Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 70 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, empathetic, honest, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
A one of a kind agent!
over 3 years ago
A one of a kind agent!

Amy is an angel in the form of a realtor. She is so kind and has such a warm energy. We actually met her at an open house and in about 30 minutes decided to use her as our realtor. She was fantastic! Amazing communication, encouraging, and super knowledgeable about the area. We were moving from about 2 hours away and she was so helpful and willing to virtually tour houses with us. She wrote super competitive offers and was such a great resource. We highly recommend Amy and would use her again in a heartbeat! We feel very fortunate to have a realtor turned friend. Thanks for everything Amy!

Buyer review
A Wonderful Experience!
almost 4 years ago
A Wonderful Experience!

Amy McMahon did a phenomenal job helping me through the entire home buying experience. She is very knowledgeable and resourceful. Amy is professional and communicates clearly. She answered all my questions and provided honest feedback. Amy was there for me at the very start of the home buying process until the end. I am very pleased with all of her hard work, and recommend her to anyone looking for their perfect home!

Buyer review
First time
about 4 years ago
First time

I was a first time buyer, Amy was great and patient working with me to find a house that met my needs.

Seller review
Great Experience
about 4 years ago
Great Experience

Amy went above and beyond to make our transaction smooth and easy. From the 1st walk through she was always positive and upbeat and walked us through the each step of the process.

Buyer review
Amazing!!!
over 4 years ago
Amazing!!!

We loved working with Amy and Burke! They were so knowledgeable and supportive. Any time we wanted to look at a listing they set it up for us immediately. Very flexible with our schedules. Even when they were on a weekend trip with their family, our dream house went on the market so they set it up for their coworker to show us the house asap and got our offer in that same day. That was the house we ended up buying and they were just as amazing during the closing process. We highly recommend them to everyone we know! Can’t thank them enough for all their help!

Seller review
Sale of Home
over 4 years ago
Sale of Home

Amy was great throughout the entire process. She made everything go smoothly and was always quick to respond if we had questions or needed something. I Would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.

Seller review
There for us every step of the way!
over 4 years ago
There for us every step of the way!

Amy’s communication is excellent, she is very professional and very helpful. We sold and bought a new house fast and it was a very smooth transition. I highly recommend her and her husband Burke.

Buyer review
So helpful
over 4 years ago
So helpful

Amy was fantastic in helping is find what we wanted and making it happen. Knowledgeable about the area and quick to help out where she could. Would recommend working with her to anyone looking for a house!

Buyer review
Amy is the BEST!
almost 5 years ago
Amy is the BEST!

Amy is simply the best. This is a tough market and she helped me navigate all of the ups and downs. She was thorough, compassionate, and incredibly professional. Amy got to know my unique fears, must haves, and how important my family is during such a big decision. She supported me better because she took the time to truly know me, holistically. She lifted me up when I was completely overwhelmed. I told her frequently but also want the world to know, I can’t even begin to imagine going through this process with anyone else. I appreciated her transparency, her genuine kindness and love for people, as well as how prompt she was in completing forms and updating me about changes along the way. When I was overwhelmed or frustrated with this process, she validated my feelings. When I had a question, she made sure I had an answer. She helped me snag my perfect home during one of the most challenging times to buy a house and I am forever so grateful.

Buyer review
Wonderful agent!
about 5 years ago
Wonderful agent!

Amy was amazing to work with! She was there every step of the way with us! Always there to answer any and all questions. Very easy to get in contact with, and cares about making sure you understand everything and doing what she can to help get things worked out quickly.

61 - 70 of 70
© 2026 RateMyAgent