Amanda's profile

Amanda's reviews

  5  
Amanda has 32 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amanda's qualities as told by our client reviews: attentive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Very professional
20 days ago
Very professional

We can't say enough great things about Amanda. From the moment we met her, we felt she listened and our concerns were addressed. This is our sixth property purchase over the years, and Amanda is the best we have ever worked with. This is despite the fact that she was in the sometimes thorny position of being a dual agent in this transaction. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in Pinellas County.

Seller review
The best person for the job.
21 days ago
The best person for the job.

You can always count on Amanda where decisions are needed, and where help is needed. Amanda shared many tips to help improve our house for sale. It was always a pleasure when we spoke, because no matter what happened she always helped to keep our spirits up. Along with being knowledgeable and friendly real estate agent, We also consider Amanda our friend.

Seller review
Excellent Communicator
29 days ago
Excellent Communicator

It was indeed a pleasant experience dealing with Amanda. She has great market knowledge and very professional.

Seller review
Amazing - top notch realtor!
30 days ago
Amazing - top notch realtor!

Amanda was extremely attentive and knowledgeable of the listings in my area. She did an excellent job of selling our villa and getting us into a house that she was selling. If you are looking to buy or sell a home, please contact Amanda - she will not disappoint!

Seller review
 Amanda’s professionalism and  her attention to detail had our home sold in less than a week!
30 days ago
Amanda’s professionalism and her attention to detail had our home sold in less than a week!

Amanda has a significant knowledge of Pinellas County and in particular, our complex community of Highland Lakes. She provided us with important market information so that we could price our place to sell. She was always available to talk when we had questions and when we needed her negotiate our behalf. I would choose her again and again! Thanks Amanda!

Buyer review
Amanda gets the job done without any pressure
4 months ago
Amanda gets the job done without any pressure

As a retired REALTOR I had high expectations, and Amanda exceeded them. She’s very professional and knowledgeable and most importantly, she listens. I used to teach communications and I would give her an A+! We looked at several homes; changed our minds about the community we were interested in; and tried to negotiate an offer that wasn’t accepted, before finding our dream home and she was very patient and helpful throughout the process. She took us from start to closing seamlessly.

Seller review
Excellent in all ways!
4 months ago
Excellent in all ways!

Amanda was so wonderful in helping us sell our house. She was so kind and patient with my elderly mom, and professional in all ways in getting her house sold!

Seller review
AMANDA IS WONDERFUL!
6 months ago
AMANDA IS WONDERFUL!

Amanda Justus is the best realtor I have worked with. We had a GREAT experience with her from start to finish. She is extremely professional, knowledgeable and honest. From our first meeting she explained everything in detail regarding the sale of our house. She managed our expectations by showing us comps in the area and making sure that we knew it was a buyers market. She regularly held an open house to bring traffic to our house and did and excellent job with our listing and photos. She somehow managed to sell our house during the summer which is the slowest time to sell a home in an over 55 community. Amanda is lovely and kind. She answered all of our questions and always made herself available whenever we needed her. I would highly recommend you call Coldwell banker in Palm Harbor and ask for Amanda Justus to sell your home and thank me later!

Seller review
Upside Experience in A Downward Market - For A Seller
6 months ago
Upside Experience in A Downward Market - For A Seller

We selected Amanda from a pool of well qualified agents because of her demonstrated knowledge of the local market and ability to explain changes in the selling process since our last time more than 25 years ago. Shortly after signing up, sales slowed dramatically, but advice in responding to the changing market brought success. Structuring the counteroffer helped to identify a more qualified buyer and with a much earlier closing. Solid explanations of the various documents from start to finish. Very calm and deliberate through what can be an emotional process. Highly recommend

Buyer review
Concierge service from start to closing, with Professionalism and unmatched communication
6 months ago
Concierge service from start to closing, with Professionalism and unmatched communication

Amanda is extremely patient, a great listener and superb negotiator. One of the nicest people I've met in 74 years and her business skills are evident from the beginning. She is relentless in her efforts to please, and capable of bridging the many gaps that can occur in negotiations. We just couldn't be any happier with Amanda and her team. A sincere thank you would not be adequate, so we give Amanda (7) seven stars that make her light shine brightest in the realtor world. She exhibits all the great traits that every realtor should strive for.

1 - 12 of 32
© 2026 RateMyAgent