Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  4.9  
Amy has 72 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
16 days ago
Excellent realtor with extensive knowledge of the area and market trends.

We had an outstanding experience working with Amy Coy to sell our condo in Ocean City, MD. From our first conversation through closing, she was professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely invested in helping us achieve the best possible outcome. Amy provided excellent guidance on pricing, marketing, and the entire process was smooth and stress-free thanks to her attention to detail, strong communication, and expertise in the Ocean City real estate market. We always felt informed and supported and it was clear that she had our best interests in mind every step of the way. Thanks to her hard work and dedication, our condo sold successfully and we couldn't be happier with the experience.

19 days ago
Amy was awesome.

Very pleasant professional and knowledgeable. Awesome experience.

about 1 month ago
Amy Coy excels in client service! She went way above and beyond at every step of the way!

Amy Coy served as our expert guide during our recent home purchase in Ocean Pines, MD. A consummate professional, Amy is extremely knowledgable about the local market and the home buying process. We were WOWED by her stellar client service. She went way above and beyond at every step of the process. Amy was extremely prepared for each of our tours and leveraged technology including an app so that we could see real-time as our appointments were confirmed, making planning much easier. We were on a tight time table and needed to identify a home and close quickly. To accomodate our quick turnaround, Amy was extremely flexible and very generous with her time. We often adjusted tours on the fly when something new and intriguing hit the market. With her strong background in and knowledge about construction, Amy was an ace! She was able to point out potential yellow and red flags at each property we visited. Her assessments about deferred maintenance and likely costs of future maintenance were spot on and absolutely invaluable. Amy was also very responsive to our questions and requests which were plentiful - annoyingly so at times, I'm sure. :-) Very well connected within the local community, Amy was able to provide a plethora of trusted and much appreciated referrals. We feel extremely lucky that we found a Realtor with such extensive expertise in all areas of home buying. As an added bonus, Amy has a great sense of humor and is an absolute pleasure to be around. We thoroughly enjoyed spending time with her. She is a delight! What we value most of all, though, is that it was crystal clear from our very first conversation through our last signature at closing that Amy was most concerned with our satisfaction and ultimate success. There were a few hairy moments along the way when our anxiety got the best of us. Amy was firmly in our corner and wanted us to make the decision that was best for us and our family. We truly couldn't have asked for a better partner!

about 2 months ago
Exceptional experience.

Agent was responsive each time she was contacted. Very knowledgeable on comps in the area. Conducted business in a professional manner.

2 months ago
Professional Realtor Extraordinaire!

Amy went above and beyond for us, consistently keeping us informed about every step in the process of purchasing our home. She was proactive in arranging inspections, follow-up inspections, and necessary repairs, while regularly liaising with lenders and insurance companies. With her background in construction, Amy identified significant issues in the properties we viewed, distinguishing between quality and subpar construction. Despite managing multiple clients, we always felt like her top priority. Her communication skills were exceptional; we received updates from her at all hours, demonstrating her unwavering commitment to our needs, even when dealing with less professional agents on the seller’s side. Amy was assertive and refused to be intimidated or undermined by anyone. She also provided valuable referrals for various professionals, including those for SmartHome and structural engineering for our future needs.

2 months ago
A Wonderful Experience from Start to Finish.....

I cannot say enough good things about Amy. She is flexible when the moment calls for it and tough when the time is right! Amy is a great communicator knowing what to tell a seller and what not to! In my case she kept me informed of the things that were needed for me but also kept a potential last-minute hiccup away from me and handled that herself. I didn't know until closing that anything happened! Her wisdom in handling that situation shows you what kind of realtor Amy will be for you. I recommend Amy as a realtor if you are buying or selling. Her professionalism and kindness makes the experince so much better!

3 months ago
Amy was the perfect agent, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable buying experience!

Amy knows what she is doing and listened to my needs and wants and my concerns. She was always reachable, quick to respond, quick to resolve any issues, and knows her market! Amy strikes that perfect balance between an extremely knowledgeable professional who has a job to do and does it well - and a good friend who listens, helps, and when necessary, acts as a calming force during what at times can be a stressful event. It really was like having a longtime friend assisting with the process.

4 months ago
Excellent at her job!!!!!

I highly recommend Amy to sell your property....the communication, clarification, guidance, recommendations....go above and beyond to sell your property and make ALL involved happy. We did not live where our property was being sold and she took care of everything....I just can't say enough positive things about Amy, she has a wonderful & caring personality that makes you feel very comfortable listing your property with her. She works very hard at her job that she LOVES!

4 months ago
A tough sale in the winter, but Amy nailed it!

Super responsive & available; knew the market and used every tool to make our family home seen; the house showed in the midst of an intense winter event and still had several showings! We had a time crunch and were not living in the area anymore, but it didn’t phase her - she helped us every step of the way! She was very discerning and helped negotiate a great offer for us. We would recommend her to everyone on the shore!

5 months ago
Dream Maker

I had a wonderful experience working with Amy from beginning to end. Not only was she knowledgeable, but I always felt that she had my best interest at heart. She was an effective communicator and guided me through each step of the process to ensure the transaction would be smooth and successful. I highly recommend her for several reasons, including her expertise, knowledge, negotiation skills and her continuous practice of going above and beyond to assist me throughout the whole process!

5 months ago
Top Real Estate Professional I have Ever Worked With!

Amy is a hard working, tireless, real estate expert who helped us sell our home quickly-even in the slow period of late fall/winter. She explained all facets of the process and stayed on top of all details and timelines from listing-providing professional photography that showed our home beautifully-through settlement. She will work hard for you and we will be calling her soon when we buy another beach home! If you want the BEST AGENT-call Amy!

1 - 12 of 72
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent