Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
122 reviewsacross 44 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, empathetic, patient, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Knowledgeable, professional and responsive
5 months ago
Knowledgeable, professional and responsive

Phillip Donahoo has provided us with excellent service during extremely difficult and stressful life situations. We appreciate his guidance through the selling process from start to finish. Highly recommended him and his wife, Amy, to anyone in need of excellent realtors.

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Excellent
10 months ago
Excellent

As an out of state buyer with limited time to house look when I was in NC, Wake Forest area, Philip was prepared when we met. He had an information file containing all the pertinent data on each house I was to visit. Philip checked my required boxes & now I’m a very happy homeowner enjoying quite country living in Youngsville, NC.

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Amy is simply the best!
11 months ago
Amy is simply the best!

Working with Amy was truly one of the best parts of our home-buying experience. From the very beginning, she was warm, kind, and incredibly knowledgeable. She took the time to really get to know us — not just what we were looking for in a house, but who we are as a family. What meant so much to us was how amazing she was with our kids. She would play with them and keep them entertained while we toured homes, which made everything so much easier and more enjoyable. Amy was also incredibly flexible and understanding of our busy schedules. She didn’t hesitate to show the same home to my husband and me on different days so we could each see it in person. Her communication was always clear and timely, and we never felt out of the loop. During negotiations, Amy was calm, confident, and truly had our best interests at heart. It’s easy to see why everyone who knows her loves her — she has a special way of making you feel supported, heard, and cared for throughout the entire process. We are so grateful for everything Amy did for us and would recommend her wholeheartedly to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Wow, that was easy
11 months ago
Wow, that was easy

I appreciated Amy for her expertise and for being so flexible with her timing. I mostly appreciated her sense of guidance as I wanted to move quickly and had a number of items I wanted on my wish list. She found my new home and highlighted it quickly - why didn't I look at the notes! When I finally came back around to it it turned out to be the perfect fit.

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Amy is GREAT!
12 months ago
Amy is GREAT!

Amy made the whole process easy. I would highly recommend

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Superb experience finding my horse property
12 months ago
Superb experience finding my horse property

The Red Wagon team is extraordinary. You’re missing out if they’re not your agent. Amy was my buyer’s agent as I sought a property suitable for my horse business and my home. Amy spent the time to understand my dreams and requirements deeply. At crucial decision points, she reflected my vision to me, which gave me clarity and a sense of resolve. She was patient, flexible, and supportive as I cast a wide net in all directions from the Raleigh-Durham airport, encompassing vacant land, rural residential homes, and existing farms. Amy's humble about her impressive knowledge of Triangle real estate, from noticing home inspection details to understanding neighborhood characteristics, such as local attractions relevant to me and my potential horse coaching guests. Learning is one of her superpowers. Anything she hadn’t encountered, she investigated along with me. The Compass app made it easy to stay in touch and act quickly on new listings. Philip’s valuation research proved invaluable as I prepared to make an offer.

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Exceptional Service & Expertise from Amy Donahoo
12 months ago
Exceptional Service & Expertise from Amy Donahoo

Working with Amy was an absolute pleasure from start to finish! Her in depth knowledge of the area helped us find the perfect home in a community that fits our lifestyle. She provided insightful recommendations and suggestions that truly guided us through the buying process with confidence. One of the many standout qualities of Amy was her organization and efficiency—she kept our home search on track with a well-planned schedule, making sure every showing was tailored to our needs. Not only was she highly professional, but she also brought a warm and welcoming personality that made the entire experience enjoyable. We couldn’t be more grateful for her expertise and dedication in helping us find our dream home. If you're looking for a real estate agent who is knowledgeable, reliable, and truly cares about her clients, we highly recommend Amy!

Amy Donahoo
Seller review
Repeat Customers
12 months ago
Repeat Customers

This is the second time we have sold a home with Philip and Amy and we were thrilled to work with them again. They really are the perfect team and as their client, you get the benefit of a team approach. Philip and Amy each lean into their strengths to bring you the best plan to sell or purchase a home. We worked with them for several months leading up to listing our home and discussed the best options for timing, pricing and marketing of our home. No one can predict the future but they were spot on and really helped set expectations for us. Additionally, they were extremely professional but shared their opinions and our options when requested. Philip and Amy communicated often and ensured we understood the process and where we were in the process. They were accessible and available as needed to help the transaction run as smoothly as possible. We have opted not to buy something else for now but will work with Philip and Amy in the future should our plans change. We highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell.

Philip Donahoo
Seller review
Repeat Customer Always!
about 1 year ago
Repeat Customer Always!

Phillip and Amy are the best duo. They make the process so easy, respond to questions, and were with us all along the way. We have bought and sold with them, and we will always be back!

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Beyond Excellent
about 1 year ago
Beyond Excellent

Working with Amy was absolutely fantastic. It's clear that Amy has been doing this for a long time and cares about those she represents as a realtor. We planned a trip a few months in advance to North Carolina to see homes. As soon as we arrived on new years day, she was taking us around to see homes. Each day spent with her was meticulously planned out and we were able to see a wide range of homes based on our budget. When it came time to purchase one of the homes, she was knowledgeable and let us know the next steps to take any time we had a question. She was also on our side and willing to negotiate just about anything we wanted with the sellers. With Amy, not only do you get a professional who does things right, but you also get someone with infectious laughter and a clear passion for connecting people to what could be their forever home. I cannot recommend her enough! We really felt like we were taken care of.

Amy Donahoo
Buyer review
Exceptional Service!!
over 1 year ago
Exceptional Service!!

We recently had the pleasure to work with Philip as our realtor, it was an unforgettable experience. From the moment we met, he went above and beyond to ensure we were comfortable and satisfied with every house visit. He answered all our questions and he gave us his honest opinion based on his experience and knowledge. Thank you Philip. We highly recommended his services.

Philip Donahoo
Buyer review
Awesome!!!
over 1 year ago
Awesome!!!

Amy was awesome !! Knowledgeable, friendly and professional !!She's great at communicating. She did her best to respond to any questions or concerns I had !!! I was really impressed how quick she found me the perfect house( I was in Maine and moved to NC) made an offert and closed in two weeks !!!!

Amy Donahoo
1 - 12 of 122
The Red Wagon Team at Compass
Contact The Red Wagon Team at Compass
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent