Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 70 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, empathetic, honest, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Professional People Oriented
10 months ago
Professional People Oriented

Most of our experiences with Amy were pretty much as buying a house goes. Although, our house was on the market slightly longer than we anticipated. Amy was very helpful in setting up additional open houses. Also giving advice on possible things to help sell. Amy was constantly checking on us to see how we were doing. Always very professional and friendly. Which I personally appreciated since I totally understand she is a busy person. Once our house sold there was a slight problem which delayed it a few days. That delay messed up my plans to get help to move. Amy hired a crew who moved us to our new house. This is way above professionalism, it was as if she was a best friend. Anyhoooooo, Thank you Amy…

Buyer review
The Best Realtor
10 months ago
The Best Realtor

From start to finish, Amy was there for us when buying a house. We found our forever home, and thanks to Amy the buying process went very smoothly. I have young children, and they also loved her :) Whenever we were doing house stuff they would always ask, “Is Amy going to be there?” Her communication was on point!! Fast replies and documents always ready for us to go over. She ensured we understood what was happening along the way. Our buying/selling process was definitely a journey, I cannot imagine going through that without her knowledge and help every step of the way. Thank you!! The homes for heroes was also a nice bonus and shows how much she cares about the community.

Seller review
Amazing Experience
10 months ago
Amazing Experience

Amy was absolutely amazing to work with. The quality of her work was top notch in EVERY aspect of the selling process. From start to finish-- Amy took great care of our family. She was punctual, professional, personable, and kind. She always stayed positive and motivated when it seemed like our house would not sell due to a unique house layout. She remained encouraging and worked so hard to help us sell. We were SO impressed by the pictures and videos her and the photographer took of our house. We highly recommend Amy if you need to sell your house! She truly cares about her clients. The homes for heroes was a nice bonus and shows just how much she cares about the community.

Buyer review
Amy made it easy
10 months ago
Amy made it easy

Amy was very easy to work with. I felt comfortable with her and knew that she was interested in finding the best home for me. Using the criteria that I gave her she sent me lots of listings to look through and she quickly set up walk throughs for me when I asked it of her. She handled all of the paperwork like the pro she is and even when we hit some bumps she worked it out for me. After the sale she continued to help me with referrals to other professionals for the work that I needed done on the house to make it my own. I definitely recommend her as a great realtor who knows her market.

Buyer review
The most supportive experience!
10 months ago
The most supportive experience!

Amy is a spectacular support to have during such a stressful and emotional process! She knows what she’s doing and keeps things simple and honest! Could not have asked for a better realtor to help us nab our dream home! Thank you so much, Amy!!

Seller review
Great agent
11 months ago
Great agent

Amy worked hard on selling our property. She lined up folks to help with our move and followed through on every detail. She is an amazing real estate agent and you can be confident she will give her all to help you through the process. Someone of her integrity is hard to find!

Buyer review
Great realtor!!
12 months ago
Great realtor!!

We met Amy after a long search for a home. Even though we had just found the home that we wanted Amy was very professional and explained all of the process that we were going through.She communicated with us all the way through to the closing process. Amy gave us recommendations on individuals who could do some changes to the home that we wanted to make. We had a tough time with our lender and Amy was very supportive during that time. If we had to go through the process again we would definitely contact Amy!

Seller review
Best agent ever
12 months ago
Best agent ever

Our experience selling our house with Amy McMahon was excellent. She communicated very well and kept us updated every step of the way. She priced the house just right. Provided good honest contractors to do required repairs. The entire process was smooth and easy. We highly recommend Amy to anyone buying or selling with confidence.

Buyer review
Simply Amazing
about 1 year ago
Simply Amazing

Amy went above and beyond. Always positive, outgoing, supportive. She answered any and every question. Amy took the time to show me every house I asked her to. If I didn’t like a house it was no big deal, just moved on to the next. Amy gave me the most phenomenal experience in my home buying process. She took all my needs into account and truly listened.

Buyer review
Outstanding
about 1 year ago
Outstanding

Punctual informative knowledgeable responsive dedicated hardworking and amazing realtor

Seller review
Amy was amazing!
about 1 year ago
Amy was amazing!

Within a week of listing our property, Amy had five offers! She was extremely professional, knowledgeable and always ready to help with any questions or concerns we had. Amy went above and beyond in helping us with the sale because we did not live in the area and relied on her to handle the things that we were not able to take care of ourselves. I would highly recommend Amy!

25 - 36 of 70
© 2026 RateMyAgent