Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 72 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, honest, proactive, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Wonderful to Work With
10 days ago
Wonderful to Work With

Amy was knowledgeable about our area and real estate in general, she has been so incredibly helpful in the buying process. After they worked together on this purchase, our mortgage lender even told us that we have a rockstar of an agent and he loved working with Amy as well. She was so kind and thoughtful and professional. She really has a knack for working with people. I know she has other clients, but she always made us feel like a priority and she always seemed calm and prepared for anything. Even after the whole process was done she has been checking on us. She really takes pride in her work and stands behind what she does.

Seller review
Fantastic all around agent
10 days ago
Fantastic all around agent

Amy had great communication through the whole process of selling our house. She gave us all the information so that we could make informed decisions but made sure we knew that she supported whatever decision we made. She was always very professional with us and with the other agents. She made every hurdle seem manageable and walked us through everything. We will happily recommend her to anyone we know selling their house!

Seller review
Amy is the Best!
24 days ago
Amy is the Best!

We could not be more proud to recommend Amy McMahon to all of our friends, family, and community members who are looking to buy or sell real estate. I have now been on both sides of a transaction with Amy. She brings such a sense of calm, confident, and communicative professionalism that brings so much reassurance to what can feel like a vulnerable or overwhelming process. Amy makes your home feel like the most special property in the world as she attends to all of the little details! Without reservation and with the utmost sincerely, we would send those closest to us to Amy McMahon for any and all real estate needs they might have.

Buyer review
Satisfied Buyer here!
27 days ago
Satisfied Buyer here!

Amy is a great realtor! She listened to what we wanted and gave us realistic expectations throughout the process. She walked us through every step along the way and was very knowledgeable and patient in explaining everything that was happening. The process was smooth because she provided an organized timeline and kept us informed the whole time. Amy is not just a great realtor, but also someone we now consider a friend. Thank you for helping us purchase our first home!

Buyer review
Found the perfect home!
about 2 months ago
Found the perfect home!

I appreciated Amy McMahon giving honest feedback, finding exactly what I was looking for, and making it happen so quickly Amy was involved every step of the way and explained things thoroughly so they made sense during the process. Amy was great to work with and would recommend her to anyone buying or selling.

Seller review
Great experience!
about 2 months ago
Great experience!

Amy McMahon was awesome from start to finish. She is smart, knows the market, and always available for questions or processes. It was a absolute pleasure working with her and recommend to anyone needing to sell or purchase a home.

Seller review
She by is an exceptional communicator, energetic, positive, and innovative.
3 months ago
She by is an exceptional communicator, energetic, positive, and innovative.

She was able to understand her client's requirements as well as the potential buyer's needs, which resulted in a rather quick transaction. She was great to work with, easily helping us to understand swhat our needs/requirements were. We hadn't sold a house in over 50 years and so we also needed a lot of help filling out forms,as well as explaning them, and she did help us!

Seller review
Amy was an excellent communicator who helped us glide through the selling process.
3 months ago
Amy was an excellent communicator who helped us glide through the selling process.

We couldn't be happier with our choice of realtor! Amy helped us from beginning to end with her proactive style and knowledge of resources in the community along with experience in market research. She was exceptionally helpful throughout the process and kept us informed every step of the way. We fully trusted Amy and felt completely comfortable asking questions along with receiving reliable information. We would highly recommend Amy to anyone wanting to buy or sell a home. She is an A+!

Buyer review
Amy is exactly what we wanted in an agent caring, patient, smart, effective.
3 months ago
Amy is exactly what we wanted in an agent caring, patient, smart, effective.

We are first time home buyers and she was very friendly and helpful; a great explainer. Amy was very respectful and understanding of our process and worked with us for about a year. I know it's not true, but it felt like we were her only client, she's that gifted. Very responsive to texts, calls, emails, you name it. She was also a great negotiator, able to make our offer more attractive and able to help the other side come to us. When we closed, we celebrated with our friend Amy. We loved working with her and would do it again.

Seller review
Really amazing!
4 months ago
Really amazing!

Amy is amazing. She foot to know us, she showed up when she said she would, she set a date a met the goal. She was super proactive. Any put out way more effort into selling our home than any other realtor. And she got us more than the asking price! Couldn't have asked for a better experience. What a joy!

Seller review
Good communicator
4 months ago
Good communicator

I chose Amy because I worked with her previously in another capacity. I chose her because I knew her to be an upstanding person that I could trust. This was my first time selling a home so I needed a lot of guidance and I needed to trust the person in charge to have my best interests in mind. In a tough market, Amy was solid throughout. She kept a good balance of honesty and helping me not to become discouraged. If there was something she didn't know - she said it and found the answers/solutions. Lovely person and loves her job.

1 - 12 of 72
© 2026 RateMyAgent