Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
177 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, friendly, proactive, hard-working, responsive, attentive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Very responsive and helpful
5 days ago
Very responsive and helpful

Very responsive and helpful in the purchase of our shop and offices.

Natasha Johns

Natasha Johns

  5   (14 reviews)
Seller review
Great Communicator and Marketing Plan
5 days ago
Great Communicator and Marketing Plan

Matthew was the third realtor that I interviewed to market and sell my recreational hunting property and truly understood the intrinsic value of a fully turnkey hunting property ready for the next owner to take over and start hunting this deer season. He presented the best well laid out marketing plan of any of the realtors and his energy and enthusiasm was apparent from the start. He understood the hard work I put into developing the property and my love for the property and was able to match me with a liked minded buyer. He did a great job of pre-screening buyers, so not to waste my time or his. It was truly a pleasure working with Matthew and he kept me informed every step of the way. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking to sell a property whether it's land, home or a business.

The COREY Team

The COREY Team

  5   (59 reviews)
Seller review
Went over and above my expectations
6 days ago
Went over and above my expectations

Vicky was very knowledgeable and professional. Easy to talk to and get to know. Always available to answer my questions. Would highly recommend her for future realtor needs.

Vicky Speer

Vicky Speer

  5   (29 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent performance
7 days ago
Excellent performance

Working with Susan is a perfect mix of professionalism and personal. I trust her advise. She is quick to respond. She respects our expectations and helps us achieve our sale goals. We live in a different state so she set us up with our local title agency to make it easy for us. Every thing went great! It was our fastest sale so far!

Susan Wykoff

Susan Wykoff

  5   (20 reviews)
Seller review
Matthew Corey is the most down to earth realtor I have ever met. He is genuine.
8 days ago
Matthew Corey is the most down to earth realtor I have ever met. He is genuine.

We had 40 acres of recreational hunting/camping. It took a special buyer to keep the property as such. Matthew had an amazing video made of thd property! I honestly believe that is what sold it, along with Matthew's Hoosier hospitality and his down to earth personality. He truly enjoys interacting with others.

The COREY Team

The COREY Team

  5   (59 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent communicator, with awesome negotiating skills!
10 days ago
Excellent communicator, with awesome negotiating skills!

Natasha knows the market, up to date on technology. So buying and selling, you have fast, talented, knowledgeable, pretty and sweet lady, I might add. That does a remarkable job when negotiations are vitally important. Will continue to use Natasha Johns for all our real estate business.

Natasha Johns

Natasha Johns

  5   (14 reviews)
Seller review
Pleasant Experience.
11 days ago
Pleasant Experience.

Matt Corey was very helpful and knowledgeable in helping us sell my Mothers home. Matt was always quick to respond to messages and phone calls and was honest through out the whole process. Working with Matt Corey was definitely a Pleasure and we highly recommend Matt !!!

The COREY Team

The COREY Team

  5   (59 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional Realtor! Even Better Person!!!
21 days ago
Exceptional Realtor! Even Better Person!!!

We absolutely loved working with Matt! From the very beginning, he made us feel completely comfortable and never like we were “just clients.” He genuinely treated us like family friends, and that made the entire selling process so much easier and more enjoyable. Matt was always great with communication, keeping us informed and answering our questions whenever we needed him. His knowledge of the local market was incredibly helpful, and we always felt confident in his advice and guidance. He also did an amazing job negotiating and making sure our best interests were always a priority. What we appreciated most was how personable, trustworthy, and genuine he was throughout the entire process. He truly went above and beyond for us, and we always felt like he cared about finding the right outcome for our family, not just closing a deal. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor and would highly recommend Matt to anyone looking for someone knowledgeable, professional, honest, and genuinely caring. He’s more than a realtor, he’s someone we’re grateful to now consider a family friend!

The COREY Team

The COREY Team

  5   (59 reviews)
Seller review
Vicki is professional and always dependable.
26 days ago
Vicki is professional and always dependable.

Vicki is so professional. She always gets right back with you if you have any questions. You can depend on her to do her best with your transactions, keep you informed, and she follows through with every thing she does. She has been a lifesaver for our family and also for our businesses in the past. We truly appreciate the care she takes.

Vicky Speer

Vicky Speer

  5   (29 reviews)
Seller review
They are the best that I know of!!!!!
27 days ago
They are the best that I know of!!!!!

She and her helper/ partner!!! Knows what they are doing!!!!

Natasha Johns

Natasha Johns

  5   (14 reviews)
1 - 12 of 177
Williams Carpenter Realtors
Contact Williams Carpenter Realtors
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent