seamless assistance to you for every aspect of your home purchase or sale.

Cathy's reviews

  5  
Cathy has 12 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 6.
Review Cathy
over 5 years ago
Cathy was so professional, energetic and aggressive in selling our home

Cathy was so professional, energetic and aggressive in selling our home. We listed when Covid hit and it didn’t stop her from finding ways for potential buyers to see our house. We hit unexpected challenges along the way, yet Cathy tried very very hard to work around them. Despite the challenges, our home got sold and we are so appreciative of her hard work. She kept us informed every step and quickly responded to all our questions and concerns. Thank you Cathy!

over 5 years ago
100% on top of finalization.. All issues.

I enjoyed the experience. She listens well and executes. Excellent knowledge of Sarasota, and has many contacts. Great follow up skills from beginning to the end. Always stays positive. Easy to get along with. There are many more details to purchasing a house, than sometimes you consider. She got all the details down pat.. Not just sell and run, but complete follow though above and beyond. If selling or buying she is great at her job.

almost 6 years ago
Cathy Rustin was a great find! I had walked into a home she was showing and was so impressed with h

Cathy Rustin was a great find! I had walked into a home she was showing and was so impressed with how she staged the home and presented the opportunity … I asked her to be my family’s realtor on the spot! Cathy listed our Sarasota home within a week, had it under contract within days of the listing, coached us through the closing date, and was an excellent communicator throughout the process. By the way, she did so through the COVID crisis. We are so thankful!

almost 6 years ago
Cathy is amazing

Cathy is amazing. Her professionalism and dedication to us as clients was outstanding. She gave us a professional presentation describing our property, the area, the comparable homes etc. She then helped us determine a fair price, advertised the property and sold it within THREE DAYS. She was there every step of the way from listing to closing. You can go with the rest or go with the best. Cathy is THE BEST.

about 6 years ago
If you are looking to buy or sell a home, I would contact Cathy Rustin without any hesitation

If you are looking to buy or sell a home, I would contact Cathy Rustin without any hesitation.. Cathy successfully and quite professionally handled the purchase of our dream house and the sale of our existing one. Her thoughts on buying and selling negotiations were nothing short of spot on, culminating in both properties closing in a month! Cathy is simply a great person with tremendous talents.

over 6 years ago
We had the pleasure of working with Cathy Rustin on the purchase of our forever home , and the sale

We had the pleasure of working with Cathy Rustin on the purchase of our forever home , and the sale of our current home. She is a true professional in every manner, has a great personality and integrity. She managed to negotiate a great buy for us, all while selling our current house at list price, in a matter of days. We would highly recommend her for both the sale and/or purchase of your next home. She is smart and a working agent, that Will gets it done’ and will have YOUR best interest in mind. We feel lucky to have met her. Thank you

Show all 12 reviews

Cathy's properties

Cathy has 5 properties for sale and sold 2 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$539,000
1484 Dorgali Dr
Sarasota FL 34238
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of FIRST LIGHT REAL ESTATE
SoldFeb 12, 2026
$727,500
305/260 Hidden Bay Drive
Osprey FL 34229
3
3
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of FIRST LIGHT REAL ESTATE and RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP
For Sale
$700,000
602/242 Hidden Bay Drive
Osprey FL 34229
2
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of FIRST LIGHT REAL ESTATE
SoldNov 7, 2025
$535,000
259 Golden Harbour Trail
Bradenton FL 34212
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of FIRST LIGHT REAL ESTATE
Show all 7 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent