Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
175 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, pleasant, reliable, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Awesome as usual!
over 1 year ago
Awesome as usual!

This was my second transaction with Keith. The 1st time was to buy a home earlier this year and this time was to sell the house I moved out of. He knows the area and market well. He quickly replies to messages and phone calls. He's my friend and go-to realtor.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
Seller review
Great job
almost 2 years ago
Great job

Kieth is that elusive realtor that goes the extra mile. Had dealings with him through my drilling business, could tell he was who I needed to get some land sold. Yep he got it sold quickly. 100% recommended.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
Seller review
She is very good at her job.
almost 2 years ago
She is very good at her job.

She took care of everything long distance for me,the price was right and sold quickly.I would reccomend her any day.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (34 reviews)
Seller review
She works very hard and is very competent
almost 2 years ago
She works very hard and is very competent

Crystal Gay is a very motivated real estate agent. She helped me around all the corners of this sale. I would recommend her to be your agent. Always returns calls and messages and just a great person to deal with.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (34 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent experience!
almost 2 years ago
Excellent experience!

Keith is extremely knowledgeable, caring, and compassionate. His expertise was invaluable and his patience never-ending as we looked at one property after another over a long period of time. He was generous with his time and never rushed us but, instead, answered every one of our questions and would even find an answer afterwards if there was one he didn't know (which was very seldom). We are forever thankful to Keith and highly recommend him!

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
Seller review
Knowledgeable and Nice!
almost 2 years ago
Knowledgeable and Nice!

Excellent communication, smart and savvy person with a kind demeanor to put us at ease, always felt Crystal was in our corner. Would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a great agent.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (34 reviews)
Seller review
Sincerely grateful to Keith Nichols!
almost 2 years ago
Sincerely grateful to Keith Nichols!

As appointed representative for my uncle's estate, selling my uncle's home was an emotionally challenging experience. Keith eased most of the many (and I do mean many) challenges that arose during the process. He responded to my messages/calls promptly, answered concerns quickly, was professional, but easy to communicate with. I highly recommend Keith Nichols as a trusted agent.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
Seller review
Superb Negotiator
almost 2 years ago
Superb Negotiator

Because I was not in Idaho, I really appreciated Crystal’s willingness to negotiate alternative options for the buyers’ requests. She communicated with us quickly and offered some needed help. I highly recommend Crystal!

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (34 reviews)
Seller review
Highly Recommend!
almost 2 years ago
Highly Recommend!

Keith was very helpful in every step of the process when selling our home. He was always available to answer any questions we had and reached out often to update us on how things were going. This was our first time selling a home and he made the entire process so easy and stress-free. Thank you again Keith!

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
Buyer review
Never a regret
almost 2 years ago
Never a regret

I spent almost a decade managing a real estate office and have worked with agents at all levels, so I am a pretty tough critic. We were selling our house out of state and moving to Idaho. Keith could have represented our sale and our purchase, but was forthcoming in telling us that not being there would have been a disservice to our timeline and goals. He helped us secure our selling agent, who was another complete professional. When we went to purchase our home, he was on every detail of the transaction, including ensuring the selling agent was completing their side to move us to closing as quickly and accurately as possible. His advice along the way has been not only professional but accurate. He knows the area, the benefits and challenges of each area, trusted local services if you are building, repairing or restoring. He is easy to talk to, insightful, quick and available. He is not a part-time agent. He is in it for and with you! My husband and I would recommend Keith Nichols to anyone looking to conduct a real estate transaction, whether selling or buying. You will never regret the decision to work with him.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
Buyer review
More like family
about 2 years ago
More like family

Our experience with Keith was amazing throughout the entire process. Even when we hit some snags Keith worked hard to do anything he could to help.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
Seller review
Above and Beyond Service
about 2 years ago
Above and Beyond Service

We found Keith online when, due to a death in the family, it became necessary to sell an out of state property. We found Keith to be very knowledgeable and professional. He provided excellent guidance through the listing and sale process, taking our thoughts and concerns into consideration. Since we live about 500 miles away, he graciously looked after the home which was especially important during the winter months. He wore many hats during his time working for us in order to get the job at hand completed. We could not be more grateful. We recommend Keith wholeheartedly.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (126 reviews)
85 - 96 of 175
© 2026 RateMyAgent