Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 77 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, detail-oriented, proactive, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
She by is an exceptional communicator, energetic, positive, and innovative.
5 months ago
She by is an exceptional communicator, energetic, positive, and innovative.

She was able to understand her client's requirements as well as the potential buyer's needs, which resulted in a rather quick transaction. She was great to work with, easily helping us to understand swhat our needs/requirements were. We hadn't sold a house in over 50 years and so we also needed a lot of help filling out forms,as well as explaning them, and she did help us!

Seller review
Amy was an excellent communicator who helped us glide through the selling process.
5 months ago
Amy was an excellent communicator who helped us glide through the selling process.

We couldn't be happier with our choice of realtor! Amy helped us from beginning to end with her proactive style and knowledge of resources in the community along with experience in market research. She was exceptionally helpful throughout the process and kept us informed every step of the way. We fully trusted Amy and felt completely comfortable asking questions along with receiving reliable information. We would highly recommend Amy to anyone wanting to buy or sell a home. She is an A+!

Buyer review
Amy is exactly what we wanted in an agent caring, patient, smart, effective.
5 months ago
Amy is exactly what we wanted in an agent caring, patient, smart, effective.

We are first time home buyers and she was very friendly and helpful; a great explainer. Amy was very respectful and understanding of our process and worked with us for about a year. I know it's not true, but it felt like we were her only client, she's that gifted. Very responsive to texts, calls, emails, you name it. She was also a great negotiator, able to make our offer more attractive and able to help the other side come to us. When we closed, we celebrated with our friend Amy. We loved working with her and would do it again.

Seller review
Really amazing!
5 months ago
Really amazing!

Amy is amazing. She foot to know us, she showed up when she said she would, she set a date a met the goal. She was super proactive. Any put out way more effort into selling our home than any other realtor. And she got us more than the asking price! Couldn't have asked for a better experience. What a joy!

Seller review
Good communicator
6 months ago
Good communicator

I chose Amy because I worked with her previously in another capacity. I chose her because I knew her to be an upstanding person that I could trust. This was my first time selling a home so I needed a lot of guidance and I needed to trust the person in charge to have my best interests in mind. In a tough market, Amy was solid throughout. She kept a good balance of honesty and helping me not to become discouraged. If there was something she didn't know - she said it and found the answers/solutions. Lovely person and loves her job.

Seller review
So grateful for Amy!
8 months ago
So grateful for Amy!

Our family felt so fortunate to have had Amy help us with the sale of our parents’ home. She was very knowledgeable, answered any questions that we had, and communicated well all along the way, as we navigated this sale. She even reached out to our estate sale contact for scheduling issues. Amy had the home cleaned and ready for inspection. She just took care of so many things, which was so helpful and made this experience pretty much worry free. We are so grateful to have had Amy as our realtor and highly recommend her services.

Buyer review
A Wonderful Experience
8 months ago
A Wonderful Experience

We met Amy by chance at an open house, and she immediately made an impression on us with her warm personality and wealth of knowledge. Lucky for us, a connection was made between her and our other agent, and she began helping us with the next step in our house searching journey. During the process, Amy was patient, professional, and extremely helpful in finding the home that was right for us. And we had a lot of questions! We both feel so fortunate to have worked with her. Highly, highly recommend!

Buyer review
Realtor Amy McMahon 10/10!!
9 months ago
Realtor Amy McMahon 10/10!!

“Throughout our home-buying process, Amy was incredibly communicative. She promptly answered calls and text messages, keeping us informed about every development. Her ability to clearly explain contract details was invaluable. As young first time home buyers she took us under her wing and treated us like family. If you’re a first time buyer or just looking for a realtor that cares, I highly recommend Amy McMahon! ”

Buyer review
Amy is wonderful!!!
9 months ago
Amy is wonderful!!!

Amy did a wonderful job helping my son purchase his first home. She went above and beyond. I would definitely reach out to her if you need help purchasing a home. She was there for us every step of the way.

Seller review
Smooth process
10 months ago
Smooth process

After living in our house for 19 years we decided to sell and reached out to Amy to be our realtor. She came over that same evening to discuss and view our house knowing we were leaving for vacation for the weekend. The listing price was what we were thinking of ourselves and Amy did an amazing job staging our house to list. There wasn’t one time we didn’t know what our next step was. When the offer came in after being listed for 3 days she walked us right through what we needed to do. Such a roller coaster of a month and we have gained a friend of the family in the process. Thank you again for all your hard work Amy!

Buyer review
Amy is Wonderful!
10 months ago
Amy is Wonderful!

Amy is Wonderful! She is knowledgeable and listens! She stays connected and answered all of our questions in a timely manner. She helped us find the perfect house. Thank you Amy!!

Seller review
Stress free sell
10 months ago
Stress free sell

Amy was amazing throughout every part of the process of selling our house. From the beginning Amy was on top of everything and kept our best interest in mind. She was always very honest with us about the whole process and always straight to the point, never just telling us what we wanted to hear. I never had a moment where I felt stress about the selling of our house, I knew I could rely on Amy. I would 100% use Amy as my realtor again. You won’t find anyone more caring, knowledgeable, or trustworthy as Amy McMahon.

13 - 24 of 77
© 2026 RateMyAgent