Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  4.9  
Amy has 68 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
over 2 years ago
Best Realtor Ever- goes above and beyond!

We cannot even put into words how amazing Amy is. She listens to what you are looking for, extremely knowledgeable of area and was able to advise us on making the best offer we were comfortable with. Her knowledge then extends to the guts of homes from knowing and looking at things that the average person wouldn't see. This is so helpful when buying an older home. She then had the resources to be able to have specialist come to give estimates on possible issue, so that we were fully informed. She was a true advocate for us as the "buyer" to make sure that we were getting the best. We could not have made it through our recent purchase of a second home without her. We will be calling Amy when we are ready to sell our other home!

over 2 years ago
Amy Coy is on top of her game! She led us to our dream home in just one day!

After three showings and none feeling like home to us, Amy found the perfect house for us because of her knowledge of a listing that had just hit the market the very day we were in town to look at homes to purchase! We were the first family to view the home, fell in love with it and with Amy's expertism made the perfect offer and the buyer accepted! She literally held my hands through the buying process. She was always kind and compassionate to my family's special needs. She was always behind the scenes, daily, step by step, until we made it to the settlement table.

over 2 years ago
Great experience from start to finish!!

Could not have asked for a more knowledgeable friendly agent! Enjoyed Amy presence throughout the whole process, with me going in pretty much new to the process, she guiding us along the way, made it enjoyable and stress free!! I highly recommend Amy for any real wastage needs.

almost 3 years ago
Exceptional Realtor!

We recently had the privilege of working with Amy Coy to navigate the real estate market. Amy's ability to communicate effectively was a standout feature of our collaboration. She actively listened to our requirements and concerns, and her responses were always clear, concise, and timely. Whether through phone calls, emails, or in-person meetings, Amy maintained an open channel of communication that fostered trust and confidence. Perhaps what truly stood out to us was Amy's commitment to going the extra mile. She was readily available to address any questions or concerns, no matter how small, and her personalized approach made us feel like a valued client rather than just another transaction. In a realm where market knowledge, communication, and professionalism are essential, Amy sets the bar exceptionally high. Her dedication to delivering a superior client experience is evident. Our experience with Amy has been nothing short of outstanding, and we wholeheartedly recommend her services to anyone in pursuit of a successful real estate endeavor. Thank you, Amy, for your exceptional service!

almost 3 years ago
Top notch agent

Working with Amy was such a pleasure. She had excellent market knowledge, easy to communicate with, and was always available for questions we had. She made it an easy process. She had our home sold in two days!

almost 3 years ago
Best agent on the Eastern Shore & Delaware Beaches!

Amy is a tremendous agent. She is always available, very professional and fun to be around. She worked all hours to help us find and close our first rental property in Ocean City. After sharing details of what we were looking for, we were presented with many options that same day. We were not available to view a potential condo we liked, so Amy took the time to do the walk through for us using FaceTime. She also went to the condo after the purchase to take measurements for us. She goes beyond the call of duty. I would recommend Amy to anyone looking to purchase a home or rental.

almost 3 years ago
Great home buying experience!

Amy was soo knowledgeable just a great, enjoyable, easy experience from start to finish. Highly recommend Amy for any real estate needs.

almost 3 years ago
Working with Amy was a pure joy!

Amy's professionalism, dedication, and knowledge of the housing market was very impressive! She made every step of the buying process stress free, especially being a resident of another state. We highly recommend Amy for finding your next dream home!

almost 3 years ago
I trust Amy. She is committed to helping her clients.

I trust Amy. She committed to meeting her clients interests. She is pleasant, understanding and most of all, patient. She did not come across as pushy at all and was very easy to work with. There seems to be a significant increase in assessments throughout the Ocean City area. To that end, I recommend Amy push as hard as possible to unlock any known details on special assessments. All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed working with Amy

almost 3 years ago
Amy’s review

Amy was very thoughtful and kept in contact with us through the whole process

almost 3 years ago
Excellent Realtor

Amy has been such a pleasure to work with, throughout our whole process of finding our beach place. She is very personable, helpful, responsive, etc. I cannot say enough good things about her. She is very knowledgeable and made the special accomodations to have us come down from PA, for showings. I would recommend her to anyone I know.

almost 3 years ago
Highly Recommend! You'll always feel like her highest priority!

Coming from out-of-state, we chose Amy Coy to help us find our new home based on reviews we read online -- and we were not disappointed! Her responsiveness, professionalism and knowledge of the area markets are exceptional. She arranged her calendar to accommodate our limited visits to the area and always answered our questions and concerns promptly, researching as necessary. She found a home that suited our needs, tight schedule and budget perfectly, and communicated with all parties to bring us to a smooth closing. As a recently retired REALTOR®, I confidently recommend Amy to guide you through the home buying process.

37 - 48 of 68
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent