Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 86 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, friendly, well-prepared, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Amy was very helpful in the entire home selling process.
6 days ago
Amy was very helpful in the entire home selling process.

We sold our home of 32 years. We definitely didn't know how to begin the process of selling or what to expect. Amy is very knowledgeable and has all the resources to get any task completed. She communicated everything along the way so we could make informed decisions based on pricing, current market for selling, real-estate lingo, and presentation of the home.

Buyer review
This is our second home Amy we’ve purchased with Amy as our realtor. She is the BEST!
9 days ago
This is our second home Amy we’ve purchased with Amy as our realtor. She is the BEST!

Amy was always quick to respond to us and never made us feel bad for asking questions anytime of day about any little or big thing. We knew Amy was knowledgeable as this was the 2nd time we’ve chosen her to purchase a home. She also represented us in selling our last home. It was very comforting knowing we had her knowledge and experience with buying and selling. Who Amy is as a person and friend flows over abundantly with her business which makes her the perfect realtor. She is very trustworthy and most importantly she is honest. Even if you don’t want to hear it, I guarantee you she has her customers best interest over her own.

Seller review
Amy is an absolute gem.  Her energy, optimism, and dedication are second to none.
9 days ago
Amy is an absolute gem. Her energy, optimism, and dedication are second to none.

It was obvious Amy had done her homework. She knew exactly how to price our home and how much to offer on the new home. She was always available and it was obvious she was dedicated to both our sale and purchase. The way she showed our home digitally with the pictures and description were simply beautiful and so well done. Amy did everything she could to make this experience the best it could be.

Seller review
Rates 5 stars plus!
about 1 month ago
Rates 5 stars plus!

Amy is exceptional with her knowledge base of the market, vendors, and procedures. She communicates this knowledge clearly, answers questions fully and promptly, and maintains an open line of communication. I particularly appreciated her willingness to find and interact with necessary vendors on my behalf. Her skills at negotiating are strong. She is always friendly and supportive of her clients. I cannot recommend her highly enough.

Buyer review
Fantastic agent, great communicator, knowledgeable and approachable
about 2 months ago
Fantastic agent, great communicator, knowledgeable and approachable

Amy McMahon was an absolute delight to work with as a first time home buyer! She was so supportive and knowledgeable throughout every step of the process and always made time to answer my many questions along the way. She is friendly, approachable, and professional. I would recommend her to anyone looking for an agent! She knows what she's doing and she does it with care and kindness.

Buyer review
Compassionate and Helpful!
2 months ago
Compassionate and Helpful!

Throughout our time together, Amy was super easy to communicate with, and gave multiple means of communication (ie text, email, call, in person). She was very timely with her responses and if she needed to reach out to an outside party for any reason, she was always very prompt and forthcoming on whether they responded or not. Amy gave us plenty of references for contractors for anything we may need assistance with in the future and gave tips on what we should expect from each one. We really liked how when we would tour a house, she would make sure everything was set up and would make sure she had all relevant information pulled up. She never hovered around us as we were touring, and never made us feel rushed to look at or choose a home. We trusted her advice and recommendations for the house buying experience, she truly seemed to have our best interest in mind!

Seller review
Was a great choice  in a difficult  sale
3 months ago
Was a great choice in a difficult sale

Was a long and difficult sale and Amy McMahon was a great choice in furnishing the expertise to navigate the difficulties always keeping in contact and updating information quickly, A great job all around.

Buyer review
An incredibly kind, responsive, and supportive realtor who went above and beyond.
3 months ago
An incredibly kind, responsive, and supportive realtor who went above and beyond.

Amy was incredibly helpful, responsive, kind, and understanding throughout the entire process. She always responded quickly to our questions and made us feel supported every step of the way. Her patience, professionalism, and genuine willingness to help made what could have been a stressful experience feel so much easier. We are extremely grateful for all of her support and would gladly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Seller review
I found Amy to be very knowable about real estate. She walked me though every step patiently..
3 months ago
I found Amy to be very knowable about real estate. She walked me though every step patiently..

Amy was excellent in her knowledge of real estate and patiently explained each step. She went out of her way to find me my next home and help in moving out of one home to the next. No detail was too small. Amy understood my physical challenges and helped me get my garbage can to the street weekly. When asked Amy shared information with my adult children who live in other states so they were sure I was well represented. When challenged with packing up my house Amy connected me with a lady who did much of my packing. Amy also helped me with men who moved my furniture from one house to my next home. I forever grateful to Amy and can highly recommend her for your real estate needs.

Seller review
Top Notch!
4 months ago
Top Notch!

Amy was absolutely a dream to work with. Responsive, knowledgeable and genuinely cared through the whole process. She kept us informed on things that would pop up and always available when I had questions. She was very helpful in setting up contractors to do repairs to the house. Took the stress off from having to find good, honest and reliable contractors. I highly recommend Amy when you’re ready to buy or sell your house. I am grateful she was our realtor.

Seller review
Turning a dream into reality
4 months ago
Turning a dream into reality

My wife and I had been talking about a big idea for quite some time. At first, we had far more questions than answers, but we decided to find out if our dream was actually possible. That’s when we reached out to Amy McMahon. From our very first conversation, Amy made us feel like we were more than just another client. She listened to our goals, understood what we were trying to accomplish, and took the time to explain every step of the process. She researched the market, pulled detailed comps, and gave us honest, straightforward advice that helped us make informed decisions with confidence. This wasn’t just a move across town—it was a cross-country relocation that required months of planning, coordination, and trust. Throughout the entire process, Amy’s communication was exceptional. She kept us informed, answered every question promptly, and made sure we always knew what to expect next. Whenever something unexpected came up, she either had the answer or knew exactly where to find it. The way Amy marketed and listed our home was absolutely top-notch. Her attention to detail, professionalism, and strategic approach made all the difference. Our home sold much faster than we ever imagined, and the entire experience far exceeded our expectations. Amy is knowledgeable, creative, organized, and always thinking several steps ahead. Her dedication and work ethic are second to none, and her entire team made us feel supported from beginning to end. At no point did we ever feel like we were navigating this journey alone. If you’re looking for a realtor who truly understands the market, communicates exceptionally well, and genuinely cares about her clients, look no further. My wife and I are incredibly grateful that Amy helped turn what started as an idea into reality. She isn’t just an outstanding realtor—she is an amazing trusted friend. We couldn’t recommend her more highly. Thank you Amy!!!

Buyer review
8 month deal. Many issues. Got it done
4 months ago
8 month deal. Many issues. Got it done

Very responsive. Took 8 months to get the deal done. Dealt with an eviction many lender delays but she stuck with it.

1 - 12 of 86
© 2026 RateMyAgent