Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
204 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, dedicated, reliable, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Crystal Gay answered my questions with prompt responses
over 1 year ago
Crystal Gay answered my questions with prompt responses

I began to look at retiring in Orofino, Idaho, in January 2025. I approached Crystal then while looking at number of available homes. I returned in April looking again with Crystal's expertise. This time I found what I was looking for with Crystal's help. She was able to help me through the whole home purchase process. She can help you through a positive home purchase as well.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, Knowledgeable, Hard Working, and Friendly
over 1 year ago
Professional, Knowledgeable, Hard Working, and Friendly

We were fortunate to have Crystal represent us in the sale of our property. She stayed in contact throughout the entire process, worked hard to make certain to be available for appointments or questions. From our initial meeting and walkthrough of the property to the timeliness of the listing going live, to closing, she went well above and beyond what any other Realtor we have used has done for us. We can highly recommend Crystal Gay for any Real Estate questions or needs you might have. Thank you

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
Easy to work with.
over 1 year ago
Easy to work with.

Keith kept us informed and was very prompt in selling our property.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Efficient and Professional
over 1 year ago
Efficient and Professional

Keith was easy to work with and helped us with each step of the process. He was flexible and customer focused. We would definitely work with him again!

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Buyer review
Very impressive response time and Crystal was very professional.
over 1 year ago
Very impressive response time and Crystal was very professional.

I was very impressed with how easy it was to get an appointment with Crystal to show us this property. She was very flexible with scheduling. Whenever we had a question that she did not know the answer for she went out of her way to get us the answers we needed, and it did not take her long to respond with the answer. I was also impressed with Crystal's knowledge of the area we were looking to buy in. That helped tremendously. I highly recommend Crystal Gay as your realtor.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
Transaction
over 1 year ago
Transaction

Excellent experience very easy transaction

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
Honest and Knowledgeable
over 1 year ago
Honest and Knowledgeable

We appreciated his knowledge in being able to work out an agreement that was good for us and the buyer. If we had any questions or concerns, his promptness in responding was timely.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Best Agent Ever!
over 1 year ago
Best Agent Ever!

I have had the privilege of working with Crystal for the sale of my home. It truly was a privilege. She took so much time to walk me through the whole process from start to finish throughly explaining every part of every detail. Always was so prompt to respond to any and all messages. Literally holding my hand and giving me her professional and honest advice. I would recommend her to my family and friends. In the future she is the only one I would want to work with. I truly appreciated the mere fact that she put me and what was best for me above all! I thank her for all of her dedication and hard work. Crystal has an attitude of lets make this happen and she follows through with that make it happen positivity during the entire process. She is patient, kind, funny and truly absolutely wonderful to have on your side looking out for what you need! Again it was a fabulous experience and it was my pleasure meeting her and working with her. If you are looking for a realtor don’t look any longer you have found the right one with Crystal. On a personal note, thank you so much for your kindness and all of your patience and always keeping a lookout for my best interest it was my privilege working with you Crystal!:-)

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Buyer review
No one better to help with your real estate transaction!
over 1 year ago
No one better to help with your real estate transaction!

From the first time we contacted Keith, to the closing of the sale, he was not only very professional, but caring, knowledgeable, and thoughtful of us and our needs. He responded within minutes most of the time and always let us know how things were going. We not only gained a great real estate agent, but a wonderful friend as well! We would never use anyone else for our real estate needs!

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Buyer review
Very Helpful for a First Time Buyer
almost 2 years ago
Very Helpful for a First Time Buyer

Keith helped me a lot through this process. It was incredibly stressful for me, but he was with me the whole way and the decision was always mine. Support but no pressure and always in touch when I needed information.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Buyer review
She was amazing and made the transaction seamless.
almost 2 years ago
She was amazing and made the transaction seamless.

Crystal as a dream to work with. She made recommendations and accommodations. Was very truthful and upfront. I will definitely work with her again.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
85 - 96 of 204
© 2026 RateMyAgent