Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
122 reviewsacross 44 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, empathetic, patient, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Phillip Is Top-Notch!
about 5 years ago
Phillip Is Top-Notch!

Philip Donahoo successfully represented my relocation to the area, assisting in finding and closing on our family home. He executed each part of the transaction seamlessly, and his deep market knowledge and advice were fantastic! He was patient and took the time to understand needs, and was along for every step of the way in working through the offer, due diligence period, and an easy close. I am delighted with the entire experience and highly recommend Philip!

Philip Donahoo
Seller review
Peace of mind in a time of stress
about 5 years ago
Peace of mind in a time of stress

Amy has been the rock I needed to sell my townhome while helping a loved one through heart surgery and recovery at the same time. She was there every step of the way to be sure that the process went smoothly, I felt comfortable, and make sure every “i” was dotted and every “t” was crossed. She even went out of her way to meet with a plumber to resolve a quick issue when I couldn’t be there myself! Truly above and beyond while maintaining the highest level of professionalism and compassion. I am thrilled to be working with her on the purchase of our next home and would highly recommend her to everyone!

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Extremely helpful, reliable, and trustworthy for First Time Homebuyers
about 5 years ago
Extremely helpful, reliable, and trustworthy for First Time Homebuyers

Amy was phenomenal! We were first time homebuyers and didn't always know what questions to ask. She was always two steps ahead of us guiding us throughout the entire process. She gave suggestions were needed and always made sure we were in agreement and understood things before making any decision. She was always quick to answer our calls, texts, and emails - communication is so important during such a huge process and Amy is and was a 10! I know we would not have been able to close on our dream home without Amy's help. She was truly a blessing for us and our family. We are very grateful for her services and for her friendship. I would highly recommend Amy Donahoo to anyone looking to purchase a home.

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
THE Agent (Amy Donahoo)
about 5 years ago
THE Agent (Amy Donahoo)

I’ll tell you this, Amy is a different type of agent. Someone that I honestly felt was looking out for us like a family member. We were so lucky to be assigned to her because she was a leader, mother, coach, etc through this whole process. The number 1 thing we valued was her honesty and not being afraid to speak up. There is nothing at all that makes me feel as though she didn’t have our best interest at heart because I was just blown away by how she conducts business. Being a Real Estate Agent to me needs to be more of a human that does Real Estate and that’s who Amy is. We are thankful for Amy and truly know there couldn’t be another agent to provide the service Amy did. Honestly, we didn’t have the words to describe this experience but we hope you see the value of Amy Donahoo.

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Very informative, friendly, & patient. She knew exactly what I wanted...
over 5 years ago
Very informative, friendly, & patient. She knew exactly what I wanted...

Amy was match made in heaven! She came to be my realtor via a program with my lender and I couldn't have asked for a better person. She was patient with me & my questions. I'm a research type of person but Amy took the time to educate me on things to look for & take into consideration that I didn't even think of and found me the perfect place. She is a wonderful listener, letting you think out your thoughts and providing unbias perspective made me feel completely comfortable & confident in her abilities. She will not disappoint!

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Exceptional!!!
It was such a pleasure working with Philip Donahoo, this is my 1st time buying a home
over 5 years ago
Exceptional!!! It was such a pleasure working with Philip Donahoo, this is my 1st time buying a home

Exceptional!!! It was such a pleasure working with Philip Donahoo, this is my 1st time buying a home and being new to the home buying process was very overwhelming and Phillip assisted a lot in making this process a little more manageable, he was very knowledgeable, kind and professional, he always had answers for me, he did an excellent job helping me get everything completed in a timely manner, we went from the offer to closing in 4 weeks. Philip was incredibly patient and provided a lot guidance and support in several multi offers situations. Phillip exceeded every expectation I had in a realtor in a professional matter and I cannot express enough how he came through for me time and time again until the end of my closing, I truly recommend his services, he is great and I know you would not regret having him and his Red wagon team as your Realtor.

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Exceptional!!!
over 5 years ago
Exceptional!!!

