Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 32 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
8 months ago
The Best!

Andy spent a crazy amount of time with us to sell our house AND buy the home of our dreams! The creativity and ingenuity he had in making both transactions happen at the same time was beyond the norm. His friendship, excellent communication and experience was invaluable. We are enormously grateful to Andy, Allison and his entire team for this successful journey! Thank you!

over 1 year ago
Highly Recommend

It was a pleasure to work with Andy. We were new to the Sarasota area and he showed us many communities and eventually our new home. We never felt rushed or pressured by him. He was patient with us and answered all of our questions, often times before we even asked them! He’s extremely knowledgeable of the area and real estate market in general. He made our search a very positive experience and I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a home.

over 1 year ago
Professional, knowledgeable and a delightful experience.

Andy was absolutely fantastic in helping us find our dream home. He was extremely knowledgeable with all the builders and communities in lakewood ranch. He went above and beyond taking us all over for many days and assisting in our decisions. Every time we called him he immediately called back and always had the answers to our questions. Buying a house is stressful and Andy made that experience a pleasure.

almost 2 years ago
5 DIAMOND EXPERIENCE

Our experience with Andy and his team was truly the most extraordinary real estate transaction we’ve had…EVER! The components that make up a 5 Diamond Experience are reaction time, knowledge, professionalism, going so far beyond the extra mile, no pressure sales, patience, listening, and getting “you, where you are and where you want to go”. We’ve caught Florida Lakewood Ranch fever and will be back not too long for another round!! Thanks TEAM!!

about 2 years ago
The Most Knowledgeable, Dedicated, and Trusted Agent We Have Ever Worked With!

Our experience with Andy Scherer was truly exceptional. Our two-year new-construction journey began with Andy helping us to find exactly the right community to match our interests and ended with our great satisfaction, two years later (due to some construction challenges along the way.) His knowledge of the Sarasota area guided our search, saved us a great deal of time, helped us make an informed decision, and placed us in exactly the right location for us. Despite the extended time that it took to complete the construction and transaction, Andy remained enthusiastic and dedicated to the success of our project. Andy was always very responsive, eagerly acted on our behalf numerous times, and skillfully and tactfully provided excellent advice and counsel. He closely monitored the construction process (applying his extensive new construction experience) since we were coming from out-of-state, and conscientiously worked with us and the developer to make sure that our new home was delivered in excellent condition and that we had the best experience possible. His tact, demeanor, and professionalism set him apart from any agent we have ever worked with. Without any hesitation, we will immediately call on him again when we need an agent in the area!

about 2 years ago
The Absolute Best in the Business

Hard to put into a few sentences the gratitude and appreciate my wife and I have for Andy. We've now completed 3 home purchases with him and it seems to get easier every time. His market knowledge, resources and even keeled professionalism makes the home buying process a breeze and you would be hard pressed to find someone more dedicated and attentive than Andy. Whether you are looking for your first-home or an investment property, Andy is there throughout every step of the process and is more of a partner than just a real estate agent. He has always had our best interests at the forefront of his work and it's apparent to anyone that does business with him that he has put in the time, effort and care to be the absolute best at what he does. For as long as Andy is in the business, we will never look elsewhere. Thank you

about 2 years ago
Above & Beyond

We had the pleasure of working with Andy Scherer throughout our recent home-buying experience in Sarasota. Andy was professional, knowledgeable, and showed a genuine care for us, taking the time to understand our preferences and needs. What set Andy apart was his dedication to our satisfaction. He was always available to answer our questions, address any concerns, and provide reassurance during moments of uncertainty. His responsiveness and attention to detail made us feel supported and empowered throughout our decision-making process. We are grateful for Andy’s expertise, professionalism, and commitment to helping us with our recent purchase. We found Andy to be extremely personable, warm, caring, and fun to work with. We have no reservations in highly recommending Andy to anyone in search of a reliable, trustworthy, and dedicated real estate partner.

about 2 years ago
Andy Scherer stands above all others!

Wow! What a ride this sale was with Andy Scherer! In short, it would not have been possible without his experience and expertise. We first met Andy in 2016 when he supported us with a buy/sell transaction. That experience was so smooth that he was our obvious first choice when we decided to buy/sell again. Andy listed our home and within 10 days we had 8 showings and 2 offers. A primary and a back up! Both offers were 98% of ask as well. Less than 1 month to close and we lost our primary buyer! With a significant deposit put on a new build, we were very tense to say the least. Andy sprung into action with the back up offer that had expired. The backup buyers were moving on another property but due to Andys experience in real estate transactions, he was pivotal in re-engaging the buyers agent and buyers and after a tense 24 hours, negotiating a new contract for the sale of our home. By the numbers; 1 listing, 8 showings in 10 days and 2 near full price offers. 45 days later a successful settlement on the sale of our home. If you are looking to sell your home and want the benefit of comfort from partnering with a true expert in real estate, look no further than Andy Scherer. Oh, and he is also a super nice guy.

about 2 years ago
Best in class

My husband and I have had the pleasure of working with Andy over the last ten years. Andy has helped us buy and sell multiple properties over the years and has become someone we can call a friend. Our latest purchase was so easy to find and every aspect of the purchase was seamless. Andy is not only an excellent communicator but his expert level knowledge of the buying and selling process helped us navigate what could have been a difficult transaction. Andy has always supported us in the most professional manner and has guided us well beyond the call of duty. Without Andy, I’m not sure we would have been able to achieve what we did. We are beyond thankful for his support and highly recommend him.

almost 3 years ago
Andrew is dedicated to getting the job done!

Andrew goes above and beyond when selling your house. He knows the market, takes time to understand al the little things that make your house special. He explains market analysis, trends, and what you can do to get the best photos and showings. Oh, and by the way, he showed the same dedication when he helped us find our house 7 years ago. We highly recommend Andrew to anyone looking for a reliable, present, and professional agent.

about 3 years ago
Andy, what can I say about Andy hmmmm Met a friend

Andy, what can I say about Andy hmmmm Met a friend. Outstanding professional. Dedicated to his customers. Timely. Thoughtful. Considerate of your needs and expectations. Cons, no sense of humor, Has a mustang but wouldnt let me drive.Wouldnt let me borrow his comb. Other than that a wonderful , considerate man. We wish each other long, healthy lives. Gene Kovacs

over 3 years ago
Beautiful Siesta Key Waterfront Home

We are so happy we were connected with Andy to help us find our new home. He is responsive, easy to work with, professional and most important-excellent at his job! Andy made the process seamless. He is also very connected in the community and helped us find an interior designer and a great insurance agent.

1 - 12 of 32
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent