Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 32 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Great job!

Andy was very helpful in providing suggestions for handling a difficult situation with the sales person. He also would provide me with resources.

over 3 years ago
We are so happy we were connected with Andy.

We are so happy we were connected with Andy to help us find our new home. He is responsive, easy to work with, professional and most important-excellent at his job! Andy made the process seamless. He is also very connected in the community and helped us find an interior designer and a great insurance agent.

almost 4 years ago
"Andy and his team did a great job of helping us find our home in Sarasota

"Andy and his team did a great job of helping us find our home in Sarasota. Andy worked hard knowing we only had a few days to look at homes. He listened to us and helped us narrow our search. Once we found the home Andy communicated with us each step of the way."

almost 4 years ago
"Andy was a true professional and his knowledge and access to resources were critical”

"Andy was a true professional and his knowledge and access to resources were critical in getting us to the finish line on this investment property. From start to finish, we felt comfortable knowing that Andy had our best interest in mind and was honest and kind throughout the entire process. I would highly recommend him and look forward to working with him in the future on more investment properties."

almost 4 years ago
Andrew Scherer is an amazing agent. Simply the best!

We were so very fortunate to have Andy as our agent. He’s professional, dedicated and is extremely customer focused. Andy’s incredibly knowledgeable, hard working and always follows thru, even on the smallest of matters. His communication verbally and thru email/texts is outstanding. Andy also has an easy-going personality. Andy is simply the best. We will recommend him to our family and friends should they decided to move to Florida.

about 4 years ago
Condo sale in Venice

Andy did such a great job helping my mom sell her condo. He was able to meet with us and make an honest and fair assessment of items we could fix before going on the market and really set us up to get top dollar offers within just a day of listing. His team took great care of all of the transaction items and made selling easy for us even though we were doing everything from out of state. The peace of mind knowing I had someone doing an A+ job for us on the ground made this home sale a fantastic experience.

over 4 years ago
= One of a Kind Realtor I would HIGHLY recommend Andy to everyone I know

= One of a Kind Realtor I would HIGHLY recommend Andy to everyone I know. His knowledge of the Market is by far unsurpassed. Andy is THE person you want on your side when making probably the biggest purchase most will make in their life. He will definitely have your back and your best interests first and foremost. He has always said to me "It's about people first" and he lives up to what he says. He's the type of person who goes above and beyond what a most Realtor's would do. Most importantly he treats you like he would one of his friends or family members. He is the most genuinely honest, hard working person I know. He has such a calming demeanor about him during what can be a stressful time that he will actually clam you down as well. As I said I have relied on Andy's expertise in the Housing Market several times which has NEVER failed me, even during the most unsure times we have faced in recent years and now going forward, I will rely on his expertise and valuable advise going forward in the next couple of month's and the next phase of my life. I can honestly say that I am so very fortunate to find him as a Realtor and that I am proud to know him. Mari Brennan

over 4 years ago
One of a kind Realtor

I would HIGHLY recommend Andy to everyone I know. His knowledge of the Market is by far unsurpassed. Andy is THE person you want on your side when making probably the biggest purchase most will make in their life. He will definitely have your back and your best interests first and foremost. He has always said to me "It's about people first" and he lives up to what he says. He's the type of person who goes above and beyond what a most Realtor's would do. Most importantly he treats you like he would one of his friends or family members. He is the most genuinely honest, hard working person I know. He has such a calming demeanor about him during what can be a stressful time that he will actually clam you down as well. As I said I have relied on Andy's expertise in the Housing Market several times which has NEVER failed me, even during the most unsure times we have faced in recent years and now going forward, I will rely on his expertise and valuable advise going forward in the next couple of month's and the next phase of my life. I can honestly say that I am so very fortunate to find him as a Realtor and that I am proud to know him. Mari Brennan

over 4 years ago
"Andrew was the best

"Andrew was the best. He felt like a friend and i felt he gave his honest opinion on properties we were not able to visit ourselves. He was never too busy and made us feel we were his prize clients. His office made every detail go smoothly and they were all knowledgeable, or found the answer quickly to our every question. I would never hesitate to recommend Andrew Scherer to anyone of my friends - buying or selling."

almost 5 years ago
"We had previously followed the golden rule that one should never select a relative or a friend as a

"We had previously followed the golden rule that one should never select a relative or a friend as a realtor. Previous experience with a friend and neighbor became disastrous when we had to fire her for lack of performance. After Andrew had negotiated the contract on our new home we had definitely become friends, despite this, we decided to proceed with Andrew as our realtor for selling our current home! Andrew made the stressful purchase and sale of our homes bearable. We were particularly impressed by the way his team organized the listing of our home with some brilliant pictures in a matter of a few days. Within 18 hours of the listing being posted, we had 3 showings, 2 offers, and a signed contract. Andrew was also very much in control of the complex legal and financial matters with both homes. We could always rely on him to resolve whatever issues arose We heartily recommend Andrew Scherer as your realtor, he is a consummate professional."

13 - 24 of 32
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent