Amanda's profile

Amanda's reviews

  5  
Amanda has 41 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amanda's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, attentive, patient, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Amanda provided exceptional, warm service while seamlessly selling my mom's Palm Harbor condo.
17 days ago
Amanda provided exceptional, warm service while seamlessly selling my mom's Palm Harbor condo.

Working with Amanda Justice to sell my mother’s condo in Palm Harbor was an absolute blessing. Amanda brought so much warmth, patience, and genuine care to the entire process, which meant the world to our family. She didn't just treat this as a business transaction—she truly looked out for my mother and kept us completely at ease from start to finish. Her deep knowledge of the local Florida market is impressive, but it’s her kind heart and dedication that truly set her apart. We are so incredibly grateful for everything she did, and we couldn't recommend Amanda more highly!

Buyer review
In depth knowledge of her profession,  always on time, excellent communicator on all platforms
20 days ago
In depth knowledge of her profession, always on time, excellent communicator on all platforms

I met amanda on a Friday and we closed 2 weeks later even though labor day was in the middle of the 2 weeks. That in itself shows her dedication to the people she represents. There are a few outstanding traits that amanda demonstrated during our transaction. Firstly I initially made contact with amanda on a Friday after 5 o clock and she met with me and patiently and professionally answered my questions and concerns. Her knowledge of the real estate industry was superb and correct. In any transaction you are going to have setbacks, nothing goes perfectly , but she overcame these setbacks with a cool dignified professional approach that facilitated my purchase better than I could have hoped for. Finally after closing I was going to have some work done on the property I thoroughly researched contractors and thought I had a solid plan. It fell through, but amanda with her vast knowledge of reliable companies and contractors who offer fair and competitive pricing saved the day. I am glad our business relationship was not just a one time transaction and I look forward to her insightful knowledge in the future. P.S Amanda's use of emoji's is unrivaled in the world of social media according to my 86 year old father. She is awesome

Seller review
Best agent ever
3 months ago
Best agent ever

Amanda was truly the best agent I’ve ever worked with. She is so professional, patient, responsive and I will be referring her to everyone needing a realtor! Amanda went above and beyond from the beginning to the end. So grateful to have had her throughout this whole process!!

Seller review
Professional, Caring, and Truly Outstanding Service
3 months ago
Professional, Caring, and Truly Outstanding Service

Selling my home on June 25th in the Rainbow Springs community was a major life transition for me, and I truly could not have asked for a better realtor than Amanda Justus to guide me through the process. Following the loss of my husband, this was an especially emotional time, and Amanda handled everything with such compassion, patience, and understanding. From start to finish, Amanda demonstrated professionalism, knowledge, and genuine care that went far beyond my expectations. She was incredibly responsive and always took the time to explain each step clearly, which gave me so much peace of mind. Her expertise in pricing, marketing, and negotiating was evident right away, and it made all the difference in getting my home sold smoothly and efficiently. What stood out most to me was Amanda’s kindness and integrity. This wasn’t just a transaction—she truly understood what this sale meant to me. The closing itself went incredibly smoothly, which I deeply appreciated. If you are looking for a realtor who is dedicated, trustworthy, and truly has your best interests at heart, I highly recommend Amanda Justus. I am so grateful for her support and would absolutely work with her again in the future.

Seller review
Excellent agent!
3 months ago
Excellent agent!

Ms. Justus was a pleasure to work with in getting my condo sold. Having someone with such a profound knowledge of the community left me with nothing but confidence that she would handle the whole process perfectly and that she did!

Buyer review
The best there is.
4 months ago
The best there is.

Working with Amanda has been an exceptional experience from start to finish. We stayed in touch on and off for two years, and throughout that entire time she remained consistent, responsive, and fully committed — even when I wasn’t actively searching. That level of dedication is rare. When I decided this spring that it was time to move forward with buying a home, Amanda immediately shifted into high gear. She handled every step with precision and professionalism, staying ahead of potential issues and keeping the entire process organized and efficient. Her communication was clear, her guidance was solid, and her follow‑through was flawless. What stood out most was her integrity. She never pushed, never rushed, and never treated the process like a transaction. She approached it like a partnership — one built on trust, competence, and genuine care for the outcome. If you’re looking for a realtor who is reliable, knowledgeable, and truly committed to doing the job right, Amanda is exactly who you want in your corner.

Seller review
A true professional, Amanda was available, responsive and a trusted partner in the entire process.
4 months ago
A true professional, Amanda was available, responsive and a trusted partner in the entire process.

I chose Amanda for her market knowledge and her presentation during our first meeting. She came prepared to show me how she presents homes to sell and what to expect during the process. I was especially impressed with the booklet she compiles for interested buyers, which helps answer many questions and provides buyers with something to take away at an Open House. I believe that the marketing piece was a big help in the quick sale of my home. I was a first-time home seller and had a lot of questions. She answered all of them knowledgeably which helped me make the right decisions about the sales process. Amanda is calm and methodical. She was so easy to work with, and available to answer questions and "take care of business" from start to finish. I wasn't pushed to an assistant; she worked with me the entire time. I appreciated that type of personal service. Another important fact I considered was that I researched how many homes Amanda sold in the past year. This is not a part time job, nor is she just starting out. She knows the business and that is what I was looking for in a realtor. Knowledge and experience. I got that 100 percent and am very happy that I chose her as my agent.

Seller review
Quick sale
4 months ago
Quick sale

I had a short time to sell my home and Amanda made it happen. I chose Amanda because of her knowledge and experience in Highland Lakes. She was always responsive to my many questions and concerns. I couldn't have done it without her.

Seller review
Amanda is as smart, responsive, helpful and "above-and-beyond" as any agent I've ever worked with.
5 months ago
Amanda is as smart, responsive, helpful and "above-and-beyond" as any agent I've ever worked with.

Amanda knows the Highland Lakes area so well! We used another real estate agent for about a year, and she was just fine, but Amanda took it to another level. To get our home sold quickly, she recommended changes to the staging on the inside, fixed the front/outside to make it more attractive, marketed aggressively, and held multiple open houses. Beyond her selling skill, Amanda was ALWAYS available for questions, input, and updates. We would 1000% recommend Amanda to anyone who wanted a clean, clear, personal, and quick selling process. :)

Buyer review
Very professional
6 months ago
Very professional

We can't say enough great things about Amanda. From the moment we met her, we felt she listened and our concerns were addressed. This is our sixth property purchase over the years, and Amanda is the best we have ever worked with. This is despite the fact that she was in the sometimes thorny position of being a dual agent in this transaction. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in Pinellas County.

Seller review
The best person for the job.
6 months ago
The best person for the job.

You can always count on Amanda where decisions are needed, and where help is needed. Amanda shared many tips to help improve our house for sale. It was always a pleasure when we spoke, because no matter what happened she always helped to keep our spirits up. Along with being knowledgeable and friendly real estate agent, We also consider Amanda our friend.

1 - 12 of 41
© 2026 RateMyAgent