It was such a pleasure working with Philip Donahoo, this is my 1st time buying a home and being new to the home buying process was very overwhelming and Phillip assisted a lot in making this process a little more manageable, he was very knowledgeable, kind and professional, he always had answers for me, he did an excellent job helping me get everything completed in a timely manner, we went from the offer to closing in 4 weeks. Philip was incredibly patient and provided a lot guidance and support in several multi offers situations. Phillip exceeded every expectation I had in a realtor in a professional matter and I cannot express enough how he came through for me time and time again until the end of my closing, I truly recommend his services, he is great and I know you would not regret having him and his Red wagon team as your Realtor.

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Helpful, Attentive, Honest
We are first time homebuyers and pretty inexperienced
over 5 years ago
Helpful, Attentive, Honest We are first time homebuyers and pretty inexperienced

Helpful, Attentive, Honest We are first time homebuyers and pretty inexperienced. Philip helped walk us through the entire process and answered all of our questions without making us feel silly. Over a period of 3 months, Philip and Amy visited 21 homes with us and helped us put in 4 offers. They were patient, helpful, and always very responsive. Easy to get a hold of and schedule showings quickly. Our 4th offer was accepted, and Philip had contacts for every step while we were under contract - lenders, attorneys, inspectors, contractors, etc. He was transparent & honest, provided solid guidance, but never pressured us - we knew each decision was ours alone. We are happy to be done with closing, couldn't have gotten through the process without Philip & Amy.

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Helpful, Attentive, Honest
over 5 years ago
Helpful, Attentive, Honest

We are first time homebuyers and pretty inexperienced. Philip helped walk us through the entire process and answered all of our questions without making us feel silly. Over a period of 3 months, Philip and Amy visited 21 homes with us and helped us put in 4 offers. They were patient, helpful, and always very responsive. Easy to get a hold of and schedule showings quickly. Our 4th offer was accepted, and Philip had contacts for every step while we were under contract - lenders, attorneys, inspectors, contractors, etc. He was transparent & honest, provided solid guidance, but never pressured us - we knew each decision was ours alone. We are happy to be done with closing, couldn't have gotten through the process without Philip & Amy.

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Relocated with ease
over 5 years ago
Relocated with ease

Amy did a great job in navigating our first home purchase in a new state and new town. We were able to house hunt just in one weekend and Amy made sure we could see every home we wanted and suggested a few that fit our vibe. She was helpful in pointing out aspects of each home that we didn't consider and helped us realize what would work best for our lifestyle. Amy was professional, friendly, and made the process relatively stress free. She was readily available to answer any questions we had and did a great job of keeping us in the loop of what was going on throughout the purchase process. The communication was AWESOME and much appreciated since we were buying from out of state. And of course Amy is just a very kind person and you can tell she loves what she does and is a pleasure to be around. 10/10 recommend!

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Amazing Agents!
over 5 years ago
Amazing Agents!

We worked with Phillip and Amy in 2018 to sell our home when we moved out of state. When we decided to move back we came back to them. Amy spent endless hours to make sure we saw everything we wanted, including previewing houses before we arrived in town. She dedicated a whole week to our home search. Once we were able to narrow it down Phillip came out to give us a keen eye on any problems we could anticipate on the inspections. He guided us through negotiations, inspections, and closing. When you work with Phillip and Amy you get an amazing team that can do it all!

Philip Donahoo
Seller review
Philip was the most thorough and responsive realtor I've worked with.
over 5 years ago
Philip was the most thorough and responsive realtor I've worked with.

Philip did such a great job getting our house sold. He priced the house higher than we expected and it sold in 2 days. The negotiation went smoothly and he explained the different scenarios clearly. My only complaint is when our house didn't appraise. I wish he could've done more about that. Perhaps offer to take a hit on his commission since we had to take a $7K hit off the original offer. Overall, we were pleased with our experience with Philip and would recommend him to others.

Philip Donahoo
61 - 72 of 122
The Red Wagon Team at Compass
Contact The Red Wagon Team at Compass
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent