Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 32 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
over 5 years ago
Andy is Awesome!

We had listed our home with several other agents, and we were frustrated with the lack of communication, and effort to sell our home. Then we met Andrew Scherer. He convinced us to give him a chance at selling our home, and Oh My Gosh, it was as if the clouds parted, the sun came out, and the birds began to sing. It was an awesome decision! We have bought and sold numerous homes, and Andy is, by far, THE BEST real estate agent we have ever worked with. He is knowledgeable, professional, honest, and hard working. There was never any doubt in our minds that Andy was always looking out for our best interest. Even when he had to give us bad news, he always had a plan to move forward. Andy has our trust and our respect. We have moved out of state, and we wish we could clone Andy so he could represent us with out next home purchase.

over 5 years ago
Agent of the Year

We met with Andrew in pre-covid January, viewed several homes, narrowed our wish list and returned to Georgia. Planned to put our lake home on the market in March. When the world shut down, Andy kept in touch sending homes to view through email. We had a cash offer on our home and the next day, after a virtual tour with Andrew, put an offer in on a beautiful home in Lakewood Ranch. Within a week, our buyer had purchased a larger home and backed out of our deal, leaving us in a bind. Andy was instrumental in reassuring the seller’s agent that this deal could go through. In the end, after a lot of work and schmoozing on Andy’s part, we got the house and closed quickly. Andy was a gem and critical to us in a tumultuous time. He arranged for the inspection and was there to help and recommend vendors. He was our eyes and ears on the ground in Florida. I do not think we would have gotten the home we wanted without him. He was always there when I called and was never too busy to help. We had a realtor, and now have a friend. I would highly recommend Andrew to anyone needing a highly experienced realtor.

over 5 years ago
Exceptional Realtor! Genuinely HONEST!

Andy genuinely cares about his clients as if they were a family member. He, in my opinion, did the impossible finding me a Home in the middle of a Pandemic! He would look at houses with me Virtually as if he were buying it HIMSELF. In such a nerve racking time he gave me a sense of ease. He is NOT a pushy hard sell Realtor. He takes the time to get to know you, answers ALL of the million questions you have during the process and is extremely knowledgeable about locations homes in the Area's you are looking at and will near steer you to something he wouldn't buy himself. I'm so grateful he was my Realtor and throughout the course of searching for a home I can honestly say that I'm proud to have met him and would HIGHLY RECOMMEND Andy to anyone looking for a place to call home!

over 5 years ago
Review of our Sarasota purchase

Andy was extremely helpful with our purchase. He helped with contacts that were personable and quick to respond. Helped with local insurance, inspections, bank options etc. We appreciate his answering our questions and his professionalism.

almost 6 years ago
Andy Scherer was an outstanding real estate agent!

I am pleased to provide a review of the experience of working with Andy Scherer as a real estate agent helping my wife and me locate a house in Sarasota, Florida. It is hard to imagine how anyone could do a better job than Andy. He is friendly, attentive, patient, knowledgeable and sought to be helpful in every imaginable way both before and after the sale. I recommend him enthusiastically and without any reservations. He is a person of high integrity who always looks after his clients’ interests. He is a thorough professional.

over 6 years ago
Agent Andrew Scherer is as good as it gets!

Agent Andrew Scherer is as good as it gets! His professionalism, promptness, work ethic are second to none. I wanted to sell my investment rental so I had to make a few repairs. By the time we were going to post a for sale sign, Agent Scherer had multiple showings on the first day. We went under contract within 24 hrs and got over asking price! He will be with you every step of the way and was always available for questions (often after hours). Look no further!!

almost 7 years ago
If you need a real estate agent, chose Andrew Scherer

If you need a real estate agent, chose Andrew Scherer. He sold my house promptly and then made the closing experience easy for me. Any problems, Andy always helped me solve them. He is the constant professional.

25 - 32 of 32
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent