Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  4.9  
Amy has 68 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
8 months ago
Best first experience selling a home!

The best agent ever, she made selling my first home smooth, fast, and stress-free! She guided me with care and sold my first home with ease. Throughout the process she was knowledgeable, supportive, and dedicated. Amy went above and beyond selling my first home! I’m blessed to have had her guidance through a nerve racking process. She’s trustworthy and will definitely recommend and use her expertise in the future.

8 months ago
More than a 5 star experience

I started my journey with Amy October 2023. Amy strived to find me a home that would suit my needs in an area near my grandbabies. To no fault of hers, I was unable to move forward. Amy has been a confidant and supportive throughout my journey to get back to a place where I was able to have her find the perfect home again. This time there very different circumstances. Once again, Amy put her all into be sure everyone in my family had their needs met. Above and beyond throughout each step! She made herself available for our home inspection, walk-through and closing. 1000% recommend Amy for any and all your real estate needs!

8 months ago
Amy Coy highly recommended for all real estate and moving needs!

Amy provides excellent service. She is very professional and knowledgeable regarding market info. She was available during every step of the buying and moving process. We moved from Arizona to Delaware and Amy was instrumental in offering recommendations in selecting healthcare, lawyers, window treatments, and many other aspects of moving. Amy is very personable and makes you feel like you’re her number 1 priority.

9 months ago
Amy ended up being Amazing Amy

Amy brought the perfect balance of patience and urgency. Her insight proved to be financially beneficial to the sale. She negotiated a favorable, yet fair sale price with three other Sales Agents/Clients. She's connected in the Real Estate community and thoroughly knows the ever-changing market conditions. Working with Amy was a delight. It made what could have been a stressful exercise a stream-lined process from listing to closing. Amy was in charge, and it made a difference. BTW, Amy does a great job on drywall point-up (spackling) - @ no charge! Thanks a ton Amy Bradd

9 months ago
Another great experience

Working with Amy Coy was an absolute pleasure! She helped me purchase a new construction home in Selbyville, DE, and I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. Amy is incredibly knowledgeable about the area and the buying process, which made everything feel smooth and stress-free. She was always supportive, responsive, and truly a go-getter, making sure every detail was taken care of. This is the second home purchase I have made with Amy as my realtor. What really stands out is that Amy isn’t just great at what she does—she’s consistently earned the trust of my family as well. Several of my relatives have also worked with her to purchase their homes in the area, and every single experience has been outstanding. Amy genuinely cares and works tirelessly for her clients, and knows the local market inside and out.

10 months ago
Five stars.!

Amy was the absolute best knowing the market and her communication was also the absolute best. I would recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home.

11 months ago
Best Listing Agent on the Maryland/Delaware Coast

This sale was part of a 1031 rental property exchange, meaning I needed to find an Agent that understood the intricacies of such transactions. Having handled 1031 exchanges in the past, Amy was right on top of what needed to be done. After doing an extensive review of local comps, Amy recommended a fair price for my adorable cottage. While a 2 bedroom, 1 bath house can be a tough sell, Amy was able to locate a buyer and negotiate a fair price for both the buyer and me as the seller. While she worked tirelessly to get the house under contract, her efforts didn’t stop there. She followed through on every action right up until settlement, making the whole experience smooth and stress-free. Not to mention her assistance in helping identify a transfer property. This is my second sale using Amy as my Real Estate Agent. If you are looking to buy or sell Amy is the perfect agent for you, as she was for me. I guarantee you will be glad that you made Amy your Agent of choice!!

about 1 year ago
Amy was so dedicated and professional

Amy is the most pleasant, dedicated and professional realtor you will find. Amy’s knowledge of the area was fantastic. Amy listened to what we wanted and she set up numerous viewings for us as we were only in town for a short time. Last minute requests for viewings we wanted were swiftly scheduled and once we found our property the support continued until settlement. Thank you Amy for such a great house hunting experience and for taking the time to get answers to all our questions. We highly recommend Amy a fantastic realtor.

about 1 year ago
Amy is the best there is!

We worked with Amy to purchase a home as a first time home buyer and Amy went above and beyond in every way possible to make our experience seamless. She was aggressive with scheduling appointments for the homes we wanted to look at. She made sure we were the first to see the home we ended up buying when it went on the market and she had a great strategy for placing our offer which was accepted within 24 hours And then she helped us through every obstacle to make it to the closing table. She made sure we understood all of the fine print, she helped us schedule every inspection and the appraisal. She also worked with the lender and the title company to make sure all deadlines were met. We simply couldn’t have done it without her. She did all of this with so much grace and kindness. If you are looking for a realtor who is going to get the job done for you, and get you into the house of your dreams, Amy is the real deal!

about 1 year ago
Excellent service

Amy is nothing but the best. She would go above and beyond to provide you what you are looking for. Always available for questions and gives you info to need to purchase your dream Home.

over 1 year ago
An expert in the local market!

The experience working with Amy to purchase our first beach property was fantastic! She is extremely knowledgeable to the local market and helped us navigate the search and negotiation/buying process. She also has an excellent network of lenders and other support personnel to assist in completing the transaction.

over 1 year ago
Save some time, look no further!

Look no further, don’t read another review, stop asking your friends, you have found your real estate agent if you have somehow found Amy Coy. Amy brings experience that few agents possess. Her background in construction and years living in the area lend themselves so well to who she is as an agent. Deep knowledge, strategic thinker, promptness, classic professionalism, excellent communication skills, are just a few of the thoughts that come to mind. When we first met with Amy we outline financial and sell timeline challenges and constraints that we knew we had to deal with on this sale. She listened, remembered, proactively engaged, and strategized with us at key junctures of the sale until we all felt comfortable with the direction we were going. We highly recommend Amy, and we wouldn’t consider using another agent for our future real estate needs.

13 - 24 of 68
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent