Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 77 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, detail-oriented, proactive, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
FROM AGENT TO FRIEND
almost 3 years ago
FROM AGENT TO FRIEND

What can I say? There are people you come across in your life who you become very thankful you meet. Amy brokered a deal for us to buy a new home, helped us find creative financing for it, then listed our old home. She worked incredibly hard to sell it and was extraordinary at every step. When it didn't sell as fast as we had hoped (the market turned right when we listed), it was very frustrating for all of us. While most people would move to a different agent and be upset things weren't moving quicker, I actually felt GUILTY knowing how much effort she was putting in and offered her an out. She refused (who does that?) and simply worked even harder to get the deal done, knowing she could have focused on other clients who had easier homes to sell. It's this kind of tenacity, focus, and now friendship that my wife and I simply marvel at. Feel free to find someone else to buy or sell your home but you won't find someone who is more honest, trustworthy, hard-working and caring than she is. In a business that's unbelievably competitive, it's comforting to know there are still people who honestly care about you and not just the money involved. Amy gave us some faith in humanity and I thank her for it. She's the best out there and choosing anyone else is a missed opportunity for you to experience the same.

Buyer review
Amazing Agent!!
over 3 years ago
Amazing Agent!!

Amy is incredible. She listens to exactly what you are looking for and then goes to work to find the perfect home for you! She is extremely fast with all inquires and works very well with with other agents. I simply would never use any other agent, and I couldn't recommend her more highly! Thank you Amy!

Buyer review
Truly a delight to work with!
over 3 years ago
Truly a delight to work with!

Amy is the perfect combination of a stellar agent who is right on top of all of her clients needs, making the home buying process less stressful and easier, and also just a really good person who is fun to work with! We felt completely confident the entire time that she had our back and we were in good hands. Definitely recommend and will work with her again!

Buyer review
BEST REALTOR EVER!!
over 3 years ago
BEST REALTOR EVER!!

Absolutely loved working with Amy on our journey of purchasing our first home!! She was very knowledgeable about any and all questions we had. I will most DEFINITELY be a returning client! 10/10 recommended.

Seller review
Can't imagine anyone better!
over 3 years ago
Can't imagine anyone better!

Amy was unbelievably helpful and energetic throughout the selling process. She was always available if we needed anything or questions answered. Amy is absolutely wonderful! I would recommend Amy to anyone considering buying or selling a home. She is professional but easy going and easy to work with. She is like family to us!

Buyer review
Amy is the best!
over 3 years ago
Amy is the best!

Amy was so fun and great to work with. She answered all of our questions was completely honest about everything that goes into buying a home. She walked us through everything at our pace. Most importantly she was always sincere and wanted to meet up with us and look at homes. She never made us feel like we were a bother. It felt like she loved showing homes as much as we loved looking and that made it so fun! When you’re around Amy her true love and light for life shows. She’s so compassionate and empathetic towards people and what’s going on in their lives, even when her hands are already completely full. She was always available and made you feel Like you were the most important thing going on, even when you knew she was super busy. She’s a true gift! Thank you Amy! Jerry and I look forward to working with you again!

Buyer review
Simply the Best
almost 4 years ago
Simply the Best

Amy is more than a realtor, she is a friend. She truly cares about you and does all she can to make sure you are happy with your new home or sale of your old home. She goes above and beyond in every way and I can see how much she truly cares about her client’s happiness. I can’t imagine ever trusting another realtor as much as I trust Amy, as she truly has her client’s best interests at heart.

Buyer review
A one of a kind agent!
almost 4 years ago
A one of a kind agent!

Amy is an angel in the form of a realtor. She is so kind and has such a warm energy. We actually met her at an open house and in about 30 minutes decided to use her as our realtor. She was fantastic! Amazing communication, encouraging, and super knowledgeable about the area. We were moving from about 2 hours away and she was so helpful and willing to virtually tour houses with us. She wrote super competitive offers and was such a great resource. We highly recommend Amy and would use her again in a heartbeat! We feel very fortunate to have a realtor turned friend. Thanks for everything Amy!

Buyer review
A Wonderful Experience!
about 4 years ago
A Wonderful Experience!

Amy McMahon did a phenomenal job helping me through the entire home buying experience. She is very knowledgeable and resourceful. Amy is professional and communicates clearly. She answered all my questions and provided honest feedback. Amy was there for me at the very start of the home buying process until the end. I am very pleased with all of her hard work, and recommend her to anyone looking for their perfect home!

Buyer review
First time
about 4 years ago
First time

I was a first time buyer, Amy was great and patient working with me to find a house that met my needs.

Seller review
Great Experience
over 4 years ago
Great Experience

Amy went above and beyond to make our transaction smooth and easy. From the 1st walk through she was always positive and upbeat and walked us through the each step of the process.

Buyer review
Amazing!!!
over 4 years ago
Amazing!!!

We loved working with Amy and Burke! They were so knowledgeable and supportive. Any time we wanted to look at a listing they set it up for us immediately. Very flexible with our schedules. Even when they were on a weekend trip with their family, our dream house went on the market so they set it up for their coworker to show us the house asap and got our offer in that same day. That was the house we ended up buying and they were just as amazing during the closing process. We highly recommend them to everyone we know! Can’t thank them enough for all their help!

61 - 72 of 77
© 2026 RateMyAgent