Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 80 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: proactive, friendly, well-prepared, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
100% recommend
almost 2 years ago
100% recommend

Amy was amazing to work with throughout the entire buying and selling processes. She is very knowledgeable and able to explain everything in a way that is easy to understand. We would recommend Amy to anyone who is buying or selling a home.

Buyer review
Superstar Realtor!!!!
almost 2 years ago
Superstar Realtor!!!!

Always kind, patient, and available. Meets obstacles with practical sense and with you, her client in mind. She’s also tech savvy.

Seller review
Unparalleled professionalism and attention to detail
about 2 years ago
Unparalleled professionalism and attention to detail

From our first meeting with Amy, she brought a positive, upbeat and professional attitude. Her ideas for updating, staging and listing were immensely valuable. Living 4 hours away from our home during the listing process, we felt well taken care of during every stage of the process. We would love to work with Amy again!

Buyer review
BEST REALTOR EVER!
about 2 years ago
BEST REALTOR EVER!

Wowzers! Amy is by far one of the best people we have ever worked with. She went above and beyond to meet our needs and to help make our dream a reality! She was patient, kind, and loving through the entire house buying process. We were lucky to work with Amy as teachers, friends, and new home owners. Amy was willing to work around our crazy schedule, take late night phone calls, and was flexible with short notice to view any house we were interested in. She went above and beyond to answer our questions in order to make the process easy and quick. She also worked well with our little guy, who was really struggling with the move and changes. She is definitely on the right career path and anyone would be lucky to buy a home with the assistance of Amy McMahon ❤️

Buyer review
Excellent Communication!
about 2 years ago
Excellent Communication!

Amy provided exceptional service, demonstrated outstanding knowledge, professionalism, and dedication throughout the entire process!

Buyer review
Great pleasurable experience
about 2 years ago
Great pleasurable experience

Amy was very professional and patient. She as a pleasure to work with.

Seller review
Easy, Fast, Simple, Professional and Top Notch
about 2 years ago
Easy, Fast, Simple, Professional and Top Notch

Amy McMahon made the sell of house simple, fast, and easy. In a situation that should have been a very stressful and complicated Amy stepped up and went above and beyond to make the experience one we will always remember as amazing. We cannot thank her enough for seeing the needs of our family and making those happen. She made our home shine and like always is top notch in her field.

Seller review
Exceptional realator!
about 2 years ago
Exceptional realator!

Amy is a delight to work with. Amy walks you through every step of the selling process. She is always available to answer questions. Her knowledge of what the market is and her ability to help make the home exactly what it needs to be to meet the current housing trend is above and beyond. When you work with Amy she makes you feel like you are the only buyer/seller she represents. I can’t say enough about this amazing realator.

Seller review
True Master of her craft
over 2 years ago
True Master of her craft

True professional. Amy’s attention to detail and availability to us as clients was more than one could have expected. Her knowledge of market and its conditions was spot on. Less that 40 hrs on the market with multiple offers to choose from was amazing. Start to finish I couldn’t have asked for someone to worked harder. Forever great full

Buyer review
Personable and Professional
over 2 years ago
Personable and Professional

Amy is an absolute gem of a realtor! From the moment we started working with her, she exuded warmth and professionalism. Her knowledge of the market was truly impressive, and she guided us through every step of the home buying process with grace, understanding, and expertise. Amy listened attentively to our needs and preferences, and she went above and beyond to find us the perfect home. Her communication was always prompt and clear, making us feel supported and informed throughout our journey. Thanks to Amy's dedication and hard work, we are now proud homeowners of the perfect house. We cannot recommend her highly enough!

Seller review
Kindness, understanding and passion
over 2 years ago
Kindness, understanding and passion

Amy is a friend from high school. When we decided to sell our family home, I knew exactly who to call. My brother and I live out of state, and our parents needed a very gentle touch and someone who understands the effects of aging and the emotional impact of selling a home that was ours for nearly 50 years. The way Amy and her family interacted with our parents was far beyond what can be expected. I would recommend Amy for all real estate needs.

49 - 60 of 80
© 2026 RateMyAgent