Betsy Sheffield

Betsy Sheffield

  •   5   (4 reviews)

About Betsy

Betsy’s priorities are simple. “These are my customers! They are my top priority! My job is to deliver a great experience!” She has been helping her customers purchase real estate for over 15 years. She became a Realtor in 2006 and obtained her Broker Associate accreditation. During her decade plus of building experience, she has had the pleasure to work with many customers from all walks of life across Florida. Betsy believes that the real estate transaction involves much more than just the complex details of buying or selling a home. She knows it is the key element to building trust and developing a long-term relationship with customers. Betsy recognizes it’s the largest financial transaction most people make in their lives. She takes time to learn about her customer’s unique needs, to efficiently put them on to the perfect property. When helping customers with buying, selling, leasing, renting or investing in residential or commercial properties Betsy devotes her experience, integrity, time, and energy so her customers obtain the best deal possible in the shortest amount of time. To accomplish this Betsy guides her customers at every step of the Real Estate transaction. Her goal is to lift her customers to a level where the decision process is clear and simple. She treats her relationships with customers in real estate transactions like a partnership. She develops a strong working relationship with her customers which lasts long after closing – perhaps a lifetime. Betsy cares about her customers and treats each new customer opportunity as special. She considers the opportunity to work with her customers to buy or sell their home in Florida very seriously. She knows it’s an opportunity to help the customer build with their property and build a new relationship. Her customers have confidence and appreciate the value of her real estate problem-solving skills. Please contact Betsy today to discuss your needs and get her started helping you.

Betsy's reviews

  5  
Betsy has 4 reviewsacross 2 different locations, showing 4.
Review Betsy
over 4 years ago
Betsy is an exceptional, knowledgeable and professional realtor

My husband and I were visiting Indian Rocks Beach two years ago and just happened to walk into Plumlee Realty on the beach. Betsy greeted us and we immediately felt comfortable with her. We were just starting the process to find a condo in the area. For two years, Betsy assisted us via phone, email and in-person showings. She was always prompt in responding to our questions. She is very professional, knowledgeable, persistent, and easy to work with, never putting any pressure on us. We highly recommend Betsy as a realtor!

about 5 years ago
Outstanding Agent

From the moment I engaged Betsy to list my condo, she worked tirelessly, even over the holidays, in order to have the unit listed by first of January. In less than 2 days we had an offer. Although the first offer fell through, she still managed to have it sold in less than a month. She kept us appraised of the status and was always available if we had any questions. I can't thank Betsy enough for helping us through this transaction, especially since we are located out of state. I would highly recommend Betsy to anyone looking for a reputable agent with excellent customer service.

about 5 years ago
Great professional realtor!

Betsy did a great job with the sale of our condo, from staging the decor all the way through the closing! She hosted multiple open houses, and made our property a priority. She followed up with all viewings, and made the whole process simple for us. I highly recommend Betsy for all of your real estate needs!

over 5 years ago
Best Realtor Ever

We were referred to Betsy by a local friend and flew out in January of 2020 to look for a home here in Florida. Betsy spent several days showing us many homes, and finally taking us to the forever home we purchased. Purchasing Our home was somewhat of a challenge due to Covid-19, and we could not get here from Colorado immediately after our purchase in March. Betsy went out of her way to take care of our unit,check our mail, and do numerous other things for us in the four months it took us to get here after purchase. If you have any need for an extraordinary realtor, Betsy Sheffield is the person you should call!

Betsy's properties

Betsy has 10 properties for sale and sold 4 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 28, 2026
$470,000
11520 132nd Avenue North
Largo FL 33778
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of PLUMLEE GULF BEACH REALTY and HOME PRIME REALTY LLC
SoldApr 28, 2026
$267,000
4515 99th Avenue North
Pinellas Park FL 33782
2
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX REALTY UNLIMITED and PLUMLEE GULF BEACH REALTY
For Sale
$765,000
702/900 Gulf Boulevard
Indian Rocks Beach FL 33785
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of PLUMLEE GULF BEACH REALTY
For Sale
$675,000
416/399 2nd St
Indian Rocks Beach FL 33785
2
2
Other
Listing courtesy of PLUMLEE GULF BEACH REALTY
Show all 14 properties
Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent