Shelly's profile

Shelly's reviews

  4.9  
Shelly has 110 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, patient, detail-oriented, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
My wife and I worked with Shelly even before we moved to Savannah from Maryland
almost 5 years ago
My wife and I worked with Shelly even before we moved to Savannah from Maryland

My wife and I worked with Shelly even before we moved to Savannah from Maryland. She was always available to assist wherever needed. I could always count on her to provide updates on homes in the area. My wife and I trusted her every move as she assisted us in our move and purchase of a new home. Which by the way was in the exact neighborhood and location that we wanted. She is extremely knowledgeable about Savannah and the housing market. Her recommendations were always taken seriously because she truly cares about helping her clients. Honest, trustworthy and friendly. Shelly was the perfect agent for us during our 5 month search for the perfect home. Thank you!

Buyer review
Shelly can be described in one word
almost 5 years ago
Shelly can be described in one word

Shelly can be described in one word. AMAZING! We were looking for a second home, during a pandemic, and she delivered exactly what we were looking for. She conducted the best video tours and helped answer all of our questions. She helped us negotiate the best offer, so that our offer was accepted over all the other offers. After we were under contract she helped guide us through the rest of the process and made it super easy on us. We look forward to working with her again!

Buyer review
Shelly is an amazing agent and went above and beyond during our home search
almost 5 years ago
Shelly is an amazing agent and went above and beyond during our home search

Shelly is an amazing agent and went above and beyond during our home search. She knows the area really well, made fantastic recommendations and was able to guide us to the best options available for our budget and timeline. Would definitely recommend her to anyone buying for the first time in the area.

Seller review
Had a rather terrible experience with Shelly...
about 5 years ago
Had a rather terrible experience with Shelly...

Had a rather terrible experience with Shelly. She accidentally texted me (thinking she was texting her boss), saying, "I'm not going to show him houses bc I don't trust him not to approach the owners on his own".... even though I'd already signed a contract with her stating I am legally obligated to go through her for any property she showed me. Shelly then proceeded to throw her boss under the bus by telling me she said that bc she was, "Trying to get information out of her boss"... Which is absolutely asinine. So yea, stay far away from this group. What kind of realtor says they're not going to show their client houses??

Buyer review
I would like to thank Shelly LaMonica for the wonderful job she did with finding our family a second
about 5 years ago
I would like to thank Shelly LaMonica for the wonderful job she did with finding our family a second

I would like to thank Shelly LaMonica for the wonderful job she did with finding our family a second home in Savannah. Her knowledge of the area was truly helpful. Shelly answered our numerous questions with patience, while demonstrating an expertise of the Savannah area. We enjoyed working with Shelly and would recommend her to anyone who does not live in the Savannah area and are looking to relocate. Thank you Shelly!

Buyer review
Shelly was so AMAZING to work with on our home purchase!  We recently purchased a second home in Sav
about 5 years ago
Shelly was so AMAZING to work with on our home purchase! We recently purchased a second home in Sav

Shelly was so AMAZING to work with on our home purchase! We recently purchased a second home in Savannah, GA and handled most of the purchase remotely from Atlanta. Shelly was available every step of the way. Only one of us got to physically see the property and Shelly took the extra step to do a video walk through of the property so we felt comfortable with the purchase decision. Everything was handled very efficiently and Shelly communicated all details effectively throughout the purchase process all the way to helping us retrieve the keys on closing date when the seller didn't bring them to closing LOL. She was always there for us! We'd highly recommend anyone looking for a new home to let Shelly assist with the search and purchase process.

Buyer review
She is very efficient and accommodating
over 5 years ago
She is very efficient and accommodating

We were connected to Ms. LaMonica via an inquiry on a property we saw on Trulia. Ms. LaMonica is very knowledgeable of the area and the market. She kept in excellent contact with me. We worked with her closely for 90 days, which was the time from our inquiry of the property to closing date. She is very efficient and accommodating, especially for clients that don't live in the area!

Buyer review
An amazing agent in the Savannah area
over 5 years ago
An amazing agent in the Savannah area

An amazing agent in the Savannah area. Over the last 4 months, my wife and I have thoroughly enjoyed the journey with Shelly LaMonica. From day one she took the time to learn about us. She wanted to understand what our likes and dislikes were, then set up a web portal that fed in homes that met our preferences. We were living in Maryland at the time, but that didn’t limit our ability to continue to communicate. Shelly is so focused on the client and will really work hard for you to ensure you get the home of your dreams. The connection we have will last forever. You never have to feel as though you are alone. She will be there to answer your questions and will give you that extra effort to find the right home for you, and hold your hand through the contract process and closing. Her friendship doesn’t end with the settlement. It’s a lasting relationship. Highly recommend contacting her in order to start your home search journey in Savannah.

Buyer review
Shelly helped us find the perfect home
over 5 years ago
Shelly helped us find the perfect home

Shelly helped us find the perfect home. She showed us plenty of options within our price point and was very detail oriented. The process of home buying can be stressful and she made it easy. The entire family is thrilled with our new house! Thanks, Shelly!

Buyer review
Shelly, was amazing with our out of state move to the beautiful Savannah area
over 5 years ago
Shelly, was amazing with our out of state move to the beautiful Savannah area

Shelly, was amazing with our out of state move to the beautiful Savannah area. She responded to us right away. She was fair in negotiations and professional. We purchased our home during tight COVID restrictions from across the country. We really depended on Shelly for all of the important details to make the transaction happen. We love our home and highly recommend Shelly as a buyers agent.

73 - 84 of 110
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent