Callie's profile

Callie's reviews

  5  
Callie has 69 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Callie's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, detail-oriented, trustworthy, patient, well-prepared, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
So kind and incredibly helpful
7 months ago
So kind and incredibly helpful

Callie was incredible throughout the entire process. Thoroughly explained things, communicated regularly, and helped navigate as things popped up.

Seller review
Callie was very helpful
7 months ago
Callie was very helpful

Recently was tasked with selling my father’s house. Calli Gottenmoller was invaluable in that process. Prior to sale the house needed some repairs and a deep cleaning. I do not live in the Rock Falls area so I needed suggestions. Calli was able to recommend local companies that did a very good job. Dad was in assisted living when the process started. Calli was patient and gracious as we kept Dad involved. Dad passed before the process was complete. She helped facilitate a smooth transition to my brother and I being the sellers. Calli was pleasant, professional and most importantly helpful.

Buyer review
House Buying Experience
9 months ago
House Buying Experience

Callie did an amazing job throughout the entire house buying process and is still helping after the sale. She kept everything running smoothly and kept me updated throughout the whole process. I couldn’t have asked for better assistance in purchasing my first home. There wasn’t a question that she couldn’t help with. I would give more than a 5 star rating if possible.

Seller review
Great Realtor!!
9 months ago
Great Realtor!!

Callie was a great realtor for us. She was friendly, helpful, professional, knowledgeable and overall good person. I would recommend her to anyone! We sold a house with her and hope to use her for when we buy. Thank you Callie!

Seller review
House sold in Tampico.
10 months ago
House sold in Tampico.

Callie did an amazing job listing and selling my house. She went above and beyond to keep me informed about everything that was happening with the sale . Extremely motivated and helpful. Five stars for Callie . Highly recommend her for selling or buying your next home.

Seller review
Great Experience
10 months ago
Great Experience

Our first meeting just set the tone for working together. Callie was extemely personable, professional and excited about helping us with our sale. She took time to explain what to expect during the process. She presented the process in a profession well laid out plan and answered all of our question. I think our choice to have Callie at United Country-Sauk Valley was our best choice.

Buyer review
No one compares!
11 months ago
No one compares!

Callie is an old soul with a modern approach when it comes to realty. That’s how I would describe her. She knows WAY too much (don’t let her youth fool you) and if there’s a hiccup along the way, this girl gets clever; She always turns what seems like a dead end into a T-intersection, where now options are presented and you’re back in control! She’s straight up gifted and her optimism is through the roof. There were times that I cried because this process can be SO OVERWHELMING 😩, and other times I simply wanted to because things seemed like they were going to go south for one reason or another. Callie and her positivity kept me hinged… she always had a creative solution up her sleeve. Throughout the years and my multiple sales/purchases and friendship with Callie, I’ve reached out to her for recommendations from painters and drywall “guys” to tree services, plumbers and lawn care experts. She, literally, has all the answers. I love her and you will, too. This girl changes lives. She’s an absolute anomaly.

Seller review
Best Real Estate Agent, ever
11 months ago
Best Real Estate Agent, ever

“Callie is the MOST patient, creative, relatable/easy-to-talk-to, and communicative (person in general) realtor I’ve EVER worked with. You text: She responds. She’s an absolute pearl and so devoted to finding you what you want/need in a BEYOND IMAGINATION-sort-of way. She hunts. She keeps you in mind when new listings appear and she keeps you informed about them if they pique your interest. She offers suggestions/advice and she strives to take the load that you can’t handle, frankly. I couldn’t. I couldn’t handle my load. I was in a pinch.. I almost had to settle. (Time contraints/divorce). Callie wasn’t looking for a sale. She was looking for my happiness. She was willing to do what I felt needed to be done in the time frame I was given, but she expressed concern about my vulnerability and continued the search. I’m in my forever home, now, because she didn’t give up… when I did.”

Buyer review
Great job!
11 months ago
Great job!

Callie was very helpful and responsive from start to finish. We could not recommend her highly enough. She is knowledgeable pleasant and responsive. We would recommend Callie to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate.

Seller review
Selling of house
about 1 year ago
Selling of house

Callie. Was very helpful and answered all my questions on selling of the house. The selling of the house was very fast. She went above and beyond in getting it sold. Highly recommended. Thank you for making this happen I rate Callie in the top 5

Seller review
Amazing as always Tks again so much
about 1 year ago
Amazing as always Tks again so much

Absolutely amazing job you always seem to just knock it out the park you make it seem effortless on my part couldn’t ask for greater experience Tks again

Buyer review
Callie helped find the perfect home for me!
about 1 year ago
Callie helped find the perfect home for me!

Callie and I searched for my home for over a year and she was always on top of sending me homes she thought I'd like. She got to know me, what I was looking for, my must haves, my price ranges, and was extremely helpful during the entire process. She is also very knowledgeable in not only selling homes, but other areas related to inspections, things to look for that I didn't necessarily think of, great areas around town, etc. She was quick in every part of the process and very responsive. This was my first time buying a home, which was exciting and nerveracking. I am so grateful that I had an amazing realtor who was so patient, understanding and helpful. I felt comfortable talking with her and loved the fact that I could ask anything, and if she didnt have the answer she'd point me in the right direction or look into it for me. I highly recommend Callie for anyone looking to buy a home, whether it's their first or last!

13 - 24 of 69
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent